What I Learned When I Chose To Get My Kid Expelled: Parenting Tips For Kids With Behavioral Needs
It’s 1:15 on a Tuesday, I’m leaning into the dairy case grabbing almond milk for my morning cereal, and the middle school principal’s name pops up on my phone. I don’t let it go to voicemail. I already knew my 8th grade son Jax had stormed out of math that morning after his teacher told him to put his sketchbook away. Three referrals in four weeks, all for walking out or shutting down when he got told to do something he didn’t want to do.
“What’s he done now?” I say, stepping away from the cooler into the canned good aisle.
“He pushed my arm when I tried to block the door on the way out,” the principal says. She’s not being harsh, actually. She’s been at this as long as I have, knows Jax has ADHD, knows we’ve tried every accommodation the overcrowded school can pull together. “District policy gives you two options here. We can do 10 days out-of-school suspension, go to the IEP meeting next week, and fight to keep him here. Or we can process this as an expulsion, and move him straight to the district’s self-contained behavior program. That’s the one you asked about three months ago, remember?”
I pause, stare at a dented can of baked beans. I’d spent weeks researching that program, bugging the special ed coordinator to tell me how to get Jax in. The school had blocked it, said Jax didn’t “qualify” because his issues weren’t “severe enough” to pull him from general ed. Now the principal was handing me the key. I said yes. I got my kid expelled.
I cried in the grocery store parking lot after that call, ate an entire 99-cent pack of gummy bears I’d grabbed for Jax’s lunch, my hands sticky with sugar when I turned the key in the ignition. Most parents fight expulsion tooth and nail. I’d had three different people tell me I’d ruin his future, that an expulsion on his record would keep him out of high school sports, out of college. But what no one was talking about was that Jax was miserable every single day at that school. He was getting three detentions a month for sensory overload that the school refused to accommodate. He’d started saying he was stupid every time he got in the car after school. Staying there wasn’t doing him any favors, no matter what the paperwork said.
After the meeting, when everything was finalized, I got a lot of weird questions from neighbors and family. My sister-in-law asked if I was just giving up on him. A mom from the PTA crossed the street to avoid talking to me at the grocery store a week later. I came up with a one-sentence script I use now, no extra explanation needed: “Jax needed a different kind of classroom than what our neighborhood school could give him.” It shuts down most unwanted questions, and I don’t have to rehash the whole messy story every time I run into someone at the post office.
If you’re a parent sitting where I was a year ago, here’s the thing no one tells you: districts don’t advertise alternative placements, but they’re required by law to offer them for kids who can’t handle general ed. A lot of schools will just keep your kid on repeated informal suspensions, where they sit at home day after day, because that doesn’t hurt their school’s discipline stats. If that’s happening to you, you can request a formal expulsion to get access to the program your kid actually needs. I brought a three-page list of every referral, every email I’d sent asking for accommodations, every time Jax came home saying he wanted to skip school, to the IEP meeting. That made it impossible for the district to say there wasn’t a need for a different placement.
When I talked to Jax about the expulsion, I didn’t frame it as a punishment. I didn’t say “you got kicked out because you were bad.” I said, “The old school didn’t have a quiet place for you to go when you’re overwhelmed, and the classes are too big. The new school has that, so we’re going there.” That’s all I said. He didn’t take it as a shame thing, because I didn’t treat it like one.
It’s not a perfect fix. Jax still has bad days. Last month he got into a shoving match with another kid over a video game controller during free period, and he had to sit out the end-of-semester bowling trip. He still gets overwhelmed by group projects, still forgets to turn in homework half the time. But he packs his own backpack the night before now. He used to fake a stomach ache every single Monday to get out of going. The new school has 8 kids in his class, one full-time teacher, one aide, and a quiet room with bean bags and fidget spinners he can go to whenever he feels his temper rising. No one yells at him for leaving the room. He got a B on his first history project about World War II tanks last month, and he taped it to the front of the fridge, right next to my grocery list.
I still don’t know what high school will look like for him. We’ll reevaluate next year, see if he can handle partial general ed, or if he stays in the alternative program all the way through. People still act like this is a failure on my part, like I should have tried harder to fix Jax at the neighborhood school. But I didn’t need to fix Jax. I just needed to get him into a place that worked for him. Sometimes that means doing the thing everyone says you shouldn’t do, the thing that feels scary and wrong at first. Sometimes getting expelled is the best thing that can happen.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Learned When I Chose To Get My Kid Expelled: Parenting Tips For Kids With Behavioral Needs