Why do kids in China shut down in class? What I learned helping one 10-year-old
The chalk dust was still hanging in the air at 8:15 on my first day substituting 4th grade math at a public school in Guangzhou when I called the roll. “Xiao Ming?” No answer. I looked up, scanning the rows of blue uniform shirts, and spotted him hunched over the first desk in the back row, gray hoodie pulled low over his black hair, face pressed almost to his notebook. A boy in the front row turned around and stage-whispered, “He doesn’t talk, miss. He never talks.”
I checked the student file the principal had slipped me that morning. Xiao Ming was 10, his mom worked in an electronics factory in Shenzhen, crossing the border back home once every two weeks. His grandma handled bedtime, homework, and school pickups. A year earlier, he’d been in the top 10 of his class; by the start of this semester, he was 32nd out of 45. He’d stopped joining his classmates for soccer at recess, stopped turning in most homework, and stopped answering questions from any teacher. The principal’s note at the bottom read: Just a lazy kid, needs a firm hand to get him back on track.
I didn’t push him that first week. I’d walk past his desk after collecting homework, and if his was missing, I’d just keep going. I left a pack of strawberry Pocky I’d bought from the school canteen vending machine on his desk after lunch one day, and didn’t say a word about it. The next morning, the Pocky was gone, and the crumpled wrapper was tucked in the small trash bin under his desk.
It was a week later that I stopped by his desk during the 10-minute free period before the parent-teacher conference. He wasn’t staring at the wall or napping like he usually did; he was drawing on the back of an old math exercise book, his pencil moving fast. I leaned over just enough to see it was a line of military tanks, each one detailed with tiny tread marks and antennae. “That turret’s really accurate,” I said. “Did you see that on TV?” He flinched so hard his pencil snapped, and he slammed the notebook shut, pressing his palms against the cover like he was hiding a secret. I didn’t push. I just said, “I used to draw cats all over my math homework when I was your age. It’s way more interesting than equations,” and walked back to the front of the room.
Two days later, I found a crumpled drawing of a tank tucked into my lesson plan book, the edges smudged with pencil. That was the first crack. Over the next couple of weeks, we started talking in 2-minute chunks after class, while everyone else headed out to recess. It turned out he’d had after-school math and calligraphy classes every weekend for three years, until his mom’s factory cut overtime pay this year and she couldn’t afford the tuition anymore. She’d promised him if he got back into the top 10 by the end of the semester, she’d bring him to Shenzhen to live with her for the whole summer—something he’d been asking for for years. If he didn’t hit the goal, he’d stay with grandma, same as always. He told me he’d sit at his desk at night trying to do the extra problems, and when he couldn’t solve one, he’d get a WeChat voice call from his mom yelling that he was wasting his chance, that she worked 12-hour days just to give him a good life. After a while, he couldn’t make himself try anymore. If he didn’t do the work, he told me, at least it wasn’t proof he wasn’t good enough to go live with mom.
I used to buy into the same line the principal did—kids that shut down are just lazy, or unmotivated. I’ve taught here for four years, and I see this all the time: kids carrying pressure that most adults I know would struggle to handle, pressure to get good grades, pressure to not waste the opportunities their parents work so hard to give them. When that pressure gets too big, kids don’t act out or throw tantrums half the time. They just shut down. It’s not laziness. It’s self-protection. If you don’t try, you don’t have to face the disappointment of failing.
What worked for us wasn’t extra tutoring or a big talk about responsibility. It was small, concrete changes that anyone can do, no extra time or money required. First, I gave him one problem a day to do after class, just one. No extra homework, no make-up work for all the assignments he’d missed. If he got it right, we’d chat about his tank drawings for two minutes before he went out to recess. If he got it wrong, we’d go through it once together, and that was it. No yelling, no “why can’t you get this”, no extra work to punish him. That took all the pressure off right away. He didn’t have to face a mountain of missing work that felt impossible to climb. He just had to do one small thing.
Second, I video called his mom one night after class, and I didn’t start with a list of all the things Xiao Ming was doing wrong. I sent her the drawing of the tank he’d given me first, and told her how good he was at focusing on small details, how that’s exactly the kind of skill that makes you good at math. Then I asked her to adjust her goal: instead of top 10, what if we celebrated if he moved up 5 places, and she still brought him to Shenzhen for summer even if he didn’t hit the original number? I explained that every time she yells at him over the phone, he gets so nervous he can’t even think straight, so he just stops trying. She agreed, surprisingly quickly—she just hadn’t realized that pushing harder wasn’t working.
Third, I talked to his homeroom teacher about moving him from the front row, where every teacher’s eyes land when they call roll, to the empty spot by the back window. We agreed we’d only call on him when he raised his hand, no forcing him to speak in front of the whole class if he didn’t want to. A lot of teachers think forcing shy kids to speak builds confidence, but for a kid that’s already shut down, it just makes him hide more.
It’s been three months now. Xiao Ming still doesn’t talk much in whole class. He still draws tanks on the back of his notebook more often than he takes notes on the front. He turned in 22 out of the 31 daily one-problem assignments I gave him this semester, and his last math test score put him at 24th in the class—8 places up from where he started. Mom brought him to Shenzhen for a week of summer break early, and he brought me back a pack of dried mango candy when he got back.
The principal still mentions every once in a while that he could be trying harder. I don’t disagree. We’re not done, and there’s no big neat ending here. He still gets quiet and curls into his hoodie when a stranger comes into the classroom. But he raises his hand sometimes now, when he knows the answer. That’s enough for right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why do kids in China shut down in class