What To Do When Your 17 Year Old Wants To Return To School After Leaving: A High School Counselor’s Perspective
Last Tuesday, I was wiping crumbs off my desk after lunch duty when I looked up and saw Javi leaning against my office door frame. He’s 17, scuffed white Vans, hood pulled up over his dark hair, and a crumpled receipt sticking out of his jacket pocket. He’d dropped out 10 months earlier, after his mom lost her nursing assistant job and he picked up full time at the local auto shop to help cover rent. I hadn’t seen him in person since he left, except for a wave across the grocery store parking lot a few months back. He pushed off the frame when I saw him, shifted his weight, and said, “I want back in. Can you help me?”
I motioned him in, and he sat on the folding chair by the door instead of the guest couch—something most kids who’ve been out of school do, because they don’t feel like they belong in the nice couch yet. His hands were still streaked with gray grease from changing oil that morning, and he wouldn’t meet my eye when he talked. He said he could get a foreman promotion at the shop if he had a diploma, which would pay $4 more an hour. But that wasn’t the only reason. He said most nights after work, he and the other part-time guys sit around the break room talking about how they dropped out and wish they hadn’t. He missed getting to learn things that didn’t involve torque specs and oil change coupons. He was scared to ask, because he thought we’d tell him he messed up his chance already.
Most parents or teachers I talk to immediately jump two ways when a kid says this. They either gush with excitement and start signing forms before the kid even finishes talking, or they hedge and ask a hundred skeptical questions about whether he can handle it after being out for a year. Neither works. I didn’t do either. I just asked him three specific questions, right there, that I always ask kids in this spot. First, what schedule can you actually commit to, given your work and family responsibilities? Second, what’s one thing that made you leave the first time that we can change this time around? Third, how much homework can you actually get done in a week, not what the school handbook says you should do.
Javi came prepared with answers. He’d already talked to his boss, he could switch to closing shifts four days a week, so he could be at school by 9 a.m. every day, leave at 1 p.m. before his shift starts. The thing that broke him the first time was unannounced pop quizzes. Back when he was going to school and working part time, he never had time to study every night, and the quizzes would send him into panic attacks that made him leave early half the time. By the end, he just stopped showing up. And he can do 3 hours of homework a week max, between closing shifts and helping his mom with his little sister on his days off. No more than that.
I called his mom that night, and she sounded shocked. She said Javi had been talking about coming back for a month, but he was too embarrassed to say anything because he thought everyone would judge him for changing his mind. She’d assumed dropping out was a permanent decision, like a lot of parents do. The next day, I pulled Javi’s transcript: he had 14 credits, needed 22 to graduate, so he was 8 credits short. The standard route would be to shove him into full-time after-school credit recovery, which would mean 4 more hours of school a day on top of his 8-hour work shifts. That would have lasted two weeks before he quit. Instead, I talked to each of the four teachers he’s working with this semester and asked for one small adjustment per class, to fit what he told me.
His English teacher swapped weekly reading responses for one major essay a month, and agreed to drop pop quizzes entirely in exchange for take-home reading checks. His math teacher lets him work through credit modules during the school’s open free block after 1 p.m., instead of requiring him to attend every full lecture. All teachers agreed that any tests can be taken at home or during my office period, no unannounced assessments. We also agreed that if he doesn’t want to socialize with old friends, he can eat lunch in the empty conference room down the hall from my office, no questions asked. I check in with him for 5 minutes every Monday morning, just to ask what one thing we need to adjust that week. That’s it—no 30-minute check-ins, no big heart-to-hearts unless he initiates it.
This is the thing most people get wrong when a teen says they want back in. They act like it’s a second chance that the kid has to earn, by fitting back into the exact same system that didn’t work for them the first time. You don’t have to force them to catch up all their credits in a semester to graduate on time. Javi’s plan has him graduating in 18 months, which is fine—he’s 17, being 19 when you graduate isn’t a failure. You don’t have to make them tell their whole story to everyone, or force them to rejoin all the old social groups that might not work anymore. Small, low-stakes adjustments work way better than big overhauls.
It’s been three weeks now. Last Monday, Javi showed up with his hood down, and told me his first essay got a B+, and he ate lunch in the cafeteria with his old chemistry lab partner the day before. He still has bad days: last week he worked a 12-hour closing shift the night before school, fell asleep in first period, and his teacher just let him sleep, no detention. He had a panic attack before his first unit test, so we let him take it home two days late, no penalty. We don’t know if he’ll make it all the way to graduation. Some kids come back for a month and realize it’s still not the right time, and that’s okay too. But the first step isn’t to panic or celebrate. It’s just to ask the three questions, meet them where they are, and adjust what you can. Right now, that’s working for Javi, one week at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What To Do When Your 17 Year Old Wants To Return To School After Leaving: A High School Counselor’s Perspective