Age-Appropriate Anti-Racism Resources for 5 Year Olds: What Actually Works
The splintered park bench outside my daughter Lila’s preschool was sticky with melted popsicle juice last month when she came bounding over, dragging a new little girl by the hand. “Mom,” she blurted, loud enough that the two dads playing frisbee a few feet over glanced over. “Why is her skin darker than mine?”
I froze mid-goldfish cracker bite. I’d seen all the posts talking about talking about race with kids young, I’d nodded along when my sister talked about raising anti-racist kids. But when the question actually came, out of the blue from my 5 year old, I had nothing ready. I mumbled something about how everyone’s skin is different shades, and it’s all good, then herded the kids back to the slide to play. After the new girl’s mom picked her up, I walked home with Lila chattering about the new monkey bars, and my mind spinning. I needed good, appropriate anti-racism resources for a 5 year old, and I had no idea where to start.
I spent three evenings after Lila fell asleep scrolling Pinterest and parenting forums, adding books to my Amazon cart and crossing most of them back off. Most resources I found fell into two buckets: either they were full of heavy content about racism and oppression meant for middle schoolers, or they were vague “everyone is special” posters that didn’t actually answer the kinds of questions 5 year olds ask. One highly recommended picture book opened with a description of segregation, and I couldn’t imagine getting through that with Lila without her getting upset and confused. Another had pages of talking points about systemic injustice that went right over what a 5 year old can grasp.
I texted my friend Jen, who’s been a preschool teacher for 18 years and leads anti-bias workshops for early childhood caregivers, and she set me straight right away. She said the biggest mistake adults make with 5 year olds is trying to teach the full scope of racism all at once. 5 year olds think in concrete terms: kind or mean, fair or unfair, cookie or no cookie. They can’t wrap their heads around abstract systems or centuries of harm. So the best resources for this age aren’t textbooks or heavy history books. They’re small, everyday things that meet kids where they are.
That changed everything. I sorted through the books I’d ordered, kept three, and sent the rest back. The first, The Skin You Live In, uses simple comparisons to food kids know (vanilla, coffee, caramel, chocolate) to talk about different skin tones. There’s no sad stuff, no talk of harm, just celebration of how different we all look. Lila loved it, and after the first read through she pointed to her arm and said “I’m vanilla! Zara from class is milk chocolate!” I just said “That’s right, all ice cream tastes good, doesn’t it?” She laughed and turned the page. That was the whole lesson, and that was enough. The other two I kept are Hair Love, a sweet story about a dad learning to do his daughter’s curly hair, and Julian is a Mermaid, about a boy who loves dressing up like a mermaid. None of them center hate or conflict, they just show different people living happy, ordinary lives. That’s what 5 year olds need to see first.
Books aren’t the only resources, though. I went through Lila’s toy bin a week later and realized every single one of her seven dolls had pale skin and straight blonde hair. I ordered two inexpensive dolls from Target: one with deep brown skin and braided hair, one with an afro. That cost me less than $30 total, and it’s become one of the best teaching tools we have. Lila runs a hair salon out of our playroom every afternoon, and she’s always asking why the curly hair feels different from her straight hair. I just answer her question simply, no big speech, and that’s that. It normalizes difference through play, which is how 5 year olds learn best.
I also started going to the free diverse storytime at the downtown library every Saturday. I used to just go to the one five minutes from my house, which is mostly white families like mine. The downtown one is run by librarians who pick great age-appropriate books, and it’s full of kids of all different backgrounds, skin tones, and abilities. It’s free, it’s an hour a week, and it’s the best resource I’ve found. Lila has new friends who look different from her, and difference is just a normal part of her life now, not something we only talk about in books.
I still mess up. Last week in the grocery store, Lila pointed to a Sikh man wearing a turban and asked why he had that on his head, and I almost shushed her because I was embarrassed. I caught myself, though, and I just said “That’s a special covering he wears because of his religion, it’s very important to him.” The man smiled and nodded at us, and that was that. Shushing her would have told her difference is something bad you don’t talk about, which is the opposite of what I want to teach.
I don’t have this all figured out. Some weeks we forget to read our new books, and I still catch myself shying away from questions sometimes. The big, hard history lessons can wait until Lila’s older, when she can process them. Right now, the work is small: simple books, diverse toys, a weekly storytime, answering questions honestly instead of brushing them off. That’s enough for a 5 year old. We’re just taking it one day at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Age-Appropriate Anti-Racism Resources for 5 Year Olds: What Actually Works