What Happens When A School Board Blocks A Student LGBTQ+ Club: A Parent’s View Of The King George County VA Case
I was sitting in the back of the King George County School Board meeting last October, folding my 14-year-old’s soccer uniform in my lap because we had a 7pm kickoff five minutes down the road. The room smelled like day-old coffee and the lemon Pledge the custodian uses on the meeting tables, and half the seats were filled with parents here to talk about the new GSA that 10th grader Lila Dorrier was trying to get approved. When Lila stepped up to the mic, her rainbow laptop sticker was peeling at the corner, and she kept one hand wrapped around the edge of the podium like she was scared it would slip away. She told the board she just wanted a space where LGBTQ+ kids could sit together at lunch, talk about what’s going on, and not get called slurs walking between classes. Before she could finish, the board chair cut her off. The rules had changed again two days before, he said. They wouldn’t be voting on any new clubs that night.
My 16-year-old son, who’s bi, was sitting next to me, and he squeezed my hand so tight I could feel his nail through my jeans. That would’ve been me, he mumbled. Three years ago, when he first asked about starting a GSA at our high school, I saw the same game play out, just slower.
The story here isn’t new, but it’s not an abstract political fight either. Back in spring 2023, Lila and her friends did everything they were supposed to: they got eight student signatures, found a teacher who agreed to sponsor, and turned in their application per the rules written in the student handbook. Back then, the policy said any student club with a staff sponsor and at least five interested students got automatic approval, no board vote needed. Two weeks after they submitted, the school board rewrote the policy to require all new clubs to get a majority vote from the board. They pushed that vote back three times over six months, then changed the rules again to ban any club that “promotes a political or social viewpoint” not explicitly covered by the state’s curriculum. That’s the rule they’re using to block the GSA now. Last month, Lila’s family and other local families joined with the ACLU to file a federal lawsuit, arguing the repeated rule changes are plain viewpoint discrimination that violates the First Amendment.
As a parent who’s watched this play out for my own kid, I don’t think most people outside of this get what this actually means for teens. A GSA isn’t some national political campaign brought into the school. It’s kids bringing cookies to meetings, talking about how to come out to their grandparents, helping each other change their pronouns on their school ID, and sitting together in the cafeteria so no one has to eat alone. That’s it. For teens, building that sense of belonging isn’t a “special interest” — it’s how they learn to feel safe enough to show up to class and do the work. When you block the only space they have to be themselves openly, you don’t make the issue go away. You just push it off school property, and you make those kids feel like the district doesn’t see them, doesn’t care if they’re safe.
I get asked all the time by other parents and local teachers what they can do, when they see this kind of thing happening in their own district, without having to quit their job or spend a year in court. The first thing I tell them is to document everything, right from the start. When my son first tried to start his club, I just screenshot the student handbook page the day he turned in his application, saved every email exchange with the administration, and wrote down the date and exact wording of every rule change that got shared at meetings. That paper trail ended up being the thing that got our local PFLAG involved early on, and it’s the same thing that made the ACLU’s case here so straightforward. It’s a 10-minute task that makes a huge difference later, when adults start claiming the rules were always that way.
For teachers who want to help but can’t risk their job sponsoring an unapproved club, there’s a low-friction workaround that I’ve seen work right here in King George. A teacher friend of mine at the high school couldn’t sponsor the GSA because she’s up for tenure next year, and she knew the board would flag it and hold it against her. Instead, she lets the kids meet in her classroom for 20 minutes before school starts, off the official school activities list. It doesn’t get funding or space at the school fair, but it’s a warm, locked room on school property where kids can be open before class starts, instead of huddling in a parking lot or a fast food booth in the morning. That’s a small change that doesn’t require board approval, and it makes a world of difference for kids who don’t have a safe space to be open at home.
For parents who don’t have a queer kid, the most useful thing you can do is show up, even for 30 seconds. You don’t have to give a big, emotional speech at the board meeting. Just get up and say “I have a kid in this district, and I want all students to have the same access to clubs, no matter what.” Or just send a 2-sentence email to the board. Most of the time, school boards only hear from people who oppose the club, so adding your voice even in a tiny way shifts the whole conversation. It doesn’t cost you anything, but it means everything to the kids who are watching to see if anyone has their back.
Right now, the lawsuit is still working its way through the courts. Lila and her friends meet every Friday at the Dunkin’ on Route 3, one of the moms brings donuts, and they sit in the back booth by the window. It’s not an official school club. They can’t put up flyers in the hallway, they don’t get to use the school’s audio system for events, but it’s still a space. No one knows how the lawsuit will go, or when the board will stop moving the goalposts. But what I’ve learned watching this is that kids don’t stop needing a safe place just because adults change the rules to keep them from it. And you don’t have to win the big fight tomorrow to give them that place today.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens When A School Board Blocks A Student LGBTQ+ Club: A Parent’s View Of The King George County VA Case