Age-Appropriate Anti-Racism Resources for 5-Year-Olds: What I Tried (And What Actually Worked)
I was wiping crushed Goldfish crumbs off my jeans at the neighborhood playground last month when my 5-year-old daughter Lila trotted over, brow furrowed, and asked, “Why is my skin paler than the little girl I was just playing with?” My brain went blank for three full seconds. I’d known this question was coming eventually, but I’d never mapped out an answer that made sense for a kid who still thinks the hardest problem in the world is waiting 10 minutes for popsicles to freeze. I mumbled something about all of us having different colored skin just like we have different colored hair, and it’s all good, but she ran off to play before I finished, and I was left feeling like I’d dropped the ball. That night I started searching for anti-racism resources made for 5-year-olds, and quickly realized how little out there actually fits this age group.
I checked out seven books from the library, saved three Pinterest boards, bought a $12 “anti-racist toddler workbook” off Etsy that popped up in my feed, and spent a week testing everything with Lila at bedtime and craft time. Most of it was useless. The workbook had pages of prompts about standing up to injustice that meant nothing to a kid who can’t even write her own name. One highly recommended picture book got into the history of redlining and segregation, and Lila kept interrupting to ask when the main character was going to get a puppy. I got frustrated, because so much advice for parents just says “talk to your kids early” but no one tells you what actually works when your kid is only 5.
The first thing that clicked was The Color of Us by Karen Katz. It’s a simple story of a little girl who looks at all the different skin tones of her friends and neighbors, comparing them to things kids already know: honey, cinnamon, coffee, peanut butter. Lila was obsessed. After we read it the first time, she spent 20 minutes running around the living room comparing everyone’s arms to food. “Mine is vanilla ice cream with a tan! Daddy’s is crunchy peanut butter! Grandma’s is honey!” It was silly, low-stakes, and it gave her words for the thing she’d already noticed. A lot of old advice says not to point out skin color to kids, because it’ll make them see race, but that’s wrong. 5-year-olds notice. They see the difference, and if you don’t name it as a normal, good thing, they make up their own wrong ideas about it.
Next, I found short 2-minute Sesame Street clips on YouTube about inclusion, and that’s been perfect for our routine. There’s a whole playlist of bits where Elmo and his friends talk about not excluding people because of how they look. Lila loves Elmo, so she’ll sit and watch one while I’m packing her lunch after breakfast, no pushing required. Last week one of the clips had a little girl saying she couldn’t join a game because of her skin color, and Elmo said that’s not okay, everyone gets to play. Lila turned to me and said “That’s mean, right?” and I said “Yeah, that’s really mean. No one ever gets to tell someone they can’t play because of their skin.” That’s a 3-minute conversation, no big lesson, just clear, simple right and wrong that a 5-year-old can hold onto.
I also tried a skin color mixing craft I saw on a preschool teacher’s blog, and that’s been one of our favorite low-effort activities. I got out red, yellow, brown, and white washable paint, and let Lila mix a shade that matched her own arm, then mix one for me, one for her dad, one for Mia, the girl from the playground. We got paint all over the vinyl tablecloth, and Lila added googly eyes to each one to make little portraits. It was just a craft, but we talked the whole time about how every single person has their own unique color, and that’s what makes it cool. For kids who learn by doing, this is way more engaging than any book.
What I’ve learned through all this is that you don’t need fancy, expensive resources. The best thing you can do is stop acting like skin color is a taboo topic. I used to tense up if Lila pointed out someone’s skin out loud, worried she’d say something rude. Now I just casually mention differences when they come up. “That construction worker has such a pretty deep brown skin, just like his hard hat.” “Auntie Mei’s skin is paler than mine, just like her mom’s.” It’s no big production, just part of talking about the world, which is exactly what 5-year-olds need.
Last week, we were back at the playground, and another little boy told Mia she couldn’t play on the slide with him because she was brown. Before I could even stand up, Lila marched over, grabbed Mia’s hand, and said “All skin colors are good. If you’re gonna be mean, you can’t play with us either.” I stood there holding my half-empty water bottle, surprised, because I hadn’t given her some big formal speech. She just picked it up from the little books and clips and casual conversations we’ve had over the past couple months.
I still don’t have it all figured out. In a couple years, when Lila asks harder questions, I’ll need different resources, bigger conversations, and I’ll probably fumble those too. The expensive workbook I bought is sitting in the bottom of her craft drawer, unused, and I still have three books from the library that we never finished. Some days the conversation is just answering a silly question about whether people with dark skin like the same ice cream flavors as me, then turning the page to the next story. Right now, that’s enough. Small, consistent, age-appropriate bits beat big, heavy lessons any day for a 5-year-old. We’re just starting out, and we’re taking it one picture book at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Age-Appropriate Anti-Racism Resources for 5-Year-Olds: What I Tried (And What Actually Worked)