What Happens When A Middle School LGBTQ+ Club Gets Shut Down After Facebook Outrage
The text popped up at 3:17 on a Tuesday last April, from my friend Clara who lives outside Richmond, Virginia. It was a screenshot of an email from her 12-year-old Sam’s middle school principal: the Gender and Sexuality Alliance club the kids had asked for was officially approved. Attached was a blurry photo of Sam grinning, still in their soccer uniform, holding a homemade sign that said “GSA = SAFE SPACE”.
Sam had been talking about starting the club for three months. They’d been called slurs in the PE locker room twice that semester, and their teacher had just told the kids teasing them to “knock it off” without any follow-up. Sam didn’t feel comfortable bringing it up to the counselor, who’d also been their 5th grade teacher and knew them before they came out. They just wanted a room once a week after school where they could hang out with other kids who got it, no questions asked.
For a week, everything felt fine. Sam and the other two kids who signed up first worked on a flyer to hang by the cafeteria. Clara brought a pack of neon paper for them to print it on. Then one evening, Clara was scrolling through the local parent Facebook group— the same one everyone joins for PTA bake sale sign-ups and lost bike alerts— and saw the post. A parent from another neighborhood had shared the school’s approval email, with a caption that said “They are indoctrinating our kids before they even hit high school.”
The comments blew up within hours. Hundreds of them. People tagged the entire school board, said they would pull their kids from the public school if the club stayed, threatened to vote out any board member who supported it. One woman commented that her 6th grade son had come home talking about pronouns the week before, and this was exactly the kind of thing she’d worried about. No one mentioned that the pronoun talk was part of the school’s new anti-bullying campaign that the same PTA had voted to approve six months earlier. The outrage fed on itself, and by the end of the weekend, the local news had picked up the story.
Three days later, the school sent another email. They said the club hadn’t completed all the required procedural steps for approval, and they were shutting it down indefinitely.
Sam came home that afternoon, dropped their backpack by the front door, and said they didn’t want to go to soccer practice. Clara ordered their favorite takeout, and they sat on the couch watching old TikTok compilations, and Sam didn’t say much for three hours.
That’s when Clara called me, and we started talking about what this actually means for kids, parents, and schools right now. A lot of the conversation around this story has been all or nothing— either people screaming about indoctrination or people screaming about discrimination— but when you break it down to the level of a 12-year-old kid who just wanted a safe place to hang out, it’s a lot more mundane, and a lot more painful.
The biggest myth I see repeated about middle school GSA clubs is that they’re doing something inappropriate for that age. I talk to a middle school counselor here in my own town who’s run a GSA for six years, and she told me last month that the biggest project they did last year was organize a pronoun sticker day for the main hallway, and help an 8th grader convince their parents to let them wear a tux to the end-of-year dance. That’s it. They eat snacks, complain about homework, help kids figure out how to talk to their parents about their pronouns, and plan the occasional after-school game night. Most of the time, it’s just a bunch of kids who don’t fit in anywhere else having a place to be together.
The other thing that stands out about this Virginia story is how much power a small, loud group on Facebook has. Clara did an informal poll of parents at the school a week after the club was shut down, and 72% of the people who responded said they supported the GSA. But less than 10% of those supporters had commented on the original outrage thread, because no one wants to get into a screaming match with strangers online and have their personal information shared around. The loudest voices aren’t the majority— they’re just the ones willing to yell the longest.
So what do you do when this happens in your town? I don’t have a big, dramatic fix, but there are small, concrete things that work.
If you’re a parent whose kid’s club got shut down, you don’t have to launch a full school board campaign right away (though that’s an option for people who have the energy). Clara ended up just hosting a monthly movie night at her house for the kids who wanted to come. It started with three kids, and now there are eight. Most public libraries will give you free meeting space for a student group if you ask, too— you don’t need school approval to meet there. If you don’t feel comfortable hosting at your home, that’s a perfect low-key alternative.
If you’re a teacher at the school and you want to help, you don’t have to fight the admin to get an official club approved. Most schools let teachers host a lunch bunch in their classroom for any kids who want to join. You can call it a “social lunch group” if you want to keep it low-key. Kids can eat their lunch, hang out, talk about whatever they want, and it doesn’t require any budget or official approval. It’s not an official club, but it’s still a safe space.
And if your kid is the one who’s disappointed, don’t just tell them “those people are stupid” or “it’ll get better when you’re in high school.” That doesn’t help when you’re 12 and you just got told the thing you were excited for doesn’t get to exist. Instead, ask them: “What’s one small thing you want to do next, even if it’s just hanging out with the other kids who wanted this?” Sam didn’t want to protest at the next school board meeting. They just wanted to hang out with their friends and watch movies. That was enough, for now.
It’s been almost a year since the club was shut down. The school still hasn’t re-approved it. The Facebook outrage has died down, mostly, because people moved on to the next controversy. Sam and the kids still have their monthly movie nights, and more kids have joined from other nearby middle schools that don’t have a GSA either. It’s not the after-school club they wanted at school, but it’s their space. No one knows if it’ll ever be official at the middle school. For now, that’s okay.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens When A Middle School LGBTQ+ Club Gets Shut Down After Facebook Outrage