Breath Holding Spells in Toddlers: Practical Advice for Parents and Teachers
I was stretching for a half-gallon of 2% milk at the grocery store when my 2-year-old, Leo, went quiet. I glanced down just in time to see his cheeks flush deep crimson, then fade to that terrifying bluish-purple that makes every parent’s stomach drop. He wasn’t breathing. A woman in the checkout line behind me gasped. “Do something!” she hissed, reaching for him like I was standing there doing nothing on purpose. I held my hand out to stop her, my own voice steady even as my heart hammered. “He’s okay. He’s having a breath holding spell.”
Six months earlier, I would have been right there with her, screaming for help. The first spell hit at a playground playdate. Leo had tried to yank a plastic truck out of another toddler’s hand, I’d stepped in to pull him back, and he’d gone rigid and blue in my arms before I could even finish saying “gentle hands.” I fumbled for my phone screaming his name, called 911, and sat on the curb sobbing while I waited, convinced I’d broken my kid. By the time the paramedics pulled up, he was blinking at me, chewing on the end of my sleeve like nothing had happened.
The next day we saw our pediatrician, who walked me through what was going on. 1 in 10 kids get breath holding spells between the ages of 1 and 5, she said, most often triggered by anger, frustration, fear, or even a sudden startle. The biggest myth she cleared up right away: this isn’t bad behavior, and it’s not a kid manipulating you to get what they want. Their nervous systems are still developing, and when a big feeling overwhelms them, their body’s breathing regulation glitches out. It’s a reflex, not a choice. She told me most kids outgrow it entirely by age 5, with no long term effects, but that there are small, concrete things you can do to keep everyone safe and cut down on how often spells happen.
The first thing I changed was how I reacted during a spell. I used to grab him, shake him, and blow hard in his face like I’d heard people suggest, which just startled him more and made me more panicked. Now I follow three simple steps, every time. First, I clear any hard or sharp objects out of the space around him. When a spell hits, most kids pass out within 30 seconds and go limp, so falling and hitting their head is the biggest real risk. Second, I lay him on his side, so he doesn’t choke on saliva if he’s out for a minute. Third, I kneel next to him and wait. That’s it. I don’t make a bunch of noise, I don’t pick him up and squeeze him, I just wait for his body to reset on its own, which it always does in under a minute.
The trickier part is how to respond after the spell is over, and that’s where I found a middle ground between the two extremes of advice I got from other people. One group told me to never give in to whatever started the tantrum, because that would reinforce the behavior and make spells happen more often. The other said I should give him what he wanted to make sure he feels safe. What works for us is right in the middle, and it’s simple. If I said no to the lollipop that triggered the spell, I still say no after. But I don’t yell at him, I don’t punish him, and I don’t walk away to “ignore the behavior.” When he wakes up, he’s always wobbly, disoriented, and scared, so I pick him up for a quick hug if he wants it, and I say the same thing every time: “That big feeling got too big for your body. I’m here. Let’s take a slow drink of water together.” Then we sit for a minute, and move on with our day. We don’t rehash the fight, we don’t make a big deal out of what just happened.
My sister, who teaches 2-year-olds at a local daycare, uses a similar simple routine for the kids she works with who have spells. She keeps a stack of soft foam mats near the block and sensory areas, where kids most often get upset, so there’s always a soft place to land if a spell hits. She tells the other kids simply, “Their body is doing a funny thing when they’re mad, we just wait with them until they feel better” so no one panics, and there’s no big fuss that accidentally draws extra attention that can make spells more frequent. It works for her, just like the quiet waiting works for me.
Our doctor also checked Leo’s iron levels early on, which is something most parents don’t know to ask about. Mild low iron is a common trigger for more frequent spells, and sure enough, Leo’s levels were a little low. We started giving him a tiny kid iron drop with his breakfast every day, and after a couple months, the spells went from once every week or two to once a month, usually only when he’s already tired and hungry. She also gave me a short list of clear red flags that mean it’s time to call a doctor right away: if a spell lasts more than 2 minutes, if he doesn’t wake up right away after he starts breathing again, if his lips stay blue for more than 30 seconds after he resumes breathing, or if he’s having more than one spell a week for a month straight. That list has helped me stop worrying about every little spell, because I know when it’s something that needs extra checkup.
Leo is two and a half now, and we still get a spell every few weeks. I still get that little twist in my stomach every time he goes quiet and red, it never stops being a little scary. I still get unsolicited stares and advice from strangers in the grocery store or the park. I know we’ll outgrow it eventually, but there are still days I’m tired of dealing with it. For now, though, this routine works. It keeps Leo safe, it keeps me calm, and it doesn’t require any big, fancy changes to our daily life. That’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Breath Holding Spells in Toddlers: Practical Advice for Parents and Teachers