How to Stay Friends When Your Parenting Styles Are Totally Different
Saturday at the playground, Beth’s son Owen grabbed the red truck out of my daughter’s hands. My daughter started to wail, the loud kind that makes other parents glance over. I crouched down beside her. “He was playing with it first, sweetheart. Let’s wait.” She was not interested in waiting.
Beth was already moving. “Owen, we don’t grab. That’s not how we share. You need to sit out for two minutes.” She took his arm and set him on the grass. He cried. My daughter stopped crying and watched, fascinated. I felt my face go warm, the same way it does when someone is polite to me in public and I know the person underneath is annoyed.
Our kids are the same age, but Beth and I have never parented the same way. She uses timers, natural consequences, and a calm voice that somehow still gets obeyed. I talk things through and offer feelings words and occasionally let snack time happen twenty minutes late because we got caught up examining a bug. Before we had kids, this didn’t matter. We were the kind of friends who could text each other at eleven at night about a strange dream or call to say, “I’m at the store, do you need anything?” Then we became mothers, and suddenly every playdate became a tiny mirror showing me what I wasn’t doing.
I don’t think Beth meant to judge me. She never said anything. But after that moment with the truck, I noticed a shift. When her son got too rough with my daughter, she would step in before I had a chance to decide whether I should step in at all. When I let the kids have one more episode of something while I finished packing up, she would check the time and politely start pulling out her son’s jacket. I started to feel like I was being managed. And I started to pull back.
We stopped doing Saturday park meetups for a while. I told myself it was fine, that parenting was hard enough without feeling watched. But the real problem was that I missed her. Not the mom version of her I kept comparing myself to. Just her, the friend who knew exactly which kind of sandwich I would order and still liked me.
The first time we talked about it, we were in her kitchen and the kids were playing in the backyard. She said, almost out of nowhere, “I worry you think I’m too strict.”
I laughed, because it was so close to what I’d been thinking. “I worry you think I’m too lenient,” I said.
We both sort of shrugged. Then I said, “I don’t know how to be around you when you’re doing things so differently. It makes me doubt myself.”
She looked at me for a moment. “I doubt myself too. I just do it quickly and then regret it later.”
That conversation didn’t fix anything. But it helped me see that the differences between us weren’t about right and wrong. Beth grew up in a house with six kids and a lot of noise. Rules were a comfort. They kept things from falling apart. I grew up with parents who argued and then never talked about it, so I learned to read every mood and over-explain every feeling. We were both doing exactly what our brains thought would keep our kids safe. We just had different ideas of what that looked like in practice.
The thing that saved the friendship, though, isn’t that we finally agreed. We didn’t. We still don’t. What saved it was that we learned to be clear about who was in charge of what.
If we’re together and her son is the one who needs disciplining, she handles it. I don’t hover. I don’t offer a gentler alternative. I might step in if one of them is physically hurting the other, but otherwise I let her do her thing. And when it’s my daughter in trouble, she lets me handle it. She doesn’t swoop in with a time-out or a lecture. She turns to the window, or she picks up a book and pretends she’s not listening. That took practice. The first few times, I could tell she was dying inside. But she gave me room anyway.
That became the unspoken rule: the parent whose child is involved makes the call. It sounds simple, but it means having to stay quiet when you’re sure your friend is making a mistake.
I had a chance to practice this at a children’s museum last month. My daughter refused to put on her shoes near the exit. Beth’s son was already standing by the door, waiting. Beth said, “We have to go in five minutes, so she needs to decide if she wants shoes or boots.” I watched my daughter stand there in her socks, arms crossed. Beth said nothing. I let her handle it, even though my hand was itching to scoop up my daughter and carry her out with the shoes in my pocket. My daughter eventually picked the boots, mostly because she knew Beth wasn’t going to budge. On the drive home, my daughter said, “Miss Beth is bossy.”
“No,” I said. “She’s just good at making decisions.”
After that, we started building in small strategies. We stopped meeting for anything too complicated. A playground, not a whole afternoon at someone’s house. That way, if the styles collided, the answer could just be “we’re leaving soon” rather than a long debate about what the kids should eat for lunch. We also started checking in before any big outing: “Should I pack snacks, or are you doing food?” It sounds boring, but it worked. So many arguments between friends come from unspoken expectations about what the day will look like.
Another thing we do is not to undermine one another in front of the kids. That doesn’t mean we agree. It means we save it for later. The other night, after Beth left, my daughter said, “Owen doesn’t like when his mom says no.” I told her, “Different families have different rules. You don’t have to like them, but you do have to be respectful.” When Beth and I text later, I told her about it. She said, “Thanks for telling him when you disagreed earlier.” That was a small thing, but it made me realize how easy it can be to stay close when you don’t force the friendship to be the same as a co-parenting partnership.
We’re not co-parenting. That’s an important distinction. We are friends who happen to be raising kids at the same time. If I need someone to tell me whether the kids should be in swimming lessons, I don’t ask Beth; I ask a parent who thinks the way I do. Beth does the same. We rely on each other for conversation, company, and someone who remembers what we were like before we had tiny tyrants demanding juice. We don’t rely on each other for parenting advice. It seems obvious now, but it took me a long time to understand that just because you love someone doesn’t mean you should want their input on every part of your life.
There are still moments when I think she’s a little rigid, and she probably thinks I’m a little careless. Last weekend, her son fell off a slide and she brushed him off and told him to get back on. I would have held him for ten minutes. But he went up again, and he was fine. She still limits screen time on vacations. I let my daughter watch a cartoon at a restaurant while I finished my coffee. We aren’t changing each other.
But here’s what has changed: I trust that what works for my friend works for her family. And she seems to trust that what works for me works for mine. We don’t say that every time we see each other. We just act like it. We laugh when the kids do something weird, and we both reach for the chips at the same time, and sometimes I look across the table and I think, This is still her. I’m still me. The kids changed our schedules, but they didn’t ruin this.
I don’t know what it’ll look like when they get older. Maybe we’ll fight about homework or phones or bedtime in ways we can’t laugh off. Maybe not. For now, we’re taking it one playground at a time, and we’re both okay with not having all the answers.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Stay Friends When Your Parenting Styles Are Totally Different