When Should Kids Start School? Real Lessons From a Mom and Kindergarten Teacher
Last August, I stood at my kitchen counter, smoothing crumpled sticker name tags onto 13 canvas backpacks. Twelve were for the kindergarten class I teach, the smallest had a peeling glitter T-Rex iron-on and belonged to my 5-year-old daughter, Lila. By the end of that first week, I’d wiped more nose bleeds and dried more tears than I did all of the previous school year, half of them my own. A week later, my neighbor stopped me on the sidewalk while I was grabbing the mail, her 4-year-old clinging to her leg, and asked the question I get at least once a month: “When do you guys start school again? And… when should she start? Everyone’s telling me different things about holding her back, I have no clue what to do.”
Our district’s kindergarten cutoff is September 1, so any kid who turns 5 by that date can start. Lila’s birthday is September 12, so we had the same choice hundreds of parents make every year: hold her back a year, or petition to start early. I’ve been teaching kindergarten for 8 years, so I’ve seen every version of this play out. I’ve had 6-year-olds who still can’t ask for a drink when they’re thirsty, and 4-year-olds who can calm themselves down after a scraped knee faster than some first graders. Age isn’t the predictor people make it out to be.
Last year, I had Javi in class, who was held back a year because his dad was worried he was too small for his age and wasn’t counting to 100 by his 5th birthday. Javi could tie his own shoes on the first day of school, something only two other kids in my class could do. But he cried for 20 minutes every day at recess for the first six weeks because he didn’t want to share his favorite dump truck with anyone. Mia, on the other hand, started this year at 4, her birthday 10 days after the cutoff, and her parents fought hard to get her in. She couldn’t unzip her own lunchbox for the first two weeks, and I had to help her go to the bathroom more than any other kid. But on the third day, she walked straight over to Javi, who was crying by the slide, and asked him if he wanted to build a road for his truck out of blocks.
We ended up petitioning for Lila to start this year. It wasn’t because she could count to 20 or write her name (the L is still backwards 9 times out of 10). It was because she’d been asking to go to big kid school for two years, ever since she started coming to my classroom’s end-of-year parties with me. She’d play school with her stuffed animals at home, making them sit for story time and pass out snack. I knew she was curious, and that mattered more than how old she was. The first week was messy: she cried every night because her teacher wouldn’t let her be line leader every single day, and she forgot her lunch box twice. I still caught myself overthinking it some nights, wondering if we’d made the wrong call.
The biggest mistake I see parents make is focusing on the wrong skills when they’re deciding if their kid is ready. Everyone worries about whether they know their ABCs or can count to a certain number, but those are things teachers will teach them once they’re there. The skills that make the first month go smoothly are all small, boring stuff you can practice at home without flashcards. If you’re on the fence, spend a week trying one simple thing: have your kid open their own snack bag and zip their own coat before you step in to help, and see how they do. Practice asking them to tell you what they need when they’re upset, instead of jumping in to fix it before they talk. Those are the things that make a bigger difference than knowing how to read a few words before the first day.
If you’re still stuck, here’s what I tell people to do: instead of asking your mom group or your social media feed, ask yourself three specific questions. Can my kid sit through a 10-minute story without wandering off more than once? Can they tell an adult when they need to use the bathroom or are hungry, instead of just crying? Do they choose to play near other kids at the park, even if they don’t talk to them much? If you can say yes to most of those, they’re probably ready, no matter if their birthday is a week or two on the wrong side of the cutoff.
And if you already made the choice and the first few months are rocky? You don’t have to panic or second-guess yourself every night. One thing that works for both my students and my own kid is to give them 15 minutes of unstructured time right after school before you ask anything about their day. I used to badger Lila the second she got in the car: “What did you learn? Who did you play with? Did you have fun?” and she’d just slump down and say “nothing.” Now, we get home, she gets her snack, and runs around the backyard chasing our cat for 15 minutes, and more often than not she’ll just start telling me about the day on her own. I also tell parents to ask their kid’s teacher one specific question at first check-ins: “What’s one small skill I can practice at home that will make their day easier?” instead of asking “how are they doing?” Most teachers will give you something straightforward, like opening containers or raising their hand to speak, and you can practice that in 5 minutes a day without adding extra homework.
This week, I dropped Lila off at school and she ran straight in to show her friend a new rock she found, no goodbye wave. Javi now shares his dump truck without crying, and Mia learned to unzip her lunchbox all by herself last month. I still don’t have a one-size-fits-all answer to when kids should start school. Cutoff dates are just arbitrary lines drawn on a calendar, age is just a number. Some kids are ready at 4, some need an extra year at home, and most of the time, whatever you choose, the first few months will be messy for everyone. I still have nights where I lie awake and wonder if we should have held Lila back. But last night, she brought home a drawing she made at school of her and her new best friend, and the L in her name is only half backwards. That’s good enough for me, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Should Kids Start School