Why Kids Insist There’s Only One ‘Correct’ Color For Each School Subject (And What To Do About It)
Last Tuesday morning, I was folding the week’s soccer uniforms at the kitchen table while my second grader, Milo, prepped his new spiral notebooks for the second semester. Crusty peanut butter crumbs still clung to the edge of the table from breakfast, my coffee had gone lukewarm next to the dryer sheet I’d dropped, and our beagle was gnawing on a lost mitten under the chair. Then Milo slammed his pen down hard enough to make the highlighters rattle.
“I don’t have the right green,” he said, voice cracking a little. “Math has to be green. Now my whole notebook is wrong.”
I blinked. I’d grabbed a pack of assorted highlighters from the grocery store the night before, and there were three different greens in there. “That dark green works fine, right?” I said, pushing it across the table. “Or you can use blue if you want. It’s just for labeling the cover.”
“No,” he said, shaking his head so hard his glasses slid down his nose. “Ms. Lopez said math is green. This one’s too dark. It’s wrong.”
That’s when I remembered: a month earlier, his teacher had suggested a color coding system to help the kids keep their notebooks straight. She’d listed an example color for each subject off the top of her head, and that was that. To me, it was a helpful suggestion. To Milo, it was a non-negotiable rule.
I texted my best friend Lila, who teaches third grade at the same school, to ask if she’d ever seen this before. She wrote back immediately, saying just last semester she had a third grader cry for 20 minutes because his mom had bought an orange spelling notebook instead of the yellow one the rest of the table group had. The kid wouldn’t use it, even when Lila offered him an extra yellow one from her closet, because the binding was the wrong shade.
At first I thought this was just kid stubbornness, the same kind that makes them refuse to wear the socks with the tiny speck on the toe or insist that chocolate milk has to be poured in the cup before the syrup. But after talking to Lila and thinking about it through the parent-teacher workshops I’ve sat in over the years, I realized it’s not stubbornness at all. It’s just how kids’ brains work around this age.
Between the ages of 7 and 10, kids are getting really good at sorting the world into clear categories. That’s how they learn to tell the difference between a verb and a noun, between a friend and a stranger, between what’s allowed at school and what’s allowed at home. Rules have to be absolute for them right now, because flexible rules feel messy and confusing. If a teacher says math is green, any other color breaks the rule, and the whole organization system feels like it could fall apart. It’s not that they care that much about the color of the highlighter—it’s that they don’t want to get in trouble, or do it wrong, when they’ve been told what’s right.
The first mistake I made that morning was brushing off his worry. I said “it doesn’t matter” which just made him more upset, because it did matter to him. Now I know better, and there are a few small things that have worked for us and for Lila in her classroom that don’t take a lot of time or money.
First, always validate the feeling before you problem solve. Instead of leading with “it’s no big deal,” say “it’s really frustrating when you don’t have the exact color you planned for math, isn’t it?” Just that one sentence takes away half the tension, because the kid feels like you get why they’re upset, instead of thinking you’re dismissing what matters to them. I did that with Milo that morning, and he stopped squeezing his pen hard enough to turn his knuckles white, just like that.
Second, keep a cheap emergency stash of supplies if you’re a parent, or extra supplies if you’re a teacher. I have a small bin in my hall closet with $1 notebooks, packs of loose highlighters, extra pens, and folders I picked up from the dollar spot at Target. It cost me less than $10 total, and it’s gotten me out of so many last-minute panics. If Milo absolutely needs the right shade of green, I can just grab it from the bin instead of running to the store at 8 p.m. the night before school. For teachers, Lila keeps a box of extra colored folders and highlighters on her shelf, and she lets kids pick what they need for free if they forget or don’t have the right one at home.
Third, if the hard rule doesn’t actually exist, test it together. After I validated Milo’s frustration, I said “What if we use this dark green today, and you can ask Ms. Lopez after morning circle if it’s okay? If she says it has to be light green, we’ll stop for a new highlighter on the way home from soccer practice.” He agreed, and that afternoon he came home laughing, because Ms. Lopez said she uses dark green for math herself. That small experience taught him that sometimes suggestions aren’t rules, and that it’s okay if it’s not exactly the same as what someone else said. Lila does this too now, when she introduces color coding: she explicitly says “this is just the color I use, you can pick any color you want for any subject. If you want math to be pink, that’s your math color forever.” She told me the number of meltdowns over supplies dropped by 70% after she started adding that one line.
It’s been a month since that Tuesday morning, and last week Milo came home and told me he switched his reading color from blue to sky blue because he likes how the pen writes better. He even pointed out that his friend has science as purple instead of red, and that’s fine, because it’s his notebook.
Last night, though, he refused to wear the new black soccer cleats I bought because all the other kids on the team have blue cleats, so they have to be blue. So the whole “only one correct thing” thing isn’t gone. It’s just part of how he’s growing up, sorting out the difference between rules and preferences, what’s fixed and what’s flexible. We just keep the extra highlighters in the bin, keep acknowledging the frustration, and let him test the rules one shade at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Kids Insist There’s Only One ‘Correct’ Color For Each School Subject (And What To Do About It)