The College Gender Gap Is Real—Why Young Men Are Getting Left Behind and How Parents Can Respond
Last fall, I stood in front of my senior English class with a packet of college application prompts. The girls in the front row had already been comparing notes for weeks—who was editing whose essay, which prompts felt too vague. In the back row, Marcus and two other boys had their heads together over a phone. I asked Marcus if he’d given any thought to his essay. He didn’t look up at first. Then he said, “Honestly? I probably shouldn’t bother. My cousin does HVAC and he’s making more than my dad did at his last job. Why sit in a classroom for four more years?”
I didn’t have a quick answer. A year earlier, that might have been a one-off comment. But I’d been hearing it more and more from boys, not just in my class but around the building. So after school, I pulled up our district’s data. For the past five years, 61% of the girls in our graduating class went on to a four-year college. For the boys, it was 44%. The gap wasn’t a blip. It was a pattern.
And it’s not just our school. Nationally, women now make up about 58% of bachelor’s degrees in the U.S., and the number keeps climbing. Men still enroll in college, of course, but the share has been dropping for years. For every 100 women who earn a degree, men earn roughly 74. That’s not a statistic I remember from college myself—it’s new.
I’ve been teaching long enough to know that not every kid needs to go to college. Trade school, apprenticeships, and direct entry into work can be smart moves. But I also know what happens to students who fall into that path by default rather than by choice. Marcus wasn’t rejecting college because he had a plan. He was rejecting it because it felt like something for other people.
At home, my younger son was the same. Not with grades—his were fine—but with any conversation about the future. If I asked what he wanted to do after high school, he said “don’t know.” If I followed up with “well, you need to start thinking about it,” he’d shrug and say I was stressing him out. I used to think he was being difficult. Then I started paying attention to what his older sisters did differently. Girls talk about college differently because they’ve been preparing for it socially for years. They see friends applying, families expecting it, and a whole culture pushing them forward. Many boys get the opposite message: that being stuck at a desk sounds like punishment, that their energy belongs somewhere more practical.
There was a moment at parent-teacher conferences that made this concrete for me. Marcus’s mom came in looking tired. She said, “He used to love school. In middle school he couldn’t stop talking about inventions. Now I can’t get him to write a single paragraph.” She wasn’t exaggerating. Marcus would do hands-on work, but any written assignment got a two-line attempt or nothing. We had a long conversation about his reading habits. He didn’t have a library card. He didn’t read at home, except maybe about cars online. She said, “I don’t know what to tell him. Nobody in our family went to college. I just want him to be happy.”
I told her something that surprised me as I said it: “You don’t have to make him love school. You just have to make sure he can use it.”
That’s become my way of thinking about this problem. The issue isn’t that boys are broken, or that they can’t do the work. It’s that the path to college has become this vague, boring, expensive obligation. Many boys don’t see a reason to climb it. So the first thing I do with a kid like Marcus is ask a different question. Not “Where are you applying?” but “What kind of workday do you want ten years from now?”
Marcus actually answered that. He wanted to work with his hands, not sit in meetings. He wanted to be outside some days. He didn’t want to live with his parents forever. That last one got a laugh. I pulled up a community college website on my laptop and showed him a two-year program in mechatronics—not to push him into it, just to show him that “college” includes wiring boards and repairing robots. He looked confused. “That’s college?” he said. It’s one thing to tell a kid that college programs aren’t all lectures and libraries. But they need to see the shop floor, the lab, the internships.
This is where parents and teachers can do something concrete. If your son writes off college without looking into it, try to change the image in his head. Don’t just hand him a brochure. Drive him to a community college campus on a Tuesday and walk around. Let him read the course listings. Ask about the welding shop, the automotive program, the computer labs. A lot of colleges have weekend open houses for high school students. The point isn’t to talk him into anything. It’s to make college less abstract.
Another practical thing: talk about money differently. A lot of boys I teach assume college is unaffordable. They’ve heard horror stories about $100,000 in loans, so they decide before ever looking at a FAFSA form. Community college, a few years at home, then transfer to a state school? That’s real debt, but a manageable one. We do kids a disservice when we don’t run the numbers out loud with them. “If you work twenty hours a week, and use the Pell grant, and apply for this scholarship, what does the monthly payment look like?” That’s a conversation they can have.
I’ve also started being more careful about what I say about reading. Reading stamina is a high-value skill for college gateways. But telling a boy to “read more” doesn’t do much. Handing him a biography of a race-car mechanic or a graphic novel based on military history works better. My own son wouldn’t open a novel, but he read through a huge book about the engineering behind skyscrapers without being asked. That kind of reading builds the same vocabulary and focus he’ll need on a college entrance exam, even if it doesn’t happen on a school reading log.
We also have to address the social piece. Many boys are not talking to anyone about their post-high school life—not seriously, and not with a trusted adult. In my classroom, I’ve started doing “future mapping” in small groups, where boys can talk with a teacher or counselor without making it a big deal. Just fifteen minutes, one-on-one, asking open questions: “What do you not want to do? What would your best day look like? Who do you know whose job would you hate?” From those sessions, you’d be surprised how many boys have real preferences and ideas. They just don’t know how to connect them to a path.
Marcus ended up applying. Not to a four-year school, but to the community college mechatronics program. I’m not sure he’ll finish. He might find a job first. But at least he’s not moving toward the exit with a shrug.
I’m not pretending one conversation fixes a national trend. The gender gap in education is tied to bigger forces: changes in the economy, cultural stories about masculinity, a school environment that increasingly rewards early verbal organization and the emotional maturity to sit still. Teachers can’t solve all that. Parents can’t either. But we can stop assuming boys will “figure it out later.” They don’t always.
The other night, my son asked me if I thought he’d be a good engineer. I said I didn’t know, but it seemed worth finding out. He was quiet for a second, then asked what an engineer actually does all day. We looked it up together. Nothing is decided. He still says he “doesn’t know” what he wants. But at least now he’s asking questions, and that feels like a start.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The College Gender Gap Is Real—Why Young Men Are Getting Left Behind and How Parents Can Respond