Why I Feel Sad About My Struggling 5-Year-Old (And What I’m Trying That Works)
I’m leaning against the chipped brick wall outside my daughter Lila’s kindergarten door every afternoon, holding the same lemon poppyseed granola bar she asks for, and last Monday I watched her trudge out 10 minutes after the first group of kids. Her backpack was unzipped, a crumpled sheet of construction paper peeking out, and she didn’t wave or run like she did the first month of school. She just stared at her sneakers until I held out my hand.
We got to the car, buckled up, and she pulled that crumpled paper out. The whole class had drawn self-portraits with big suns in the corner, and Lila’s sun was a mess of wobbly lines that overlapped each other. “I can’t do circles,” she said, her voice wobbly. “Everyone else’s circles are round. Ms. Rosa had to help me three times. I don’t want to draw ever again.”
I squeezed her hand across the center console, and that old familiar ache settled in my chest. I’d known for a while she was struggling. Parent-teacher conferences two weeks before had ended with her teacher telling me she sits out cutting activities, refuses to join playdough time, says her hands “feel like jello” when she tries to hold a pencil. I’d nodded and said she’s got a late December birthday, she’s just the youngest in class, she’ll catch up. But sitting there in the parking lot, watching her crumple the paper even smaller so I couldn’t see it, I couldn’t lie to myself anymore. I was sad. Not just sad that she was hurt, but sad that this easy, fun kindergarten thing I’d imagined wasn’t the reality we got.
That night I scrolled Google until my eyes burned, then texted my friend Jen, who works as an occupational therapist at a different elementary school, and asked if she could come over for coffee that weekend. She showed up with glazed donuts, looked at the stack of Lila’s crumpled drawings I pulled out of the trash, and listened while I cried a little about how I didn’t know what to do.
Jen didn’t give me that vague “just be supportive” stuff everyone else says. She gave me specific small things to change, starting with what I say when Lila gets upset. She explained that when I jump in to say “it’s okay, your drawing is pretty!” that makes Lila think her frustration is wrong, that I’m not taking how she feels seriously. Instead, I should just name the feeling plainly: “Drawing circles is really hard right now, that feels so frustrating.” I tried that the next night when Lila got upset trying to put a sticker on her water bottle and it tore, and instead of her running to her room and shutting the door, she nodded and said “yeah, it does” and let me help her peel a new one. It worked faster than I expected.
Next, she said fine motor practice doesn’t have to be tracing worksheets or 10 minutes of forced sitting and coloring every night, that just makes kids hate anything related to drawing or cutting. Instead, build hand strength into the stuff we already do every day. So now, Lila stirs the pancake batter every Sunday, no matter how much it sloshes over the side of the bowl. She peels all the fruit stickers off our grocery produce when we put it away, and we stick them on a beat-up notebook just for fun. She tears lettuce for salad every night, and crumples up old grocery ads to throw in the recycling bin. None of this feels like work or practice. It’s just part of our dinner routine or weekend breakfast. No grades, no pressure, just small, steady movement that builds strength without her noticing.
She also pointed out that a lot of kids with weak hand strength also get tired sitting crisscross on the rug or hunched over a tiny kid table for 20 minutes of work, which makes their hands even more tired. I talked to Lila’s teacher, and she agreed to let Lila stand at the back table when they do drawing or cutting. At home, I grabbed a $10 stepping stool from Target, so she can stand at the kitchen counter instead of slumping over her tiny play table when she wants to draw. It’s such a small change, but Lila says her hands don’t ache as much now when she’s done working.
Last week, after we stirred chocolate chip cookie batter, Lila grabbed a piece of construction paper and drew a sun for me. It was still wobbly, still lopsided, but she didn’t crumple it up. She carried it over to me, held it up, and said “I did that all by myself.” I didn’t gush about how it was the most perfect sun I’d ever seen. I just said “That took a lot of hard work, huh? I’m gonna put it on the fridge right now.” She grinned and ran off to grab a warm cookie off the tray.
Some days are still hard. Last Friday she came out of school crying because she couldn’t cut out a heart for Valentine’s day, and I still felt that same sad twist in my chest when I saw her rubbing her hand like it hurt. I don’t know if we’ll need to do formal OT down the line, or if she’ll just slowly get stronger as she gets older. A lot of people tell me I’m worrying too much, that all kids develop at different rates. They’re probably right, but that doesn’t make the sadness go away completely. It’s okay to feel sad when your kid is struggling, even if it’s something small that most people grow out of. The small stuff we’re doing is working, slow as it is. We’re not in a hurry to fix anything. We’re just taking it one wobbly circle at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why I Feel Sad About My Struggling 5-Year-Old (And What I’m Trying That Works)