Did Your Degree Shape You? What I Realised When My Daughter Started Applying to University
It was a Tuesday evening in October, and my daughter was sitting at the kitchen table with a university application form open on her laptop. She’d been staring at the personal statement box for twenty minutes, typing a sentence, deleting it, typing again. The rest of her homework was untouched.
“This is impossible,” she said, not looking up. “I don’t know what to write.”
I sat down with my tea. “Try telling me what you want to study and why.”
She pushed the laptop away. “That’s the problem. I don’t know if I want to study anything. I just know everyone says I should go.”
I asked her what she meant, and she shrugged. Then she asked me a question I wasn’t expecting. “Did your degree actually shape you? Like, are you who you are because of it?”
I studied English Literature. I graduated twenty-two years ago, and for the last fifteen of those years I’ve worked in local government, in a job that involves spreadsheets, meeting minutes, and almost no literary analysis of any kind. I remember the exact moment I realised I’d probably never write another academic essay again. It was during my second week of work experience, when my supervisor asked me to file a housing complaints report, and I felt a strange mixture of relief and grief.
“No,” I said. “I don’t think my degree shaped me. I think it just delayed my entry into the job market by three years.”
She nodded. “So it wasn’t worth it?”
That question stayed with me longer than it should have done. Not because I suddenly remembered some life-changing lecture that had rewired my brain — there wasn’t one. But because, over the following weeks, I kept noticing the small ways my degree had actually lingered. Not as knowledge. More like residue.
I notice it in meetings. Last month, we were reviewing a report on a refused planning application, and the report stated, plainly, that “it was decided the application should be refused.” I asked who decided. Nobody could tell me. The sentence was doing a specific kind of work — hiding the person behind the decision — and I could see it because I’d spent three years reading sentences like that, asking whose interests they served.
It’s the same habit that makes me read a news story and notice what the writer has left out. The same habit that makes me listen to someone present a bad argument confidently and be able to say, calmly, “I don’t think that premise holds.” None of this came from any single seminar. It came from three years of sitting in badly heated rooms with overpriced coffee, learning to argue about books I’ve never opened since.
When I explained some of this to my daughter, she looked at me like I was speaking a foreign language. “So it shaped you,” she said slowly, “but not in a way that gets you a job?”
That was the moment I realised I’d set the wrong frame for the conversation. We’d spent months talking about applications in outcomes — course rankings, graduate employment statistics, earning potential. We’d been asking “what will this degree do for you?” when the more honest question was “what will it do to you?”
I don’t mean that in a dramatic, life-affirming way. I watched plenty of people go through university and come out the other side remarkably unchanged — same opinions, same habits, same ways of thinking. A degree doesn’t shape everyone. It depends on the course, the person, and a fair amount of luck. My cousin studied accounting and describes it as “three years of learning how to format spreadsheets.” She’s the same person she was at eighteen, only more tired. A friend who studied nursing, on the other hand, still talks about the placement that made her cry every day and how it taught her to be present when someone is afraid. The difference wasn’t the institution. It was the substance.
But for the degrees that do shape you, the change is rarely what the prospectus promises. It isn’t about leadership or employability. It’s subtler. You pick up the habit of reading long, difficult things all the way through. You learn to say “I don’t know, but I can find out” without feeling ashamed. You get a sense of which arguments hold up under pressure and which collapse the moment someone asks a follow-up question. These aren’t skills you can put on a CV. They’re more like furniture in the mind. You don’t notice them most days, but they’re there, and they change how you move through the room.
At the school gates the next week, the conversation was all about UCAS. One dad was worried his son had chosen a “soft” subject. Another mother was quoting a league table from her phone like it was scripture. Everyone was asking the same thing: what will this get them? I stood there and realised I’d rather ask my daughter something else.
So on Sunday, over breakfast, I tried a different set of questions. Not “what job would you like to have?” but “what would you like three years of your life to be for?” Not “what’s the best university you can get into?” but “where will you be pushed to think differently?” She wanted a course that would make her write a lot, because she’d always enjoyed writing but never trusted that enjoyment to count for anything. She wanted to be somewhere that would test her opinions, because she’d noticed she’d got comfortable agreeing with herself. She wanted to live somewhere she didn’t know anyone, because the idea frightened her slightly, and she thought that might mean it was worth doing.
At some point I tried to steer her back towards “employability,” and she cut me off. “You literally just told me your degree made you better at reading a room and arguing about nothing. That’s not a career.”
She’s right. It isn’t a career. It’s something else. And the uncomfortable truth is that for a degree to be worthwhile, you have to accept that unpredictable something else — while knowing you might not get it at all. A degree doesn’t guarantee you’ll become a better thinker, or a more curious person, or anything at all. It’s an expensive gamble on your own development, and the odds aren’t as good as universities would like you to believe.
There’s also a question I think parents are too afraid to ask, which is who actually needs a degree in the first place. My daughter’s school pushes university hard. Her friends are all applying. But I’ve worked with people who never went, and some of them are sharper, more thoughtful, and better with people than I’ll ever be. A degree isn’t a shortcut to becoming a certain kind of person. Sometimes it’s an expensive certificate that proves you can hit a deadline. Sometimes it’s not even that.
We didn’t resolve anything that Sunday, or the Sundays after. She’s still writing her personal statement, and she’s still uncertain, and I’m still uncertain about what to tell her. I don’t want to sell her a fantasy of university as a life-changing journey when so many people pass through it without being touched at all.
But I’ve stopped saying my degree was useless. That was wrong. It was useful in the way a pair of hiking boots is useful when you only walk in them three times a year and mostly keep them by the door — not because they’re doing much on a daily basis, but because you know, in a quiet background way, that you’d notice if they were gone.
Did my degree shape me? Yes. No. Kind of. My daughter asked me a better question about my own life than I’d ever thought to ask, and the least I can do is let the answer stay open rather than tying it off with a neat bow.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Did Your Degree Shape You