How History Is Taught In American Public Schools: Coping Tips For Struggling Students Before Exams
Last Tuesday night, I wiped down the kitchen table after dinner and found my 10th grader Javi’s half-crushed bag of cheddar Goldfish, a crumpled mind map covered in blue highlighter, and an open laptop playing a history podcast on the Haitian Revolution. He slouched into the chair next to me, pushed his glasses up his nose, and said, “I can tell you three ways the Haitian Revolution changed global slavery laws, but I can never remember if it ended in 1803 or 1804. Why does that even matter for the exam?”
That question sums up pretty well how history is taught in most U.S. public high schools right now: it’s a tug of war between two very different goals. When I was in 10th grade, history was all rote memorization. We opened the textbook, copied dates off the chalkboard, answered 20 review questions at the end of the chapter, and that was it. We spent more time quizzing each other on which pope excommunicated which king than talking about how ordinary people lived through the Middle Ages.
Today, Javi’s class is almost the opposite. His teacher starts every unit with a primary source: a letter from a 19th century factory worker, a political cartoon criticizing colonialism, an excerpt from a Taino elder’s account of Columbus’s landing. Last semester, they did a whole group project creating fake social media profiles for civil rights leaders, focusing on their personal disagreements and unspoken biases instead of just memorizing the dates of major marches. It’s meant to teach kids to think critically about the past, not just recite it, and I think that’s a really good change.
But the tug of war comes in with testing. All public high schools in our state require an end-of-course exam for 10th grade world history that counts for 20% of a student’s final grade, and 60% of that exam is multiple choice questions about specific dates, key terms, and causal connections that require rote memorization. Teachers are expected to teach critical thinking, but they also have to get kids to pass a test that rewards memorization. That gap leaves a lot of struggling kids stuck. Javi has ADHD, and his working memory isn’t as strong as other kids his age. He can talk for 20 minutes about how different historical accounts of the same event change how we see the past, but he mixes up the dates of major wars every time.
Over the past six months, we’ve tried a lot of different strategies to help him cope with exam prep, and most of the best ones came straight from his history teacher, not me or a parenting book.
The first trick she gave him is the five key date rule. Instead of asking kids to memorize every date in a 10-chapter unit, she pulls out the five that almost always show up on the state exam. For the revolutions unit, that’s 1776, 1789, 1804, 1917, 1949. That’s it. Javi doesn’t waste time stressing over 20 minor dates that almost never get tested; he just focuses on remembering those five and what each one means.
The second thing that’s worked is ditching all-night cram sessions for 10 minutes of low-pressure quizzing every night. His teacher pre-makes Quizlet sets for each unit that only include the key terms the exam tests, so I just pull up the set on my phone while I’m cleaning up after dinner, call out a term, and he answers. It takes two minutes most nights, 10 at most. No big fight about sitting at the desk for hours, no last-minute panic that makes him shut down.
The school also offers an after-school study session every Wednesday, run by the history department and led by seniors who got top scores on past exams. The PTA buys cheap pizza, and it’s just low-key work time. Javi says it’s way less stressful than asking the teacher a question in front of the whole class, because the seniors get what it’s like to mix up dates too. They’ll tell you straight when a detail doesn’t matter for the exam, instead of making you memorize every little thing.
One practical thing I tell other parents about that no one really talks about: if your kid struggles with test taking or working memory, check with your school counseling office about exam accommodations. Javi gets 50% extra time on the end-of-course exam and can take it in a quiet room away from the whole grade. We just needed his ADHD documentation from his doctor, and the school approved it in two weeks. A lot of parents I know don’t even know this is an option, and it makes a huge difference for kids who work a little slower than their peers.
It’s not a perfect system, of course. I’m glad history class now teaches kids to think critically, and I hate that we still have to spend so much time drilling dates for a standardized test that doesn’t measure that skill. But that’s the system we have right now, and these small, low-friction steps are what work for kids like Javi who struggle with the memorization side of things.
Last night, Javi took a practice quiz on the revolutions unit and got 8 out of 10 questions right. He still mixed up the end of the Haitian Revolution, guessed 1803 instead of 1804. He laughed and crumpled up his quiz, said he’d get it next time. The exam is three months away, and we’re not aiming for a perfect score. We’re just aiming for him to pass, so he can take the public history elective he wants next year, the one where students lead walking tours of old Black neighborhoods in our city. It’s messy, it’s not how I’d design things if I had a choice, but this is working for us right now. We’ll see how it goes.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How History Is Taught In American Public Schools: Coping Tips For Struggling Students Before Exams