Why I’m Sad My 5-Year-Old Is Struggling (And What’s Actually Helping)
I’m leaning against the chain-link fence outside preschool, sipping lukewarm coffee from a travel mug with a cracked lid that leaks onto my jeans every time I lift it, when my daughter Lila comes out. Her rain boots are on the wrong feet, her backpack is unzipped, and half her crayons have already fallen out into the fabric bottom. She doesn’t run to me like she did the first month of school. She stares at her scuffed toes, shuffling slow across the blacktop, and her teacher pulls me aside before I can even bend down to hug her.
Ms. Henderson says Lila still won’t join circle time most days. She cries when they pass out the tracing worksheets, and yesterday she pushed a little boy who tried to sit next to her. She says it’s nothing to panic over, just something to keep working on. I nod and smile and say “thanks for letting me know,” but by the time I’m buckling Lila into her car seat, my chest feels tight.
She chews on the frayed end of her stuffed rabbit Floppy’s ear the whole ride home, quiet like she knows I’m upset. When I pull into the driveway, I turn around and ask her what’s the hardest part of preschool these days. She shrugs, her hair falling in her face, and says “I’m bad at everything there.” That’s when the sadness hits me, hot and heavy in my throat. I’d heard all the lines about every kid developing at their own pace, I’d sat through the parent orientation where they said 5-year-olds don’t need to know how to read to start kindergarten. But when it’s your kid saying she’s bad at the thing she does every day, none of those lines feel real.
That night, I pulled out a tracing workbook I’d bought on a whim at the grocery store, spread it across the dining table, and asked Lila to try just one page. She stared at it for 30 seconds, then threw her crayon across the room, where it rolled under the fridge, and crawled under the table to hide. I stood there staring at the empty spot where she’d been sitting, and cried a little bit while she couldn’t see me. I wasn’t crying because she wouldn’t do the worksheet. I was crying because I could feel how scared she was. She used to cover our whole driveway in chalk drawings of rainbows and cats, but now she won’t even pick up a piece of chalk anymore, says her circles are “too wonky.”
I called our pediatrician a few days later, not because I thought there was something seriously wrong, but because I had no idea what to do next. She asked me what Lila loves to do at home, and I told her: she can spend 45 minutes stacking acorns we collected on a walk into piles by size, she can sort all 60 of her plastic animals by what they eat, she can sing every verse of “We Don’t Talk About Bruno” word for word, even the fast part. When it comes to holding a pencil, sitting still for 15 minutes, and naming written letters, though, she’s months behind the checklist the preschool hands out. My pediatrician said this kind of uneven development is way more common than parents talk about. Some skills zoom ahead, some creep along slow, and it rarely means anything long-term. What we needed to do, she said, was stop pushing and meet Lila where she was.
That’s when I started making small changes, none of which cost any money or take hours a day. I got rid of the workbook entirely. Instead, I weave little skill practice into things she already wants to do. When we make our grocery list before we go to the store, I write one item at a time and ask her what sound the first letter makes. If she doesn’t know, I just tell her and move on, no follow-up quiz. When we bake chocolate chip cookies, I have her trace the number of cups of flour we need in a dusting of flour on the counter. When we walk to the mailbox, we play a game where we point out all the red stop signs and read the first letter out loud. She never says no, because it doesn’t feel like work.
I also talked to Ms. Henderson about letting Lila stand during circle time instead of forcing her to sit crisscross on the rug. Lila’s always wiggly; she can’t hold still for more than five minutes even when she’s watching her favorite movie. Ms. Henderson agreed to let her stand at the back of the circle holding Floppy, and within a week, Lila started singing along with the morning songs instead of hiding behind the bookshelf. When Lila says she’s bad at something now, I don’t say “no you’re not, you’re amazing!” like I used to. She hates that, because she knows she’s struggling. Instead I say, “It’s okay to take a long time to learn this. I still take a long time to learn new things.” Then I tell her a specific, silly story, like how I fell off my bike last week when I was trying to ride it to the store, or how I still burn toast half the time. That makes her laugh, and she’s usually willing to try again, even if it’s just for a minute.
It’s not fixed. Some mornings Lila still cries and says she doesn’t want to go to preschool. Some days I still sit in the car after drop off and breathe through that sad, tight feeling in my chest, wondering if I’m doing enough, if she’ll be ready for kindergarten next fall. Last week, though, she came home with a drawing of our cat Mochi, and she’d written the letter M all by herself in the corner. It was backwards, lopsided, and the sides were way thicker than the middle, but she held it up to me and yelled “I did it!” That’s enough for me right now. We’re not in a rush to check off all the boxes. My kid is still here, still curious, still good at so many things that never make it onto a preschool progress report. And for now, that’s all we’ve got, and that’s okay.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why I’m Sad My 5-Year-Old Is Struggling (And What’s Actually Helping)