Why quiet kids hide learning struggles: Lessons from a 10-year-old student in rural China
Mid-morning sun slanted through the cracked classroom window, dust motes swirling around the chalkboard as I walked between rows of desks checking third-grade math work. I got to Xiao Ming’s seat in the back, where he always sat chewing on a dried wheat straw and staring out at the green rice paddies beyond the playground. His notebook was open, but the page was completely blank. “Can I see what you’ve got done, Xiao Ming?” I asked. He slammed the cover shut, shoved the notebook deep into his desk, and hunched his shoulders so far forward his chin almost touched his chest. He wouldn’t look at me, no matter how gently I asked.
I’d been volunteering at this small village school in Yunnan for four months, and 11 of the 18 third-graders were left-behind kids, their parents working factory jobs in Guangzhou or Shanghai. Xiao Ming lived with his grandma, who farmed half an acre of cabbages and couldn’t read a single character. I’d called his dad a week earlier to talk about his missing assignments, and he’d just sighed down the line. “He’s always been lazy. Just yell at him if he acts out, I can’t do anything from here.” I bought it, too, for the first couple weeks. I kept after him to turn in work, kept him in for recess once, and nothing changed. He just got quieter, and more likely to shut down when I came near.
The truth came out on a Tuesday when grandma had to stay late at the town market to sell her produce. Xiao Ming hung around the school gate instead of walking home alone, and I invited him in while I fixed a wobbly leg on the classroom bookshelf. I gave him a lemon biscuit from my bag, and we talked for 20 minutes about the stray dog he feeds behind his grandma’s house before I worked up the nerve to ask why he never writes anything in class. He twisted the frayed cuff of his hand-me-down sweater for five minutes before he whispered that he can’t read most of the words on the page. He’d missed all of first grade when he came down with bad pneumonia and had to stay in the city hospital for three months. When he recovered and came back to school, there was no extra spot in first grade, so administrators moved him straight to second. He never learned the basics of reading, and if he admits he can’t keep up, the other boys call him “baby” and tease him for weeks. So he just pretends he doesn’t care.
That’s when I realized I’d been doing everything wrong. I was punishing him for a problem he couldn’t fix, and I was calling attention to his struggle in front of everyone, which just fed the shame that made him hide in the first place. I didn’t make a big announcement to the class or pull him out for public special tutoring that would mark him as different. I just made three small changes, none of which took more than 15 extra minutes out of my day.
First, I started meeting him for 10 minutes before class every morning. He picks whatever book he wants from the donated book corner—he’s stuck with an old tattered picture book about a sheepdog that saves a lost lamb—and he reads one paragraph out loud. I only help him if he gets stuck on a word, I don’t stop him to correct every small mistake, because the point right now is to build the habit of reading, not perfection. Second, I write all the daily math word problems on a small index card just for him, with a tiny doodle next to each tricky word to jog his understanding, and he keeps it in his desk where no one else can see it. Third, I gave him a small scrap of whiteboard that fits right on his desk, and told him if he doesn’t know a word, he just writes it down, and I’ll stop to help when I circle through the classroom. He doesn’t have to raise his hand and announce he needs help in front of everyone.
Three weeks in, he folded his first full worksheet into a tiny square and handed it to me after class, then ran out to recess before I could open it. I counted when he was gone: seven out of ten answers were right. It was the first assignment he’d turned in since I arrived. Last week, he even raised his hand to read a sentence out loud during reading class. His voice was so quiet I could barely hear it from the front, and he messed up the word for “mountain”, but he finished the whole sentence. No one teased him. They were all too surprised.
A lot of people hear “help this kid in China” and think of big donations or new school buildings. Don’t get me wrong, those things help, but what most quiet struggling kids need more than anything is someone to notice the small shame they’re hiding, and make small changes that don’t embarrass them. This isn’t just true for rural China, either. If you’re a teacher or a parent with a kid who’s consistently defensive, won’t turn in work, or clams up when you ask about school, don’t start with punishment or lectures. First, pull them aside when no one else is around, and ask, “What’s the hard part here?” Don’t assume they’re just being lazy. Then, if they open up about struggling, give them private ways to get help that don’t single them out. You don’t need to rearrange your whole schedule or life to do it. A 10 minute daily check-in, a separate note with adapted work, a quiet way to ask for help—that’s enough to start.
Xiao Ming still has bad days. Last Monday, it rained all morning, and he left his whole notebook blank again. I didn’t push him. I just wrote the first word of the first problem for him, and moved on. His dad still hasn’t come home for a visit in two years, and his grandma still can’t help him with homework at night. He’s still a year and a half behind the rest of his class, and we don’t know if he’ll ever catch up all the way. But he doesn’t slam his notebook shut anymore when I stop by his desk. He just pushes it toward me, and points to the word he doesn’t know. That’s more than enough for right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why quiet kids hide learning struggles: Lessons from a 10-year-old student in rural China