What I Learned From My Kid’s School’s AI Music Video About The New Phone Ban
The car line at Westbrook Middle School creeps along even on good days, last Tuesday I was rolling the window down to let the cold November air in when my 13-year-old Mia plopped into the passenger seat, already pulling her phone out of her jacket pocket before she clicked the seatbelt. “Mom, you have to see this,” she said, already cackling.
She pulled up the video the school posted to their Instagram that morning, the official introduction to the new cell phone ban starting after Thanksgiving. The beat is generic upbeat pop, the lyrics are all about “locking it up to make some memories” and “friends don’t need screens to have fun.” Every person and background in the video is AI-generated: the hallways look just like Westbrook’s except the lockers are all the wrong shade of blue, and one student leaning against a wall has six fingers on his right hand. Mia paused it to point out the gym scene: the basketball hoop is floating a foot above the backboard. “They made the whole thing in an afternoon,” she said. “No one from the school even filmed anything.”
Over dinner that night, my husband asked what the actual rule is, and we realized the video doesn’t say much besides “all personal devices locked in lockers from 8am to 3pm, no exceptions.” The fine print is buried in a 3-page addendum to the parent email that I deleted after skimming the first paragraph. Mia told us half her grade is already planning to bring a beat-up old second phone to hide in their hoodie lining. They think the whole thing is a joke.
I got to thinking: I’m one of those parents that wanted the phone ban. I’ve heard enough stories about kids scrolling TikTok during math class, about cyberbullying happening in the back of the room during lunch. I’ve seen Mia zone out for 45 minutes after school just mindlessly scrolling Reels, so I get why the school wanted to do this. But this video was such a perfect example of how we mess up rule changes before they even start.
A week later at parent-teacher conferences, I brought it up to Mia’s homeroom teacher, Ms. Henderson. She leaned against the desk and shook her head. She said administration wanted something fun and shareable to get kids excited, didn’t want to wait for the school film club to squeeze it in between their own cross-country documentary project, didn’t want to pay anyone for it, so one of the admin assistants made the whole thing with free tools over a Saturday. “They thought it would go viral with the kids,” she said. “Instead all the kids are dueting it on TikTok making fun of how bad it is.” She already had four kids get detention for having phones on them, before the ban even officially started.
It’s not that the technology is bad, or that the phone ban is wrong. It’s that when we make rules for kids, we forget that the way we communicate the rule matters as much as the rule itself. An algorithm can spit out a catchy song and pretty graphics in a couple hours, but it can’t ask kids what actually bugs them about phones at school, or what parts of a total ban will make their lives harder. It can’t know that Mia’s best friend Lila moved to Oregon over the summer, and they text each other between classes to check in after panic attacks. It can’t know that half the 7th grade forgets their notebooks at home once a week, and uses their phone camera to snap notes off the whiteboard. None of that made it into the video, or even into the top of the rule sheet.
I’ve seen this same mistake at home, too. Last year I tried to enforce a “no phones after 9pm” rule out of nowhere, printed a little checklist, stuck it on the fridge. I was furious when I found Mia hiding her phone under her pillow a week later. Then I sat down and actually asked her why, and she told me her dad works night shifts sometimes, and he texts her goodnight when he’s on his break at 9:30. I never thought of that. We adjusted the rule: phone goes on the counter by my room by 9, she can come get it if she’s expecting an important text. That one small change fixed 90% of the pushback, no arguments, no extra work.
What’s the concrete takeaway for any parent or teacher rolling out a new phone rule? It’s three tiny things that take less than an hour total, no fancy tools needed. First, before you announce anything, pull two or three kids who aren’t the already over-involved student leaders aside—get kids that are quiet, that are in different grades, that have different needs—and ask them what’s hard about your proposed rule. The school could have done that in 15 minutes during lunch. Second, put your clear exceptions right up front, not buried in fine print. Instead of “no phones at all,” say “no phones in class, you can keep it on the nurse’s or homeroom teacher’s desk if you need it for a family emergency.” Third, add one small piece of actual kid input to your communication. Even if it’s just a 30 second voice memo from a kid saying “it’s really annoying when people text during group work, so I’m glad we’re doing this” that’s way more real than any generated video.
The phone ban started this Monday. Mia packed her old iPod touch in her gym shoe this morning, says she needs it to text her grandma when she’s having chemo appointments during the school day. She still pulls up the weird video to show every guest that comes over, pointing out the floating basketball hoop and six-fingered student like it’s a family joke. Ms. Henderson told me she’s started letting kids leave their phones on her desk if they need to be accessible for emergencies, a small change that hasn’t made it to the official rule book yet. More kids are following the ban than were during the pre-ban pilot, but there are still kids sneaking phones to the bathroom to check social media. No one’s talking about remaking the video. It’s messy, it’s not perfect, and we’re all still figuring out what works when it comes to phones and kids.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Learned From My Kid’s School’s AI Music Video About The New Phone Ban