What To Do When Your Kid Asks If They’ll Get Banned For Asking About Bullying
The gym was empty after back-to-school night last August, and I was stacking folding chairs when I noticed Leo still hanging around by the door, twisting the strap of his frayed Minecraft backpack so hard his knuckles were white. He was my 5th grader the year before, starting middle school this year, and he’d hung back after his mom finished chatting with his new homeroom teacher. I wiped a smudge of popsicle stickiness off my jeans and asked if he needed anything. He shifted his weight, stared at his scuffed sneakers, and mumbled, “If I ask my new teacher if I’m gonna get bullied this year… will I get banned from school?”
I froze for a second, because that’s not the question I was expecting. I’d known Leo since September the year before, when he first joined our class and barely spoke, because his stutter gets worse when he’s nervous. A group of boys had teased him about it a few times that fall, and we’d sorted it out, but he’d been quiet and cautious ever since. I pulled a blue raspberry popsicle out of the cooler I keep for kids waiting for late pickups, handed it to him, and leaned against the wall next to him so I wasn’t standing over him. I asked where he got that idea.
He told me he’d seen a video on YouTube Kids a couple weeks before where a kid said he got kicked out of his after-school program for telling staff someone was bullying him. Then he remembered at the end of last year, the kid who got in a fight in the cafeteria got “banned from the lunchroom” for a month, so he figured asking about trouble before it starts gets you in trouble too. “My mom says don’t bring up stuff that makes people uncomfortable,” he said, sticky blue juice running down his wrist. “What if my new teacher thinks I’m looking for trouble, and bans me?”
I hear this a lot, actually, even if it doesn’t usually come out this blunt. Kids don’t just worry about getting bullied—they worry that asking about it beforehand will get them labeled as a problem, or punished, or kicked out of the space they’re trying to feel safe in. It’s not irrational kid logic, either. They pick up on all the small unspoken rules adults don’t even realize we’re teaching: when you tell a teacher someone teased you and get told “just ignore them” or “stop being sensitive,” that’s a lesson. When you ask an administrator about a bullying incident and get told “don’t gossip,” that’s another lesson. Kids connect the dots faster than we give them credit for: talking about bullying = bad = I will get in trouble for it.
A lot of adults would have laughed this off, right? Said “Of course not, that’s silly, don’t worry about it.” I almost did that, until I saw how hard he was squeezing that popsicle. So I didn’t. I said “That’s a really good question. It makes total sense to worry about that.” It sounds small, but just validating the fear instead of dismissing it immediately made his shoulders drop an inch.
I told him that I couldn’t promise every adult would react perfectly, because some adults do get uncomfortable talking about this, but I could promise him that asking about it doesn’t mean you deserve to get banned. Then we practiced what he could say, because giving him a script made it less scary. Instead of the jumbly “will I get bullied” question he was nervous about, we came up with a line he could use: “Ms. Henderson, I had a hard time with people teasing me about my stutter last year, and I’m a little worried about it this year. Can we talk about what I should do if it happens again?” He mumbled it through once, then said it again a little louder, and wiped his blue hand on his shorts. I told him that was perfect, and if anything went wrong, if his teacher reacted weird, he could text me or send me a note through the office, and I’d come sort it out.
When I walked him out to his mom’s minivan, he told her what he’d asked me, and she looked surprised. She said she’d known he was nervous about starting middle school, but he’d never mentioned this specific fear to her. She thought he was just worried about harder homework and bigger lockers. A couple days later, she texted me that they’d practiced the line again that night, and he asked his teacher on the first day of school. Ms. Henderson pulled him aside after homeroom, told him she’d already heard about his stutter from the office, and even gave him a quick pass to leave the hallway or the cafeteria if the boys who teased him last year (who were also at the middle school) got too close. He didn’t get sent to the office, he didn’t get banned, he just got a plan.
That’s the thing no one tells you about weird, off-putting questions like this: they’re never really about the ban. They’re about a kid testing the waters to see if it’s safe to talk about what they’re actually scared of. If you’re a parent or a teacher, there are three small things you can do that work way better than generic “you can talk to me” lines. First, when a kid says something that sounds silly or overblown, don’t start with “that’s crazy.” Start with “That makes sense, that’s a good thing to ask.” It takes 10 seconds, and it immediately takes away the fear that they’re in trouble for asking. Second, state the rule explicitly, don’t make them guess. Instead of “you can always come to me,” say “If you ask about bullying, or tell me it’s happening, you will never get in trouble just for bringing it up here. Even if I can’t fix it right away, you won’t get punished.” Third, if your kid is starting a new school or new grade, bring it up first. You don’t have to make a big talk out of it. You can just say on the drive to school: “A lot of kids worry about being teased when they start a new year. If you’re worried about that, we can ask your teacher what their plan is, no problem.”
I saw Leo at the grocery store two weeks into the school year, he was grabbing a blue Gatorade from the cooler by the checkout. He told me things were going okay so far. The boys haven’t bothered him much, and he eats lunch with a kid he met in art class. He still worries sometimes, he said, but it’s not the big, unnameable scary thing it was before back-to-school night. I don’t know what’s going to happen for the rest of the year, and I can’t promise he’ll never get teased again. But at least he knows now that asking for help before something bad happens won’t get him banned. That’s more than a lot of kids get.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What To Do When Your Kid Asks If They’ll Get Banned For Asking About Bullying