What to Do When Your Child Does Something Bad: Lessons From The Worst Thing My Kid Ever Did
The door to the middle school principal’s office smelled like old lemon Pledge and microwaved popcorn, and I was still replaying the voicemail in my head when I walked in: “Mrs. Hale, we need you to come pick up Leo. There’s been an incident.” My iced coffee had sloshed all over the center console of my minivan on the drive over, and I kept wiping my damp palm on my jeans, trying not to imagine the worst. Turns out, my imagination didn’t come close.
Twelve-year-old Leo and his best friend Javi had snuck into the 7th grade girls’ locker room 20 minutes before first period, pulled out permanent markers, and drew crude drawings on every mirror. Three girls had already changed for PE before anyone noticed, and two of them went to the nurse crying because they felt uncomfortable and unsafe. The school had to close the locker room for two hours while they sorted it out, and now I was here to collect my son.
Leo was slouched in a plastic chair by the secretary’s desk, hood pulled up over his curly hair, staring at his scuffed sneakers. He wouldn’t look at me. I didn’t yell right there, because I could feel my throat closing up, and I knew if I opened my mouth I’d say something I couldn’t take back. We just walked out to the car and drove home in complete silence.
When we got through the front door, I pulled two slices of bread out of the bag, slathered peanut butter on both, cut the crusts off like I did when he was little, and set one down in front of him at the kitchen table. I sat down across from him, and I just waited. After five minutes of him picking at the toast crust, he mumbled that Javi dared him, said he was too scared to do it, that he just wanted to prove he wasn’t boring. He said he didn’t think anyone would see it before it got cleaned off. He didn’t think about the girls changing. He just thought it was a dumb joke that only the two of them would know about.
I’ve had other parents ask me since what the worst thing my kid ever did was, and this is always it. It’s not that it was violent or life-altering, exactly, but it was mean. It was disrespectful. It was the kind of thing that makes you step back and think, did I do this wrong? Did I raise a kid who doesn’t care about other people? I spent that whole first hour after we got home going through every conversation I’d ever had about respect, every time I’d told him to think before he acts, wondering where I messed up.
Once I calmed down, though, we got to work. First, we got back in the car, drove to the hardware store, and let Leo pick out the strongest permanent marker remover they had. I made him pay for it with his own allowance. We went back to the school after all the kids had left, and he spent an hour and a half on his knees scrubbing every mirror. The custodian stood by and watched, didn’t offer to help, which I think was exactly what Leo needed. When he was done, his hands were chapped red from the chemical cleaner, and he was quiet the whole drive home.
Next, he had to write an apology. Not a one-sentence note to the principal. A full apology to all the 7th grade girls in PE, that the principal read out to the class after—Leo didn’t feel comfortable standing in front of all of them, and the principal agreed that was okay, as long as the apology was honest. He had to name what he did, say it was wrong, say he disrespected their space, and that he was sorry he made them feel uncomfortable and unsafe. That took him three tries to get right, because he kept trying to say “I’m sorry if you were upset” which shifts the blame, and I made him rewrite it to take full responsibility.
What I learned from this, that I pass on to other parents when they ask, is three small, concrete things that are way more useful than generic “ground them for a month” advice. First, always wait 10 minutes before you react when you’re furious. I sat in my car in the school parking lot for 12 minutes, actually, before I went in. I just breathed and reminded myself that this is a mistake, not a permanent character indictment. If I’d gone in right away, I would have yelled at him in front of the principal and his friend, and he would have left the interaction feeling ashamed instead of accountable. Shame doesn’t teach kids anything, accountability does.
Second, fix the harm before you hand out punishment. Most kids, when they do something bad, are already waiting for you to yell and take their phone. That’s easy, it lets them check the box: I got punished, we’re done. Making them fix the harm to the people they hurt forces them to actually engage with what they did. We still took his phone for two weeks, and he did extra chores for a month to compensate the custodian for his time, but the main consequence was cleaning the mirrors and writing the apology, and that’s the part he still remembers, not the no-phone rule.
Third, after all that, talk about the why behind the behavior, not just the behavior itself. We sat on the porch after everything was done, and we practiced three specific phrases he could use next time someone dares him to do something stupid: “No, that’s dumb,” “I don’t want to get in trouble,” and “Bet you can’t beat me to the gas station for slushies.” It sounds small, but giving him actual lines to pull out makes saying no way easier than just telling him “don’t give into peer pressure.”
That was three years ago. Leo’s 15 now, and he still makes dumb mistakes. Last month he got sent to the office for skipping study hall to get milkshakes with his girlfriend. I still get that cold pit in my stomach when I see the school’s number pop up on my phone. I don’t think we ever stop worrying that the next bad thing our kid does means we’re doing this wrong. But I also know now that the worst thing your kid ever does doesn’t have to break you, or them. It just has to teach you both something. Right now, that’s enough for me.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What to Do When Your Child Does Something Bad: Lessons From The Worst Thing My Kid Ever Did