Why Can’t My 6-Year-Old Recall Schoolwork or Tell Me About Their Day? Tips That Work For Us
Last Tuesday, I leaned against the driver’s side door of my minivan, crumbs of a pre-pickup granola bar sticking to my leggings, and watched my 6-year-old, Jax, trudge across the school parking lot. Like I do every day, I called out “how was school today?” before he even reached the curb. He dragged his dinosaur-stickered backpack (it weighs roughly as much as a small toddler) up to me, shrugged, and said “fine.” When I followed up with “what did you do in reading group?” he just kicked a loose piece of gravel and said “I don’t remember.”
That night, his teacher sent home a note saying he’d stared at his phonics worksheet for 10 minutes that morning, unable to recall the three sounds we’d practiced together for 20 minutes after dinner the night before. I sat down with him at the kitchen table, pulled out the same flashcards, and asked him what sound “sh” makes. He blinked at me, twisted his dinosaur eraser in his hands, and said “I don’t know.” I felt that familiar little twist in my chest, the one every parent gets when you start wondering if something is wrong. That night I went to my local parenting group online, typed out my question about Jax’s struggles, and hit post. I got 40 comments back, half saying I was overreacting, half saying I should get him tested immediately. So I made an appointment to talk to his first grade teacher, Mrs. Hale, who’s been in the classroom for 22 years, and that’s when things started to make sense.
Mrs. Hale pulled out Jax’s file and pointed out that he aces his end-of-week quizzes, can retell the entire plot of his favorite cartoon word for word, and can build a 200-piece Lego set on his own without instructions. He just can’t pull up information immediately when someone asks him out of the blue. She explained that 6-year-olds’ working memory is still only about half the size of an average adult’s. That means when he’s spent six hours at school, holding onto new rules, new sounds, new lunch line orders, his brain is completely full by dismissal. Asking him to dump all of that out immediately when he sees you is like asking you to recite all the work emails you answered that day before you’ve even had your first sip of after-work coffee. Most of us couldn’t do that either.
We started making small, low-effort changes to our routine right away, and I was surprised how much of a difference they made. First, we nixed the post-pickup interrogation entirely. I used to fire questions at him the second he got in the car, because I was dying to know how his day went. Now, I don’t ask any big questions for the first 15 minutes. We turn on his favorite silly road trip playlist, he eats his fruit snack, and he can zone out if he wants. Some days he’ll start talking on his own, some days he just stares out the window at the cows passing by. No pressure. That one change alone cut down on my after-school frustration more than I expected.
Second, when I do ask questions to get him talking, I don’t ask broad ones. Instead of “what did you do today?” I ask tiny, specific questions that don’t take much effort to recall. Instead of “how was recess?” I ask “did you play on the swings today?” Instead of “what did you learn in math?” I ask “was your math worksheet yellow or blue?” It sounds silly, but it works. Last week, I asked him the worksheet color question, and he said “green! We got to count candy corn and I got to put three extra in my pocket after.” Then he went on to tell me how his friend dropped his whole bag of candy corn down the bathroom drain, and how the whole class crowded around to help fish it out. That’s more than he’s ever told me about his day in one go.
For homework recall, we made two more small changes. First, we don’t do homework right after school anymore. We used to get it done the second we walked in the door, but now he spends 20 minutes running around the backyard chasing our cat before we sit down. His brain gets to empty out a little, so it has space to pull up what he learned that day. Second, when he gets stuck and says he can’t remember, I don’t say “think hard” or “you learned this this morning.” I give him a tiny, tiny cue. If he can’t remember the vowel sound they practiced, I say “is that the sound that starts with octopus?” not the actual sound. That’s just enough of a nudge for his brain to find the information it already has, instead of freezing up because he’s worried he’ll get it wrong.
It’s not fixed, obviously. Some days we’re running late, I forget the 15-minute no-questions rule, and we end up with a kid shrugging in the backseat and a frustrated parent in the front. Some nights, he still can’t recall a single thing he learned that day, even after a run around the yard and a full snack. Mrs. Hale told me some kids just grow into this skill slower than others, and as long as he’s retaining information by the end of the week (which he does) there’s nothing to worry about. I still get that little twist of anxiety sometimes, when other parents at pickup talk about their kids coming home and reciting their entire day lesson by lesson. But now I just remind myself that my kid can tell me every character’s name in Bluey, can remember where we hid his Halloween costume three months ago, he just can’t pull it all up on command 10 minutes after the final bell. It’s working for us, slow as it goes.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Can’t My 6-Year-Old Recall Schoolwork or Tell Me About Their Day