Why K-12 IT Education Is Falling Short (And Small Things Parents Can Do To Fill The Gaps)
Last Saturday, my 13-year-old niece dropped her Chromebook on my kitchen counter, next to the half-eaten plate of chocolate chip cookies we’d baked an hour earlier, and sighed so hard her bangs fluttered. “I need help with IT homework,” she said. “I can’t get a good grade unless every single slide has a different transition and I change the bullet point style on each one.” The assignment was a 10-slide presentation explaining cloud storage. Seventy percent of her grade was tied to formatting rules. Only 30% mattered what she actually wrote about what cloud storage is or how it works.
I scrolled through her work and saw she’d already written all the content she needed: three short sentences on the first content slide that covered the basics. She was just stuck picking a seventh transition that hadn’t been used yet. I asked her to explain the difference between saving a photo to her Chromebook’s hard drive and saving it to cloud storage. She stared at me for 10 seconds and said, “Does it have something to do with the internet?” That moment drove home what I’d been noticing for a while: IT education in most public schools hasn’t caught up to the world kids actually live in.
I volunteer at my son’s middle school after-school tech club, so I get to talk to IT teachers regularly about what’s going on. Last month I had coffee with the school’s head IT teacher, and he laid it out plain. His job is 70% fixing broken Chromebooks and troubleshooting projectors for other teachers, 20% filling out district-mandated paperwork, and 10% actually teaching. The curriculum he’s required to follow was written in 2012, before TikTok, before ChatGPT, before most people carried a supercomputer in their pocket every day. He doesn’t have time to rewrite lessons from scratch, and if he strays too far from the district’s guide, he gets a formal note from administration. He’s not the problem; he’s just stretched too thin.
A few weeks ago I ran a 30-minute activity for the 8th graders in the tech club to test this gap. I pulled up three example emails on the projector: one was a real phishing email pretending to be from Amazon saying your package is delayed, click here to reschedule, one was a legitimate shipping notification from Target, one was a fake email pretending to be from the school office asking for your student ID and password to update your lunch account. Only 4 out of the 18 kids in the room correctly spotted all three phishing emails. Half of them said they’d click the link in the school email without a second thought. That’s not an exaggeration of how big the gap is: kids are growing up surrounded by tech, but they’re not learning the basic skills to keep themselves safe or use it effectively.
I don’t think we need to overhaul every family’s schedule to fix this for our kids, either. There are small, low-effort things any parent can do to fill the gaps, no coding experience required.
The first thing I do is carve out 10 minutes once a month to walk through one useful skill together at dinner or after homework. Last month, my 14-year-old son and I sat on the couch after dinner and adjusted his Snapchat location settings. I showed him how to turn off sharing your location with everyone who adds you, and how to only let close friends see it. This month, we’re going to set up a free Bitwarden account together, and I’ll show him why we don’t use his dog’s name plus his birthday as the password for every account. It’s not a big time commitment, it’s just 10 minutes once a month, and it adds up way faster than a semester of busywork.
If your kid comes home with IT homework that’s just formatting practice or other mindless busywork (which it usually is), you don’t have to fight the teacher to change it. Just add a 10-minute conversation after they finish to tie it to real life. When my niece finished that cloud storage presentation, after she got all her transitions right for her grade, we spent 10 minutes talking about what that actually means for her. I showed her the folder of baby photos I have saved on Google Drive, and the same folder backed up on an external hard drive I keep in my closet. We talked about what would happen if Google shut down my account tomorrow, and why having two copies matters. We talked about what information cloud companies can see in the files you save. It didn’t take long, and it turned a useless assignment into something that actually stuck with her.
If your kid is curious about building or creating with tech, you don’t need to sign them up for a $500-a-week summer coding camp to nurture that interest. My son makes fan edits for his favorite video game, and a few months ago we spent a slow Sunday building a free simple website on Carrd to post all his edits and connect with other fans. He learned how domains work, how to upload files, how to tweak basic settings to make the site look how he wanted. That’s a way more useful skill than learning how to change bullet styles on a PowerPoint slide.
I don’t blame teachers for this gap, and I don’t expect individual parents to fix the entire system. I know curriculum updates take years, and school budgets are stretched thinner every year. Last week, my son came home and told me he spent his entire IT period helping the teacher reset passwords for all the 6th graders after a district-wide login change. No learning happened that day, and that’s just how it is right now. We won’t get a perfect IT curriculum for most kids any time soon. But we can fill in the gaps, 10 minutes at a time. Last night, my niece texted me a screenshot of a phishing email she got in her student account, and she circled all the red flags: bad grammar, generic greeting, weird link. She got a B on that cloud storage presentation anyway, which is fine. But the thing she learned that Saturday afternoon, that’s the lesson that matters.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why K-12 IT Education Is Falling Short (And Small Things Parents Can Do To Fill The Gaps)