Why Kids Ask “Which One Looks Better?” And How To Respond For Parents And Teachers
I’m folding laundry at the kitchen counter at 7:15 a.m. when my 10-year-old Lila appears in the doorway, holding two crumpled pieces of watercolor paper in her left hand. “Just curious which one looks better?” she says, shifting her weight from one socked foot to the other. The school art show is that afternoon, she’s required to bring one piece to hang, and she’s been hovering by her desk turning this over for 20 minutes.
Five minutes ago, I would have blurted out an answer. I’m a part-time 4th grade aide, I’m used to making quick calls to keep the day moving. Last fall, she asked which cookie to bring to her class bake sale, I picked the neater, more evenly iced one, and she spent the whole car ride moping that she actually liked the lumpy chocolate chip one better. She ended up giving my pick to her teacher and eating the one she liked on the way to school, so it didn’t ruin anything, but it stuck with me. I’d robbed her of the choice before she even got to name what she wanted.
One painting is a sunset over the lake we camped at last June, soft blended pinks and oranges, a blobby blue reflection she keeps saying is ruined. The other is a crayon and watercolor drawing of our rescue cat Mochi, her green eyes lopsided, her orange fur colored in with so much black crayon it smudges off on your fingers if you touch it. Her nose is twice the size it should be.
I lean against the counter, brush a strand of hair out of my face, and don’t pick. Instead I say, “Tell me what you like about each one.” That’s the trick I’ve started using, at home and at work, and it takes barely any longer than just answering.
She talks first about the sunset: she says she got the color of the sky right, that when we were there that night, it glowed that exact peach color over the water, and she sat on the hood of our car eating a popsicle while she watched it. She wanted to capture that warm feeling. Then the Mochi drawing: she drew it when Mochi had to get her bladder stones removed last month, when we were stuck at the vet waiting for three hours, she drew it on scrap paper to calm herself down. Even though the eyes are wrong, it looks like how Mochi feels: soft, grumpy, always squinting at you like you woke her up from a nap. She stops talking, stares at the two papers for 10 seconds, then says “Oh. I want to bring Mochi.”
I see this play out every week at school. Last month, a 3rd grader named Javi was putting together his volcano science fair display, and he pulled me aside to ask which title layout looked better. One was typed, centered, perfectly aligned, the kind of display that looks great in photos. The other was hand-lettered, with tiny doodles of exploding volcanoes all along the border, a little lopsided. Early in my time as an aide, I would have picked the typed one. It looks “better” to an adult eye, right? Neater, more put together. This time I just asked him what he liked about each. He shrugged and said the typed one looked like what teachers “expect” but he drew the volcano doodles while he was researching for his project, and they made him laugh every time he looked at them. He went with the hand-drawn border, and by the end of the fair, three other kids had come up to ask him to draw doodles on their projects next year.
Most of the time, when kids ask which option looks better, they aren’t actually asking for your opinion. They already have one. They’ve just learned that “good” work is neat, perfect, matches what adults want, so their favorite, the messy one that matters to them, feels wrong. They just need space to say out loud why each option matters, and their own preference pops right to the surface. When we jump in and answer right away, we’re telling them that our call matters more than theirs, even if we don’t mean to. It’s easy to do, especially when we’re running late or have a stack of papers to grade, but it adds up. Over time, kids stop trusting their own taste and start asking everyone else what they should think before they even try to decide.
The strategy I use is so simple, it feels silly to call it a tip. When someone asks “which one looks better,” pause before you answer. Ask them to name one thing they like about each option. It takes 30 seconds, tops. If they still can’t choose after that, ask them which one they’d rather show their favorite person – their best friend, their grandma, their favorite coach. Nine times out of ten, that’s all they need to figure it out. If they still say they don’t know and actually want your take, you can give it then. No one’s stopping you.
Lila hung her Mochi drawing at the art show, and by the time I got there after work, a little girl from her class was standing in front of it telling Lila she also has a chonky orange cat that squints just like that. They exchanged phone numbers after and arranged a cat playdate at the park a week later. It worked out, but that doesn’t mean I get it right every time. Last week, a student of mine asked which poem he should submit to the school literary magazine, and I almost blurted out my favorite before I caught myself. The week before that, I answered my college nephew’s question about two resume designs before I remembered the trick, and he sighed and said he actually liked the messy one with his side graphic design projects front and center anyway. It’s a habit, unlearning the urge to fix the choice for them. It doesn’t need to be perfect. Most days, all it takes is pausing long enough to let them talk. They already know the answer. They just need someone to let them say it.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Kids Ask “Which One Looks Better