What I Wish I Knew Before Posting Another Parenting Question Online
Last Tuesday, I was leaning against my kitchen counter at 10:17 p.m., a mug of cold chamomile in one hand, my phone in the other. A hole gaped in the toe of my fuzzy sock, and there was a sticky applesauce stain on the counter right next to my elbow. Forty-five minutes earlier, my 8-year-old Milo had crumpled his spelling worksheet into a ball, thrown it at our golden retriever, and stormed to his room slamming the door so hard the magnet on the fridge fell off. I’d deleted three versions of my local elementary parent Facebook group post already, and the fourth was ready to go: “My son won’t do any homework, screams every time I mention school work, I’ve tried rewards and taking away screens, what am I doing wrong?”
I hovered my thumb over the post button for a full minute, then hit it. Within 10 minutes, 42 comments popped up. One person said I should get him tested for ADHD immediately. Another said I was too soft, and I needed to follow through with consequences every single time. A woman said her kid acted the exact same way and it was all food dyes, cut out red dye and you’ll see a change in a week. Someone else said it was because my 2-year-old gets more attention now, and he’s acting out to get a reaction. I read every comment, and left feeling worse than I did before – every suggestion felt like a judgment, like I’d missed some obvious step that all other parents already knew.
Then I saw a comment from a woman named Carol, who said she taught 3rd grade at the same school. All she wrote was, “Can I ask how much work he’s supposed to have each night, and how long he can focus on things he likes?” I answered her: 30 minutes total of homework a night, he can build Legos or play Roblox for an hour straight without stopping. That led to a quick back and forth, and she pointed out I hadn’t mentioned any of the small changes that had happened that month: I’d started working later shifts, so homework time was now right when I walked in the door, when I was still checking work emails and rushing to get dinner on the table. The school had just switched from daily homework to 3-day packets, and I’d been making him finish the whole packet the first night it came home so it wouldn’t hang over our weekend. He’d just gotten new glasses two weeks earlier, and he’d been complaining they hurt his eyes but I’d told him he just needed to get used to them.
None of those details made it into my post. When I’m frustrated and tired, I boil my messy, specific problem down into a generic little package for strangers to solve. That’s when I realized I’d been doing this for years – with toddler sleep, with hitting, with picky eating – every time something felt off, I ran to the internet before I sorted it out for myself.
Now, before I type up any question post, I do three quick things that take less than 10 minutes, and more often than not, I end up not posting at all. First, I open my notes app and write down only what actually happened, no emotional labels. Instead of “Milo is defiant and hates school,” I write “Milo crumpled worksheet, yelled, left the room. This has happened 3 out of 4 nights this week. Last week it happened once.” That separates what I’m seeing from the story I’m telling myself about what it means. Second, I list every small change that’s happened in the last month, even the ones that feel too minor to matter. New glasses, new homework schedule, my shifted work hours, the 2-year-old’s new playgroup that throws off our whole afternoon routine. Almost always, one of those small changes lines right up with when the problem started. Third, I pick one tiny adjustment to try for three days, based on what I just wrote down. For Milo, that was splitting the packet into one night’s work at a time, putting my phone away for the first 10 minutes of homework to sit with him, and letting him take a 2-minute glasses break mid-work if his eyes hurt.
By the end of that first week, we only had one homework meltdown, not three. It wasn’t perfect, but it was a huge shift. I thought back to when my 2-year-old was hitting every time we went to the playground, and I posted that same generic question: “My toddler hits everyone, what do I do?” I got 100 comments saying ignore it, he’s doing it for attention. I didn’t mention he only hit when we’d been there for more than 45 minutes, and he couldn’t yet say he was tired and ready to go home. If I’d done this little exercise back then, I would have figured out to leave 15 minutes earlier before he hit that tired wall, instead of standing around ignoring him while he got more and more frustrated.
This isn’t to say online parent groups are useless. I’ve gotten great recommendations for allergists and speech therapists, I’ve swapped tips for cheap winter coats and good potty training books, and when I’ve done my three steps and still don’t have an answer, posting has helped me a lot. The problem is when we post first, and sort through our own mess later. Strangers can only give generic answers to generic questions, and most of the time, the answer is hiding in the messy little details you leave out when you’re typing late at night.
I still get frustrated. Last week, Milo had a screaming meltdown over brushing his teeth, and I opened the group app before I even thought. I started typing, then closed it, pulled up my notes, and did my three steps. Turned out his toothbrush bristles had been worn down for two weeks, and the hard plastic was rubbing his gums. I bought a new one that night, and we haven’t had a teeth-brushing meltdown since. I still post questions sometimes, when I’ve tried my small steps and nothing changes. But I don’t post first anymore. It saves me a lot of late-night overthinking, and a lot of unnecessary stress that doesn’t help me or my kids.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Wish I Knew Before Posting Another Parenting Question Online