Do People Really Find Life Worth Living? What I Tell My Students When They Ask
It happened on a Tuesday during the last ten minutes of lunch. A student I’ll call Marcus stayed behind after most of the class had headed out to the courtyard. He was a quiet kid, not the type to linger. He sat on the edge of the desk, swinging his legs, pretending to look at his phone.
“Miss,” he said, “do you ever think life is just not worth it?”
I didn’t panic. I’ve learned that when a teenager asks that in the middle of a school day, they aren’t usually standing on a ledge. They’re standing in the middle of a cafeteria, feeling tired and unsure. Still, I didn’t rush to answer.
“Sometimes, yeah,” I said. “Especially when I haven’t slept enough or everything feels heavy. Do you feel that way right now?”
He shrugged. “I don’t know. It’s just weird. Like, everyone says life is great, but I look around and I don’t really get it. I don’t have a reason to be alive.”
That last sentence could have made my stomach drop. Instead, I reminded myself to breathe and stay in the moment. I said, “That’s honest. Thanks for telling me. Can I ask what made you think about that today?”
He mentioned a video game he’d finished, an argument with his mom that morning, and a math test he thought he’d failed. Ordinary things. But for a fourteen-year-old, they all blur together into the same question: What’s the point?
I didn’t want to give him a lecture about the meaning of life. I wanted to give him a way to be in the room a little longer.
“Okay,” I said. “I don’t have a magic answer. But let me tell you something a counselor told me years ago: You’re not asking for a reason to live. You’re asking for a reason to feel less tired. And that’s something we can work with.”
He looked at me like I was speaking a different language. But he stayed.
That conversation stayed with me. Since then, I’ve realized that kids aren’t usually asking the big philosophical question in the abstract. They’re asking it because something smaller has worn them down—a bad grade, a lost friendship, a parent who’s stressed, a body that feels unfamiliar. The question is real, but it’s also a doorway. What they often need is not an answer but a way to talk about the broken pieces without being told to just be positive.
I’ve also learned what not to say.
“Life is so worth it, you’ll see!” sounds nice, but it can make a kid feel like they’re failing at something everyone else gets. “You have so much to live for” can land as a guilt trip. Even “How can you say that?”—said with shock—can shut the door. Marcus didn’t need me to argue with him. He needed me to take the question seriously and stay calm enough to help him unpack it.
So I’ve started doing the thing parents and teachers aren’t always comfortable with: I lean into the boring details.
I asked Marcus what he did on Sunday afternoon. He said he watched an old cooking show with his grandmother and made scrambled eggs with too much pepper. He laughed a little describing it. I asked him if that hour felt okay. He said it did.
“Okay,” I said. “So let’s not worry about whether life is worth living in general. Let’s just think about Sunday at 2 p.m. That was a real hour, and you remember it. What made it okay?”
He said his grandmother didn’t ask him any questions and she talked about the chef on screen like he was an old friend. It was quiet. It was fine.
“That’s a small reason,” I said. “It’s not a tattoo-worthy meaning of life. But it counted for something.”
He didn’t suddenly transform into a joyful kid. But he did nod. And two days later, he came back and told me he’d baked the same scrambled eggs for his little sister.
Is that the answer to “do people really find life worth living?” Maybe the answer is that they find hours worth living. They find one conversation, one good meal, one time someone notices them. And they stack those hours together until the question feels less terrifying.
Something else I’ve learned is that kids need stable ways to answer “how am I actually doing?” without needing to be in crisis to get attention. So in my classroom, I started using a low-key check-in system. Not a big emotional wheel with thirty feelings on it. Just a small index card at the start of each week with three boxes: “Doing fine,” “Hanging in there,” “Not great.” They fold it and hand it to me. It’s not mandatory, and no one has to explain. But it means a kid like Marcus can tell me quietly that he’s had two rough weeknights without having to raise his hand in front of the class.
When “Not great” shows up, I don’t ask for details in the hallway. I just say, “I see it. I’m glad you marked it. If you want to talk, I’m around after class.” If the pattern repeats, I involve the school counselor. That’s a concrete step but it doesn’t sound like an emergency. It’s just checking an inbox.
There’s also a phrase I’ve started using with my own kids at home. When one of them says something like “I wish I wasn’t alive,” which is a harder and scarier version of the question, I don’t leap into problem-solving. I say, “That must be really painful to be carrying. I’m here. You don’t have to solve it right now.” Then I sit next to them, maybe put a hand on their knee. I don’t tell them they’re wrong. I don’t tell them they’re overreacting. I just stay.
In the weeks after that lunch conversation, Marcus didn’t turn into a different person. He still wore the same sweatshirt, still slumped in his chair, still grumbled about homework. But he started staying after class occasionally. Not to talk about life—to ask what kind of coffee I was drinking, or to look at a photo of my dog. Those conversations mattered. They were practice. He was learning that adults could be around without demanding that he be happy.
One day I asked him, “Are you still wondering about life being worth it?” expecting him to say he didn’t know. He said, “I don’t know. But I made my grandma laugh yesterday, so I guess that was okay.”
That’s not a resolution. It’s not even really an answer. But I’ve come to believe that for kids, “worth it” isn’t a destination. It’s a repeated small choice to stay in contact with something real—a person, a task, a funny dog video, a badly cooked egg. They don’t need us to solve the meaning of life. They need us to help them find the next thing that feels less heavy.
I’m not sure I could tell you whether life is objectively worth living. But I can tell you this: when a kid asks, the best response is not a grand speech. It’s a quiet, steady presence, a practical question, and time. And sometimes, that’s enough to get them through to the next class, the next meal, the next ordinary Tuesday.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Do People Really Find Life Worth Living