How to help a quiet kid falling behind in primary school: a teacher’s real experience in China
I was shoving dried markers back into their cardboard box after after-school art class last October when I noticed 10-year-old Xiao Ming still lingering by the door. His scuffed blue canvas shoes were too big, and there was a small hole frayed at the heel of his white sock. He twisted the corner of his crumpled Chinese composition notebook between his fingers and wouldn’t meet my eye. When I asked if he needed help with homework, he just pushed the notebook across my desk. The assignment was “My Happy Weekend”; he’d written exactly two lines: “I helped my mom clean the noodle shop after closing. I was tired.”
Xiao Ming and his parents moved to Guangzhou from a small village in Hunan two years ago. His parents run a six-table noodle shop on the street behind the school, open from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. every day except Lunar New Year. He’s the quiet kid in class, the one who never raises his hand, who finishes his tests five minutes after everyone else and sits staring at the wall until the bell rings. Most teachers just mark him as slow, and I’d done the same until that day after class.
I called his mom a couple days later, caught her between lunch orders. She sounded harried, like she expected me to say he’d gotten in a fight. When I said I just wanted to talk about his homework, she sighed and said, “We know he’s not that clever. We don’t need him to get top grades, just enough to graduate middle school. Then he can either help us here or go to trade school for auto repair. That’s enough for us.” I asked if he ever talked about school at home, she said he mostly just sits on the stool by the door peeling garlic and doesn’t say much.
I started setting aside 10 minutes after class every day just to chat, no homework pressure at first. I learned he catches crickets behind the back of the noodle shop every evening after closing, keeps them in glass jars he salvages from customers’ takeout. He can name every type of cricket they have around there, tell you how to tell if a male will fight well. He once counted off 17 different ways to catch them without hurting their legs. That’s when I realized he wasn’t slow, he just wasn’t engaged with the work we were giving him.
A lot of the time when we talk about helping kids in China, people think of big donations or specialized learning programs for rural or migrant children. But the problem with Xiao Ming wasn’t that he couldn’t learn, it was that all our curriculum material is built for kids who go to the zoo on weekends, who have parents that take them to the science museum, who know what a “summer camp” or “family picnic” is — the things that end up in every textbook example. When the word problem asks about the cost of movie tickets for a family of four, he’s never been to a movie theater. He can’t wrap his head around the context, so he gets the answer wrong, and everyone thinks he can’t do math.
The first small change I made was his writing assignments. Instead of making him write about fake happy weekends he never had, I told him he could write about whatever he actually did that week. The next week he turned in three pages about his best fighting cricket, how it beat three other crickets last weekend, how he feeds it mashed mosquito larvae to keep it strong. I didn’t correct all his grammar mistakes at once; I just praised the parts that were vivid, and showed it to his homeroom teacher. She put it up on the classroom bulletin board, the first time his work has ever been displayed there.
For math, I started rewriting his practice word problems to fit his life. Instead of amusement park tickets, it’s how much change his mom should give a customer who buys three bowls of beef noodles. Instead of calculating how far a bike travels on a trip to the suburbs, it’s how many boxes of noodles he can carry from the delivery truck to the shop. He gets 8 out of 10 right now; he used to get 3 out of 10 before that. I also noticed the boy who comes to after-school class lives in the same neighborhood and also goes cricket catching on weekends. I just moved their desks next to each other, didn’t make a big deal out of telling them to be friends. Now they walk home together after school, talk about crickets the whole way.
For other teachers or parents who encounter a kid like Xiao Ming, the biggest mistake I used to make is trying to push them to fit the mold we’ve already made. You don’t have to organize a big intervention, or force them to be more outgoing, or hire an expensive tutor. Small, specific adjustments work way better. If a kid won’t write more than two lines, ask them what they like talking about for 10 minutes, then let them write that instead of the assigned topic. If they keep getting word problems wrong, read the problem out loud and ask them if they understand what’s happening in the story — if they don’t, rewrite it with something they know. If they eat alone at recess, look for one other kid that shares a tiny interest, not a whole group. That’s all stuff you can do in 10 minutes a day, no extra budget or special training needed.
It’s not a neat, inspiring success story. Xiao Ming is still near the bottom of his class in reading. His parents might have to close the shop and move back to Hunan next year if the landlord raises rent again, like he’s been talking about. He still rarely raises his hand to speak in front of the whole class, even when he knows the answer. But last month he brought me a small styrofoam container of beef noodle his mom packed for me, still steaming when he carried it over. He smiled when I thanked him, and didn’t run off right away. That’s enough for now. We’re taking it one 10-minute check-in at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to help a quiet kid falling behind in primary school: a teacher’s real experience in China