What Do You Do When A Kid Refuses To Do School Work? A Teacher’s Real Experience
It’s 9:17 a.m. in my third grade classroom, the projector glows with five math warm-up problems, and there are still Goldfish crumbs on the rug from morning snack that I didn’t get to sweep. Every kid pulls out their whiteboard except for Milo, who’s slouched in his chair with his dinosaur hood pulled over his eyes, arms crossed tight over his chest. I call his name soft, like I always do, and he just shakes his head. No eye contact, no snarky remark, just still.
A kid in the next row leans over and whispers “Milo’s in trouble” and I wave him off, turning back to check another student’s subtraction. Five years ago, I would’ve stopped the whole class to address it. I would’ve reminded Milo of our classroom rules, asked him why he couldn’t follow along like everyone else, made a big deal out of nothing that just made everything worse. But I’ve learned by now that work refusal is almost never about the work.
Milo’s been with me since the start of the year, the kid who brings a small plastic T-Rex tooth in his pocket every Friday for show and tell, who can name every Pterosaur species by heart. Two weeks ago, his parents split, he moved to a new apartment 25 minutes across town, and he missed two days of school for the move. We’d been practicing three-digit subtraction with borrowing those two days, and he’d come back lost, too embarrassed to say he didn’t get it.
When I’m done checking the first three rows, I kneel down next to his chair (my left knee cracks so loud he almost smiles under the hood) and whisper so only he can hear: “Looks like your pencil’s not feeling like working today, huh?” He pulls the hood down half way, eyes glistening a little, and mumbles “All these problems are stupid. I don’t get any of it. I’m just bad at math.”
I don’t tell him he’s not bad at math. I don’t tell him he has to finish all five problems to stay in for recess. I just pull a blank neon pink sticky note off the lanyard I wear around my neck, scribble the two simplest problems from the board on it: 15 minus 7, and 22 minus 10. I hand it to him and his pencil, and say: “Can you just do these two for me? If you get stuck, I’ll be right over by the reading corner to help you. No one else has to see your paper, I promise.” Then I walk away to help another kid who’s waving me over.
Two minutes later, a small finger taps my elbow. He’s got both answers right, written neatly in pencil on the pink sticky. I nod and say “That’s great work. Do you want to try one more from the board, or do you want to wait until after recess to do the rest?” He thinks for a second, then picks the third problem off the board. By the time we go over the answers as a class, he’s got three right, and he’s put his hood down.
I’ve had so many parents email me this month asking what to do when their kid just refuses to do homework or class work, and I always tell them this story first. The biggest mistake we make is assuming it’s defiance, that the kid is being lazy or trying to push our buttons. Most of the time, it’s either the work feels too big, they’re embarrassed they don’t get it, or they’re carrying so much other stuff (a bad sleep, a split home, a fight with a friend) that they don’t have any brain space left for math problems.
The first thing I tell people to try is remove the audience. Never call out a kid’s refusal in front of their classmates or siblings. Shame makes them dig in faster than anything else. If you’re at home, pull them into the other room for a minute to talk. If you’re in class, whisper or wave them out in the hall for 30 seconds. No one else needs to be involved.
The second thing is break the work into something so small it feels impossible to say no to. Instead of “you need to finish all 20 math problems before you can play,” try “let’s do the first three together, then we’ll take a 10 minute break.” Instead of “write a five paragraph essay for homework,” try “just write down the three ideas you have for your topic tonight, that’s all.” That sticky note with two problems didn’t sound like much, but it was way less scary than five problems on a big whiteboard in front of the whole class.
Third, name the feeling before you ask for work. When Milo said he was bad at math, I said “It’s so frustrating when you miss a couple days and everyone else already gets the thing, right? I’d feel that way too.” I didn’t fix it right away, I just let him know I got it. Most kids will try something hard once they know you’re not mad at them for feeling stuck.
I talked to Milo’s mom after that day, and she said he’d been throwing his backpack down as soon as he got home and refusing to touch homework for a week straight. She tried the small chunk trick that night, asking him to do just three problems instead of 15, and he did them without yelling. It was the first progress she’d had in days.
It’s not a perfect fix. Some days, Milo still won’t do any work. Last Thursday, he drew dinosaur fossils on his whole writing worksheet instead of writing his story about his weekend, and I just let him. I knew he’d stayed late at his dad’s the night before and only got seven hours of sleep. We check in for two minutes every morning now, he shows me whatever new dinosaur thing he brought, and we pick one small thing he’ll try that day. It’s slow, and it’s not the neat, perfect outcome people often ask for, but it’s working, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Do You Do When A Kid Refuses To Do School Work