Why a 17 Year Old Guy Can Move On So Fast After Seeming Obsessed: Parenting Tips for Teen Heartbreak
The marshmallows were stuck to the bottom of my cocoa pan when Lila threw her iPhone onto the couch so hard the case cracked a little more at the corner. She’d just tramped in from soccer practice, cleats still caked in November mud by the front door, and her cheeks were pink from more than the cold. I wiped my hands on my apron and sat down next to her, waiting. She’s 16, and doesn’t yell unless she’s really hurt, so I knew this wasn’t just a bad practice.
“He’s posting pictures with her. Mia from sophomore class. At the homecoming dance,” she said. That’s Jace, the 17 year old who’d been obsessed with her for two months. He waited for her after every class, left handwritten notes in her locker, commented on every one of her Instagram posts, and told her he’d never felt this way about anyone. Lila wasn’t sure she wanted to date exclusively—she’s got her driver’s test coming up, she’s trying to get into advanced art next year, she didn’t want to jump into anything serious. She told him that two weeks ago, they agreed to step back, and now it’s been a week and he’s already with someone else. “How do you go from obsessed to gone in seven days?” she asks me, and her voice cracks.
I work as a guidance counselor at the same high school, so I know Jace. He came to my office back in October, after another kid called him a creep for hanging around Lila’s locker too much. He sat across from my desk bouncing his tennis shoe for 20 minutes, and told me he’d moved here this summer from western Pennsylvania, after his parents split. All his old friends were back there, he ate lunch in the bathroom the first month because he didn’t know who to sit with. Then Lila had smiled at him in biology and lent him a pencil. “No one’s ever been that nice to me just because,” he’d said.
That’s the thing most people miss about that so-called obsession. It wasn’t really about Lila. It was about a 17 year old kid who was drowning in loneliness, and he latched onto the first person who made him feel seen. That intensity isn’t love, it’s a lifeline. When Lila said she couldn’t give him the full-time commitment he needed right then, that lifeline got pulled away, and he scrambled to grab the next one. That’s why it only took a week.
When I was talking to Lila, I didn’t start with that explanation right away. I’ve learned the hard way that when a teenager is hurting and asking “why,” the last thing they want is a lecture before they’ve even cried it out. First I just said, “That hurts so much. I’d be shocked and humiliated too,” and then I handed her a napkin when she started crying. That’s the first thing any parent should do here: don’t jump to calling the guy a jerk or telling your kid they should have seen it coming. They already feel stupid for believing the intensity. Let the hurt land first.
I also let her text her coach and skip afternoon practice that day. A lot of parents I talk to think pushing kids to “keep going” and “stay busy” helps them get over heartbreak faster, but that just teaches them to stuff their feelings down. If they need a day to sit on the couch and eat bad candy and rewatch old episodes of The Office, let them. It’s just one day, and it doesn’t make them weak.
After Lila cried for a little while, she asked me again what it means. I didn’t say “he never cared about you,” because that’s not true. He did care, in the way a 17 year old who’s never had to sit with a hard feeling can care. The problem is, most teenage boys are socialized their whole lives to not sit with uncomfortable feelings. If they’re sad, they’re supposed to play video games or hang out with friends or find something new to distract themselves. They don’t get told it’s okay to sit for a month feeling disappointed and lonely after something doesn’t work out. So when things with Lila fell apart, the fastest way to stop hurting was to find a new person to give him that same good feeling. That’s not always malicious, it’s just what he’s learned to do.
A lot of parents ask me if this means the kid was just playing games the whole time. Sometimes that’s true, but most of the time, it’s just how teenage brains work. The part of the brain that regulates emotion and handles slow, steady thinking is still maturing at 17. Big feelings feel permanent when you’re that age, and they also fade faster than you expect, because you don’t have a lot of practice holding onto them. That obsession felt huge because it was the biggest good feeling he’d had in months, so when it went away, he got rid of the bad feeling as fast as he could by moving on.
I’ve found that if your kid keeps circling back to the same question over and over, you don’t have to keep coming up with new answers. Last week, Lila brought it up again while we were folding laundry, and I just said “I know it still doesn’t make sense. Do you want to go get that salted caramel milkshake you like after I’m done here?” Sometimes that’s better than any explanation.
Last Friday, Lila went to the homecoming game with her friends. She saw Jace and Mia there, holding hands, and she didn’t run away or start crying. She just got a hot dog with her friends and cheered when the home team scored. Last night she was going through her backpack and found one of the notes Jace left her. She crumpled it up and threw it away, and then she said “It still doesn’t make sense how he moved on that fast. But it doesn’t hurt as bad as it did last week.”
That’s as good an ending as we get, I think. Teen heartbreak doesn’t wrap up neat, with a big lesson learned and everything fixed in a week. Sometimes you just get to the point where it hurts less, and that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why a 17 Year Old Guy Can Move On So Fast After Seeming Obsessed: Parenting Tips for Teen Heartbreak