Which Subjects Should I Pick for GCSE: Practical Advice From a Parent Who’s Just Been Through It
The kitchen table was still covered in pepperoni crumbs from our Friday takeaway last month when my 14-year-old son Sam slid his blue GCSE option form across the surface, the school logo smudged where he’d been picking at the edge. His phone was plugged into the wall socket by the toaster, cord stretched across the table, and he’d paused mid-scroll through TikTok to ask the question I’d been dreading for six months: “All my mates are picking media. Why can’t I?”
I stared at the list of options, my own GCSE options form popping into my head unbidden. I was 14 once, too, and my mum talked me out of picking art, told me French was more useful, I’d thank her later. I dropped French after a year, never used it once, and still have a half-finished watercolor I was going to submit for my art GCSE tucked in the back of a drawer at my mum’s house. So I bit my tongue instead of saying the thing that popped into my head first—that media is a “soft” subject, not worth the space on a certificate.
We went to the school’s options evening a week later, and that’s where most of my old assumptions fell apart. I cornered Sam’s form tutor by the refreshments table, holding a half-empty paper cup of cheap tea, and asked her what I should be telling him. She leaned against the wall and told me about a girl she’d taught five years ago, whose parents made her pick three humanity subjects because they wanted her to be a lawyer. She hated every minute, got C’s across the board when she’d have gotten top grades in art and textiles, and now works as a wedding dress designer. “Most kids change their mind about what they want to do after GCSE twice before they finish Year 11,” she said. “There’s no point locking them into something they hate before they even get there.”
That stuck with me. I also talked to my niece, who finished her GCSEs three years ago. Her dad made her pick triple science because he wanted her to be a physiotherapist, even though she’d been drawing and designing clothing in her room since she was 10. She got Bs in all three sciences, which wasn’t bad, but she got a 9 in art that she did as an extra after school. Now she’s in her second year of a graphic design degree, and she still says the three years of science she suffered through were a waste of time that could have been spent on something she cared about.
After the options evening, I sat down with Sam again, and we went through his list with three simple questions I got from the form tutor, that any parent can go through with their kid. First: do you already do this thing in your free time anyway? For Sam, that was an easy yes for media and art. He’s always editing short clips of our dog and his skateboarding for his friends, he draws all over his notebook, he takes apart old speakers to mess around with the wiring for his design tech project. Second: can you see yourself sticking with it when the coursework gets boring? There’s always going to be a part of any subject that sucks—for art it’s writing the artist analysis, for media it’s planning your project before you can start editing. Sam said he’d rather do that boring work for a subject he liked than do boring work for something he hated anyway. Third: are you picking this just because your best mate is picking it? Sam thought about that for a minute, then said one of his mates was picking geography just because his other mate was, but he actually likes editing so he wasn’t just following. That was good enough for me.
I also stopped worrying so much about the “soft subject” myth, after talking to the head of sixth form at the school. He told me that as long as the subject is an accredited GCSE, most sixth forms and colleges don’t turn you away for picking media or art over geography or a language. And a 9 in a subject you enjoy is always better than a 4 in a subject you hate, no matter how “respected” that subject is. If Sam changes his mind later and wants to do a history degree, he just needs to get the A level, and his GCSE options won’t hold him back.
The only concrete check I made was if he had any vague idea of what he might want to do after GCSE, and if that required any specific subjects. He said he thinks he might want to do something with video or design when he’s older, so none of that requires a specific GCSE he wasn’t already picking. If he’d said he wanted to be a doctor, we’d have made sure he picked the two sciences he needed for sixth form entry. But if your kid has zero clue what they want, don’t force them to pick every subject under the sun just to “keep their options open”. All that does is stretch them too thin and bring down all their grades. I also reminded Sam not to pick a subject just because he likes the teacher, and not to drop a subject just because he doesn’t. Teachers move year groups all the time, and you can’t base two years of study on who’s taking the class this term.
We submitted the form last week. Sam picked art, media, design technology, and PE. No geography, no French, which is what I would have pushed him to do a few years ago, before I talked to teachers and other parents who’d already been through this. I still get that little niggling worry sometimes, late at night, that we got it wrong. Last night, though, he called me over to his laptop to show me a short test edit he’d started for his first media project, of our dog running around the backyard chasing a squirrel. The editing was clean, the music fit perfectly, and he was grinning like he’d already won an award. He might change his mind next year, he might end up needing a subject he didn’t pick, and that’s okay. Right now, he’s not dreading the next two years. He’s actually looking forward to them. That’s more than I had when I picked my GCSEs, so that’s good enough for me.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Which Subjects Should I Pick for GCSE: Practical Advice From a Parent Who’s Just Been Through It