The Common Parenting Advice I Ignored About Toddler Tantrums (And What I Wish I’d Done Sooner)
The cereal box teetered off the display and thudded to the linoleum, and I knew we’d hit rock bottom of our Tuesday evening grocery run. My 3-year-old Milo had dropped to his stomach mid-aisle, screaming so hard his whole body shook, all because I wouldn’t add a bag of neon blue dinosaur gummies to our cart. A woman with a canvas tote slowed down, gave me that tight-lipped look that says “I would never let my kid do that,” and I wanted to melt into the freezer section. I grabbed Milo under the armpits, hauled him kicking and yelling to the car, and lectured him the whole way about how rude and embarrassing his behavior was. Back then, I’d tell anyone who asked that tantrums were just misbehavior, and the only way to stop them was to hold the line and shut them down fast.
Six months before that grocery run, my sister-in-law, who’s taught 3-year-olds in a public preschool for 12 years, had pulled me aside at a family barbecue. I’d complained that Milo threw two or three tantrums a day, and I was exhausted. “Don’t rush to shut a tantrum down before it peaks,” she’d said, flipping a burger on the grill. “It’s not misbehavior. It’s just their little brain getting rid of a feeling too big for them to hold. If you let it run out, it’s over way faster than if you fight it.” I’d nodded and smiled, but I ignored her. I’d read half a dozen parenting posts that said letting kids tantrum unchecked taught them that screaming got them what they wanted. That was permissive parenting, I thought, and I was going to raise a kid with good boundaries, not a tantrum-prone brat.
That grocery store meltdown left me so drained I decided I had nothing to lose. Two weeks later, when Milo threw himself on the kitchen floor after I turned off Bluey before his second episode, I didn’t do my usual: I didn’t yell, I didn’t pick him up, I didn’t bargain with extra screen time later to get him to calm down. I’d already mopped the floor that morning, so I just leaned against the fridge, out of his kicking range, and said, “You’re really mad I turned off the show. That’s a huge, heavy mad. I’m here.” Then I shut up.
He screamed. He threw his favorite plastic T-Rex at the cabinet. He kicked the baseboard so hard I thought he’d hurt his foot, but I just counted the silverware in the drawer next to me and waited. Ninety seconds later, he stopped screaming. He rolled over, pushed himself up, and walked over to lean against my leg. “My tummy hurts,” he said, quiet as anything. I’d never had a tantrum end that fast, or that gently. Before that, every meltdown turned into a 20-minute battle of wills that left both of us crying.
I started to see what my sister-in-law meant that I’d missed before. The advice wasn’t telling me to give him whatever he wanted to avoid a tantrum. I still didn’t let him have extra Bluey, and I still didn’t buy the dinosaur gummies at the store. It was telling me to stop fighting the feeling before he could even process it. Little kids’ brains don’t develop the part that handles big emotions until they’re 4 or 5, at least. When they’re mid-tantrum, they can’t hear your lecture, they can’t make a better choice, they just feel everything all at once. Trying to reason with them before the feeling passes is like trying to turn off a fire alarm while the alarm is still going off—it just doesn’t work.
It’s such a small shift, but it’s changed our whole days. The concrete routine I follow now, the one I wish I’d started years ago, is simple. First, I check for safety: if he’s swinging his arms near a ceramic mug or kicking near the stairs, I move him a foot or two out of the way, that’s it. Then I say one short sentence to name the feeling, no more: “It’s really disappointing when we can’t get the treat you wanted.” No bribes, no shaming, no repeated reminders about the rule we already talked about. Then I just wait, close by, so he knows I’m not leaving him alone with the big feeling. Only when he’s calm—when his breathing is back to normal and he’s talking again—do we talk about boundaries. If he colored on the floor when he was mad, we clean it up together after, and I say “You can be mad, but we don’t color on the floor. Next time, tell me ‘I’m mad’ okay?” That’s the whole conversation.
Last month, we were back in that same grocery store aisle, and he saw the same blue dinosaur gummies. He asked for them, I said no, we have fruit snacks at home. His lip quivered, and I said “That’s such a bummer, huh? You really wanted those.” He stood there for 10 seconds, nodded, then said “Can we get the spotty bananas? I want to make banana bread.” That was it. No meltdown, no yelling, no cereal boxes on the floor.
I still mess up, of course. Last week I was 15 minutes late dropping my older kid at baseball practice, and Milo threw a tantrum about putting on his rain boots, and I snapped. I grabbed his boots and shoved them on his feet, and yelled that we didn’t have time for this. He cried all the way to the car, and I sat there feeling guilty, because I knew I’d fallen back into the old habit. It’s not a perfect fix, and it doesn’t stop all tantrums. But I wish I’d listened to that advice sooner. I used to think being a good parent meant stopping bad behavior before it started. Now I know it just means sitting through the big messy feelings with them, until they learn how to sit through them themselves. We’re still working on it. Some days are better than others.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Common Parenting Advice I Ignored About Toddler Tantrums (And What I Wish I’d Done Sooner)