The Common Parenting Advice I Ignored About Small Problems That I Now Wish I’d Followed
Last September, I stood at my kitchen stove stirring spaghetti while my 7-year-old Lila screamed from the dining table. She’d gotten a Lego friendship bracelet kit for her birthday, and one tiny 1×1 round brick wouldn’t click into place. I wiped tomato sauce off my wrist, walked over, and pressed the brick into place in two seconds. Done. Next. I got back to stirring, and she ran off to show her finished bracelet to our cat. No big deal, I thought. That’s what moms do, right? Fix the small stuff so we can all keep moving.
Six months before that, my older sister, who’s taught first grade for 12 years, had pulled me aside at a family barbecue. She said, “When the kids get stuck on something that’s not dangerous, don’t jump in to fix it. Wait 60 seconds. Let them try first.” I’d smiled and nodded, but internally I rolled my eyes. I had a full-time job, a mortgage, a dog that needs walking three times a day. I didn’t have 60 seconds to wait around while my kid cried over a stupid Lego brick when I could fix it in two. I ignored her.
Parent-teacher conferences came that October. Lila’s teacher pulled me aside after the 15-minute slot, asked if we could chat an extra five minutes. She said, “Lila’s such a kind, smart kid. But she won’t try anything that feels even a little hard. If a reading word has more than two syllables, she hands me the book and says she can’t do it. If her paper doesn’t fold right for origami, she crumples it up and waits for me to do it for her. Have you noticed this at home?”
That question stopped me cold. I walked to my car after the conference and started running through the previous week. Lila couldn’t get her lunchbox latch open after snack, I opened it. She fumbled with her rain boot tie, I tied it. She messed up a stitch in the bracelet she was making her best friend, I pulled the stitch out and re-did it for her. I was so focused on getting through the day, on avoiding the 10 minutes of whining that comes with watching your kid struggle, that I never let her actually struggle. I’d created the exact problem her teacher was pointing out, and I didn’t even see it.
I called my sister that night, admitted I’d ignored her advice, and asked what to do next. She said it wasn’t too late, you just start small, shift your default. So I tried her 60-second rule, but adjusted it to fit my life. The first change I made was adding five extra minutes to our morning routine. That way, even if Lila fumbles with her zipper for two minutes, we don’t miss the bus. I don’t have to jump in just to beat the clock anymore. That small shift took all the pressure off me to fix things fast.
The next change was simple: when Lila yells that she’s stuck, I don’t walk over and fix it immediately. I say, “That’s so frustrating, honey. Give me just a minute to finish what I’m doing, I’ll be right there.” Then I actually count to 60. Nine times out of 10, she’s figured it out before I get there. If she hasn’t, I don’t just do it for her. I say, “What have you tried so far? What’s another thing you could do?” instead of jumping to the solution.
A few weeks after I started this new routine, Lila was building a cardboard dollhouse for her doll out of recycling boxes. The low-temp hot glue (she uses it with me standing right there) wasn’t holding the roof up, and she started yelling for me. I was folding laundry, so I did my usual line and started counting. Before I hit 60, I heard her yell “Oh! I got it!” She’d propped the roof up with two extra cut-up cereal boxes from the recycling bin. It’s lopsided, it still falls over when she moves it too fast, but she built it. I would have just glued it the way I thought it should go, and she never would have figured out her own solution.
I used to think this advice was just about teaching kids to do chores or be independent. What I didn’t understand is that every time you fix a small problem for a kid before they even try, you’re teaching them something without meaning to: you’re teaching them that they can’t handle hard things. They start to believe that if it’s not easy the first time, they’re bad at it, and they need someone else to do it for them. It’s not that they’re being lazy. It’s just the pattern they’ve learned from years of small, well-meaning fixes from the adults around them.
I still break the rule all the time. If we’re running late for piano lessons, I’ll zip her backpack and tie her shoes without waiting. If she’s overtired after a bad night’s sleep and crying over a broken crayon, I’ll just get her a new one instead of waiting for her to fix the broken one with tape. It’s not a perfect rule, it’s just a default I’ve shifted. I used to jump in first, ask questions later. Now I wait first, jump in only if I really have to.
Last week, Lila’s teacher sent home a note saying Lila volunteered to do the hardest diorama project for their animal unit, all by herself. She said Lila told her “Even if it’s hard, I can try it first.” It’s a small win, and there are still days she sits at the table crying because she can’t get something right, and I have to remind myself to keep counting. I still wish I’d started this earlier, when she was younger, before the pattern was so set. But it’s getting better, one small unsolved problem at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Common Parenting Advice I Ignored About Small Problems That I Now Wish I’d Followed