Why kids repeat songs their caregivers sing: What I learned when my kids sang my husband’s songs to me
Last Monday, I came home from back-to-back meetings with a migraine that felt like someone was tapping a hammer behind my eyes. I dumped my work bag by the door, told the kids I was going to lie on the couch for 20 minutes before dinner, and warned them no yelling, no fighting over Lego, and no dragging out the craft supplies that leave glitter everywhere until my head stopped hurting. I’d snapped at my 6-year-old that morning for leaving her cereal bowl on the floor for the third day in a row, so I knew they’d be cautious. I fully expected to wake up to a quiet house and them parked in front of a cartoon, like they usually do when I’m under the weather.
Instead, I heard tiptoes down the hallway 10 minutes in. I opened one eye, and there they were: my 6-year-old clutching her worn rabbit stuffed animal, my 4-year-old with a half-eaten fruit snack still stuck to her chin, both in mismatched dinosaur pajamas they’d dug out of the clean laundry pile themselves. They didn’t say anything at first. They just stood at the end of the couch, looked at each other, and started singing.
It wasn’t any lullaby I’d ever sung them. It was the weird, meandering made-up song my husband created three years ago, when we got lost for 45 minutes on our first trip to the city zoo and ended up hanging out by the penguin exhibit instead of seeing the giraffes like we planned. He only sings it when he’s putting them to bed on the nights I’m out for evening work events, so I’d only caught snippets before. My 6-year-old remembered all the verses, even the silly one about the penguin that stole my ice cream cone. My 4-year-old yelled the chorus off-key, getting half the words wrong, and they both giggled when she messed up the line about the crumpled lost map. By the time they got to the end, I was crying. Not big heaving sobs, just quiet tears that ran down the sides of my face into my hair. They got quiet all of a sudden, and my 6-year-old leaned forward, touched my arm, and said “We did it wrong, didn’t we? Dad sings it when we miss you, so we thought it would help your head hurt.”
I told them it was perfect, that it helped a lot, and they ran off to turn on their cartoon, like nothing big had happened. But I lay there for another 15 minutes after that, thinking about all the little things I’d been overthinking as a parent for the last six years.
I’ve always been the one who keeps the routines in our house. I have a note on the fridge of the bedtime order: pajamas, brush teeth, one book, one song, lights out. I’ve read enough parenting posts to know kids crave consistency, so I’ve always been quick to step in when my husband does things his own way. I’d corrected his lyrics to common lullabies more times than I can count. I’d gone in after he left their room to straighten their blankets and swap the green one for the blue one they “always” use. I’d asked him to stick to the snack schedule I’d mapped out, even when he wanted to take them for ice cream on a random Tuesday. I thought I was doing the right thing, keeping things consistent for the kids.
That night, I realized I’d gotten it wrong. Consistency isn’t about everyone doing everything the exact same way. It’s about kids having predictable people who love them, even when they do things wrong or different. When kids repeat a song one caregiver sings to them, to another, they’re not just singing. They’re taking the feeling of safety they get from that song, and sharing it with someone else who needs it. That’s a social skill a lot of adults still struggle with, and my 6 and 4-year-old were doing it without even trying.
The practical takeaway, for anyone else who’s ever been the keeper of the routine in their house, is simple: stop correcting the small stuff. If your co-parent, grandparent, or babysitter sings the wrong lyrics, let them. If they use the wrong blanket, or let them have a cookie for snack once a week, or put their shoes on the wrong feet, step back and walk away if you have to. I started doing this six months ago, after that night on the couch, and the only change I’ve seen is more songs, more laughter, and less stress for everyone. I even started a little routine of my own: when I take the kids to visit my grandma, I teach them one of her old silly camp songs that she sang to me when I was little, so they can sing it to her when we get there. It’s become our little pre-visit tradition, and she cries every time.
Kids don’t need perfect, identical routines every single day. They need multiple sources of safety, and they need to learn that different people love them in different, equally good ways. Learning to carry that connection from one person to another, through a silly song or a shared snack or a bad joke, is how they build the social skills they’ll use for the rest of their lives. It’s not something you can teach from a book. They learn it by getting to have their own special rituals with each person who loves them.
I still slip up sometimes. Last week, I almost stepped in to correct my husband when he was helping my 4-year-old tie her shoes wrong, and I had to remind myself to turn around. It doesn’t matter if she gets to preschool with laces that are half undone. What matters is she gets to have her own way of tying shoes with dad, that’s theirs.
Last night, we were all cleaning up after taco night, and the kids started singing that penguin song again. My husband joined in, yelling the silly verse even louder than they did, and all three of them messed up the order of the story. I wiped crumbs off the table and watched them, and I didn’t cry this time. I still have days where I think I have to be the one who makes all the special memories, who does all the things the right way. I don’t think that instinct goes away completely. But now I know the best moments aren’t the ones I plan. They’re the songs the kids bring to me, that someone else gave them first.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why kids repeat songs their caregivers sing: What I learned when my kids sang my husband’s songs to me