The Cassandra Effect in Adulthood: Why No One Believes What Teachers and Parents See Coming
At the end of the day, I still think about Cole. He sat at the back table in my second-grade classroom, chewing a pencil. When it was his turn to read, he looked at me, then at the page, then at me again. He said, “I don’t know.” But he knew the first sound. He usually used the pictures, but this was a page with no pictures. His mother didn’t see this. She saw a boy who was quiet and tired after school. When I sat across from her at parent-teacher conferences, I said, “He’s guessing words. I think he might be seeing something different than the rest of us.” She tilted her head. “He’s lazy,” she said. “His dad is the same.”
I understood. Lazy was a safe word. It didn’t open a door to specialists and meetings. It meant he’d grow out of it, like his dad did. So I didn’t push. I sent home a short list of three-letter words and a note inviting her to email me. She didn’t. By February, the reading specialist had a waitlist, and Cole made it on. The diagnosis was dyslexia—not severe, but enough. When his mother stopped me in the hallway, she didn’t say sorry. She said, “You knew before anyone else.” She said it like I’d kept a secret from her, which maybe I had. I didn’t say “I told you so.” I just said, “Now we can do something about it.”
This is what I call the Cassandra effect of adulthood. Cassandra was the Greek prophetess who told the truth, but no one believed her because Apollo cursed her. She saw the fall of Troy coming and couldn’t stop saying it. No one listened. As a teacher, I feel this a lot. But it also happens in ordinary parenting. You watch your child sleep at nine o’clock, and you notice they’re curled up with their eyes still open. You start keeping a mental note of how many times they’re asking to stay home from school. You mention it to your partner or your mother, and they say, “They’re just tired. You’re overthinking.” Sometimes you are overthinking. But sometimes you’re the first one to see the thing that no one else believes is there yet.
I was that partner two years ago. My daughter, Maya, was eight. Every Sunday night she’d announce her stomach hurt. At first I gave her a warm bath and said, “It’ll feel better in the morning.” Then one Sunday, I noticed she said it right after I told her about a spelling test on Monday. I started a log on my phone. It wasn’t a journal or anything emotional. Just facts: “Sunday 8:30, said tummy hurts. Mentioned test. No issue before bedtime. Slept at 9:30.” After three Sundays, the pattern was obvious. It wasn’t sickness. It was dread. I told my husband, “She’s not faking. She’s scared. We need to do something about the morning, not the stomach.” He looked at me like I was diagnosing a disease from a splinter.
But I didn’t argue. I got a dry-erase board and wrote the next morning’s schedule. “Spelling test at 9, then library, then lunch.” I gave Maya a small flashlight and let her read in bed. I said, “If you get stuck on the test, you can circle unknown words and tell yourself they’re just puzzles.” The Sunday night stomachache didn’t stop immediately. It faded. Maya still tells me after every test, “My tummy hurt early, but then it went away.” I’ve stopped trying to fix it. I’ve stopped wanting to be right. I just want to give her a set of tools she can reach for.
What I’m learning is that the Cassandra effect doesn’t go away when you grow up. It just changes form. You become the adult who says, “I notice this,” and you get met with “That’s not what I see.” The curse isn’t having accurate instincts. The curse is caring enough to say them when no one believes you. So you learn to speak more quietly, with more data and less drama.
Here is what I’ve learned to do, slowly, through trial and error with parents, colleagues, and my own family.
First, keep a boring record. If you think you see a pattern, write it down. For Cole, I had a clipboard with sticky notes for each child. For Maya, a note on my phone. This works not because you need proof to win an argument, but because when you’re ignored, you can go back to your notes and see if you were imagining it. Usually, you weren’t. And if you bring it to a doctor or teacher, saying “I noticed that after every Wednesday music class, she says her ears hurt” is more convincing than “She’s always complaining.”
Second, use the phrase “I wonder” instead of “I know.” Say, “I wonder if there’s something about the letters that is making it harder for him to guess.” This does two things. It leaves room for the other person’s perspective, and it makes you sound curious rather than certain. It also protects you when you’re wrong. Because sometimes you’re wrong. Sometimes the stomachaches are just digestion. Sometimes the reading struggle is just a developmental lag. If you say “I wonder,” you haven’t lost face. You’ve invited collaboration.
Third, ask the other adult what they’ve seen. This is the hardest one. When someone doesn’t believe you, the natural reaction is to feel defensive. But if you ask, “What do you notice at home?” you might learn that he reads fine at home. Then you can say, “So maybe it’s the environment here. Maybe he feels different when he’s in a room with other kids.” That turns an argument into an investigation.
Fourth, make one small change that doesn’t require anyone to admit anything. With Cole, I switched from oral reading to whisper reading. I let him use a bookmark with a slot cut out so he could isolate one word at a time. With Maya, it was the whiteboard. The point is not to fix everything. It’s to show the child that someone is on their side. And often, that small change gives the adult evidence. When the word-guessing goes down after a week of the slot bookmark, the Cassandra doesn’t have to prove anything. The change proves it.
I haven’t mastered this. Some days I still want to say, “I told you so.” But I don’t think that’s what the other adult needs. They need a path forward, not a scoreboard. More importantly, the child needs that too. Cole’s mother and I eventually made a plan. He came to school early three days a week and read with a high school volunteer. I sent home a checklist of “quick reads” that took four minutes. He started calling his reading time “book safe.” At the end of the year, he still read below grade level, but he no longer tried to hide it. That felt like a win, although it didn’t look like one at the time.
Now, when a parent tells me I’m being too sensitive about their child, I still hurt. When my husband says “here we go,” I still bite my lip. But I’ve stopped treating it as a battle. The Cassandra effect isn’t about being right. It’s about being in a room full of people who aren’t looking at the thing you’re looking at. You can’t make them look. You can only make your voice steady enough, and your observations specific enough, that when they finally do look, they recognize what you saw. That’s what I’m working on now. It’s not dramatic. It’s just notes on a phone, a whiteboard on the kitchen counter, and a little more grace for the people who aren’t ready yet.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Cassandra Effect in Adulthood: Why No One Believes What Teachers and Parents See Coming