Why do new kids act out at school? A teacher’s real experience and simple tips
The air smells like wet maple leaves and grape cough drops when the 4th grade line trundles back from recess at 12:30. Javi swings a smooth gray rock he fished out of the playground mulch, Lila hops on one foot complaining her shoelace came untied, and Miles plants himself square in the classroom doorway, arms crossed over his hoodie, and booms “You shall not pass.”
The line stalls. A couple kids snort, others roll their eyes, and one yells “C’mon Miles, I need to pee.” Three weeks earlier, Miles had moved here from western Pennsylvania, after his parents split and he moved in with his mom. For the first two weeks, he’d sat in the back row, said three words total to me, and spent all his free time drawing Lord of the Rings characters in a beat-up notebook. This was his new thing: blocking doorways, blocking the water fountain, blocking the cubby row when kids tried to put their backpacks away.
The first time he blocked the cubbies, I’d told him firmly to move, and when he didn’t, I sent him to the office to cool down. He’d sat there silent the whole time, and when he came back, he didn’t speak to anyone for the rest of the day. His mom emailed me that night, frazzled, saying he did the same thing at the grocery store—planted himself in front of the cereal aisle, refused to move when she asked. She had no idea what had gotten into him, he’d been such a quiet kid before the move.
I leaned against the wall opposite the doorway that day, and didn’t tell him to move right away. I said “That’s a really good Gandalf impression. I saw the new movies when I was your age, I still yell that line at my cat when he blocks the couch.”
Miles’ eyebrows lifted a little. He’d been expecting a fight, I could tell. “You like Lord of the Rings?” he said.
“Sure do,” I said. “Problem is, all these kids need to get inside for math, and we’re already two minutes late. What if you step to the side here, and you can guard the door from orcs while everyone walks in? No orcs get past you, right?”
He nodded immediately, and stepped over to the side frame, still holding his arms crossed. As kids filed in, he muttered “You shall not pass” at anyone who made a face, and Javi played along, pretending to cower and saying “I’m just a poor hobbit, let me through!” By the time everyone was seated, Miles was grinning. I’d never seen him grin before.
That moment changed how I think about new kids acting out. For a long time, I would have categorized this kind of behavior as defiant, attention-seeking, something to nip in the bud. But what it really was, was Miles’ awkward, fumbling way of asking to be seen. He couldn’t walk up to a group of kids who’d known each other since kindergarten and ask “Can I play with you?” That’s terrifying for any 10 year old, let alone a new kid who doesn’t know anyone’s name yet. This bit gave him a ready-made role. Everyone got the joke, everyone interacted with him, and he didn’t have to figure out how to start a conversation from scratch.
The small, simple actions that worked here are things I share with every new parent and teacher I talk to now. First, if a kid is doing something disruptive that feels like a bit, not just a tantrum, don’t jump to correcting the behavior first. Acknowledge the bit. You don’t have to laugh it off if it’s disruptive, just name it. Instead of “Stop blocking the door,” try “That’s a pretty scary guard bit you’ve got going on.” It takes the wind out of the need to fight you, because you’re not telling them their whole thing is wrong.
Second, adjust the role instead of eliminating it. Miles didn’t want to stop being the door guard, he just needed to do it in a way that didn’t make everyone late. Giving him a small adjustment let him keep the identity he’d carved out for himself without disrupting the whole class. If you’re a parent dealing with this at the grocery store, you could say “You can be the cereal aisle guard while I grab the oats, then we need to move to checkout, okay?” instead of demanding they move immediately.
Third, pull them aside for a two minute chat later, no lecture. After math that day, I stopped by Miles’ desk and said “I saw a lot of kids having fun with your guard bit today. If you ever want other jobs to do, like passing out art supplies or leading the line, just let me know.” He nodded, and said “I like being guard.” That was fine with me.
A month later, Miles still breaks out the “You shall not pass” line sometimes, usually when someone tries to steal his spot at the four square court. The kids call him Gandalf Miles now, and he thinks it’s cool. He hasn’t blocked the classroom doorway in three weeks. Last week I saw him show a couple kids his drawing notebook, and they were asking him to draw Gollum for them.
There are still days he’s quiet, still days he sits out at recess and just draws. We don’t have everything figured out, and he still misses his old house and his dad back in Pennsylvania. But if I’d pushed him hard to stop being disruptive that first day, I don’t think we’d be here right now. Some behavior that looks like a problem isn’t a problem to fix. It’s just the first awkward step a kid takes to belong.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why do new kids act out at school