How to Manage Overnight Visits to In-Laws 90 Minutes Away With Young Kids
Last Sunday, I was wiping cherry popsicle juice off my leggings and shoving a tupperware of leftover banana bread into the back of our SUV when my mother-in-law nodded at my four-year-old, Lila, who was currently draped over her new golden retriever puppy, and said, “Why don’t you let her stay overnight? We’ll have her back by lunch tomorrow.” My six-year-old, already passed out in his car seat from three hours of swinging, didn’t stir. My husband leaned against the trunk and shrugged, one eye on his work email. Lila popped up, puppy fur sticking to her cheeks, and started begging so fast her words ran together.
I’d felt this same twist in my stomach a dozen times before. My in-laws live an hour and a half away, close enough that we can head up for a Sunday brunch and be home by dinner, far enough that an emergency trip back isn’t a 15-minute run. For the first two years they kept asking for overnights, I always said no. I made excuses: Lila still wets the bed some nights, she needs her lavender lotion to fall asleep, she gets confused waking up in a strange room. The truth was, I was scared half the time that she’d spend the whole night crying, and we’d have to drive 90 minutes in the dark to pick her up, and everyone would end up annoyed.
But that day, I said yes. I dug her stuffed rabbit out of her backpack, wrote down the time she usually wakes up, reminded my mother-in-law about the pull up in her diaper bag, and we drove home without her. The drive back was weirdly quiet, just my older son snoring and the radio on low. I checked my phone every 10 minutes, waiting for the call that would tell us she was inconsolable. It came at 10:15 pm, and when I answered, my voice was already tight—only to hear Lila’s sleepy mumble in the background, and my mother-in-law saying she’d just woken up for a drink, crawled right back into bed with the puppy, and didn’t actually need anything. We slept through the night, picked her up after breakfast the next day, and she chattered the whole drive home about how the puppy slept on her feet.
After that first time, we’ve done a handful of overnights, some that worked perfectly, one that ended with us driving up at 8 pm to pick up a feverish, crying Lila mid-cold. That 90-minute distance I always saw as an awkward middle ground has actually turned out to be a really good testing ground for helping kids get comfortable with separation from us, which I never would have expected. I’ve read all the stuff about how kids build independence through small separations, but I always thought that meant sleepaway camp or a night at a friend’s house when they’re older. It never occurred to me that these casual overnights an hour and a half away are the perfect low-stakes way to practice.
The thing that makes it work is that it’s not all or nothing. If we were across the country, we couldn’t just come get her if things go wrong, and that would feel too scary for all of us. If they lived 15 minutes away, I’d probably end up popping over every time she whined, and she’d never get a chance to work through being upset on her own. 90 minutes is right in the middle: close enough that even if it goes wrong, it’s just a three-hour round trip, which is annoying but not a disaster. Far enough that she can’t just demand I show up in 10 minutes, so she has to figure out how to calm down with my in-laws.
I’ve picked up a few small things that make this easier, no big schedule overhauls required. After the first time I forgot her lavender lotion, I packed a small duffel with all her non-negotiables—extra pajamas, pull-ups, her rabbit, the lotion—and left it at my in-laws’ house. Now I don’t have to remember to pack every single thing every time we go, I just swap out the pull-ups when she outgrows them. We also agreed with my in-laws upfront: there’s no such thing as a failed sleepover. If the kid is upset for more than 15 minutes, just call us, we’ll come get them, no one has to feel like they messed up, no one has to try to force them to stay to “be brave.” That takes the pressure off everyone, instead of my in-laws feeling like they have to fix it or I have to pretend I’m fine with my kid sobbing all night.
We also started doing practice runs before the first overnight. First time, we left Lila there for four hours after brunch while we drove home and ran errands, picked her up before bedtime. That let her get used to being there without us, and let me get used to not being there with her. I also make a point to tell her exactly when we’ll be back, not just “soon.” I’ll say “we’ll pick you up right after you eat pancakes tomorrow, after you feed the puppy.” Concrete timing makes it feel less like we’re not coming back, and more like a plan she can count on.
I still get that little twist in my stomach when they ask to stay, sometimes. Last month, Lila asked to stay two nights in a row, and I said no, because we had her dentist appointment first thing the second morning, and that’s okay. You don’t have to say yes every time just because it works sometimes. My mother-in-law still gives them three cookies for breakfast when they stay, and I still cringe a little when I hear that, but it’s one breakfast a month, it’s not going to rot their teeth permanently.
This weekend, we’re heading up again for brunch. I already stopped by the house last week to add the new size pull ups to the duffel and refill the lavender lotion. I don’t know if either kid will ask to stay overnight. If they do, we’ll probably say yes, and I’ll check my phone a little more than usual that night. If they don’t, we’ll all pile back in the car after eating, bring home the leftover banana bread, and be home in time for bedtime in their own beds. Either way, it works out, more or less.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Manage Overnight Visits to In-Laws 90 Minutes Away With Young Kids