What To Do When A Quiet Kid Won’t Participate In Class: A Teacher’s Experience With A Migrant Student In China
The air conditioner in my third-grade classroom hums so loud some days it drowns out the readers, but I still heard the collective sigh when I got to Xiao Yu’s spot in the circle last September. It was our second week of co-teaching at a public primary on the outskirts of Chengdu, and I’d already learned the routine: when I called Xiao Yu’s name, he’d drop his chin to his chest, trace the edge of his workbook with a pencil, and not make a sound. That Tuesday, I asked him three times to read the first sentence on his page. The kid in front of him turned around and whispered, “He doesn’t talk. He’s dumb.” Xiao Yu’s ears went pink, and he pressed his pencil so hard through the paper it left a hole in his desk.
I kept him back after class, but I didn’t bring up the reading. I just leaned over his desk and pointed at the half-dozen tiny trucks he’d drawn in the margins. “These are really good. I rode past a construction site on my bike this morning that had exactly these blue dump trucks,” I said. He didn’t look up for a full minute, then he slowly slid the whole workbook across the desk toward me. That was the first time he let me get closer than three feet.
Over lunch that day, I talked to his homeroom teacher, Ms Li, who filled me in. Xiao Yu’s parents moved from a mountain village in southern Sichuan two years ago, opened a noodle shop half a block from the school. He started halfway through second grade, after his grandma—who’d cared for him in the village—got too sick to continue. Before that, he went to a school with 11 kids total, one teacher for three grades. He’d never had to read out loud in front of 45 kids, and when he tried the first month, a few kids laughed at his thick village accent, how he pronounced “sh” sounds like “s”. He’d barely said a word in class since. His parents work from 6 a.m. to 8 p.m. every day, they don’t have time to practice pronunciation or reading with him. They just tell Ms Li “he’s always been shy, just let him sit, we don’t mind if he doesn’t talk.”
I walked past the noodle shop that Friday after school, just to see. The air smelled like chili oil and garlic, his mom was wiping down tables, his dad was pulling hand-pulled noodles for a line of delivery riders. Xiao Yu was sitting on a wooden stool in the back corner, doing homework on a crate, a half-eaten plate of fried rice next to him. The TV above his head blared a cartoon no one was watching. No one was going to ask him to read anything there, other than maybe the order slip a customer left.
That’s when I stopped thinking we needed to “fix” Xiao Yu to get him to talk. A lot of people see kids like him and jump to tutoring, or testing for learning issues, or telling parents they need to spend more extra time helping with homework. But the biggest changes we made didn’t cost anything, and didn’t add extra work for anyone. First, I stopped calling on him in whole-class reading circle. Instead, I paired him with a quiet girl who sat next to him, who also drew in her notebook during recess. The rule was they only had to read their sentences to each other, not the whole group. If neither of them wanted to read out loud, that was fine too—they could just point and read quietly to themselves. That took all the pressure off right away.
Second, I stopped by the noodle shop one night when it was slow, and talked to his mom. I didn’t ask her to add 30 minutes of reading practice to their already packed day. I just asked if when they counted orders and closed up the register at 9 p.m., Xiao Yu could read the handwritten order slips out loud to them. It was something they were already doing, just adding one small step: let him read instead of her. She said that was easy, she’d been meaning to ask him to help with that anyway.
We did that for almost two months. No big speeches, no pushing him to “overcome” his shyness. One Wednesday in November, we were talking about our favorite things that go vroom, and before I could call on anyone, I saw a tiny hand creep up halfway along the side of the classroom. It was Xiao Yu. I called his name, and he said, quiet but clear, “I like the dump trucks that built the new road by our apartment. My dad drove one of those before he moved here.” That was all he said, then he dropped his hand and stared at his desk. The whole class went quiet for a second, then someone clapped, and I had to pretend I was looking for a marker in my desk so they wouldn’t see me smile too hard.
That’s the thing about helping kids like Xiao Yu, the ones people often write off as shy or slow. The issue isn’t usually that the kid can’t do the work. It’s that they don’t feel safe enough to try. People ask for help for this kid, that kid, like the kid is the problem that needs fixing, but most of the time the fix is just small adjustments to the space around them. If a kid won’t talk, don’t start with forcing them to perform for a whole room. Start with one person, whether that’s a trusted peer or just you. If the parents can’t fit big homework routines into their schedule, find a small 5-minute task that fits into what they already do every day, instead of asking them to add something new. Meet the kid where they already are—if they love drawing trucks, talk about trucks before you talk about reading.
Xiao Yu still doesn’t raise his hand every day. Sometimes when I call on him by accident, he still drops his chin and doesn’t say anything. Kids still tease him about his accent sometimes, though less than they used to. Last week he gave me a drawing of a big yellow school bus, with my name written on the side in messy, wobbly characters. It’s taped to my desk now. We’re still taking it slow, and that’s okay. Progress doesn’t have to look like a big, perfect breakthrough to matter.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What To Do When A Quiet Kid Won’t Participate In Class: A Teacher’s Experience With A Migrant Student In China