Traveling With a Toddler: Is Business Class Actually Worth the Extra Cost?
The applesauce pouch split open right as they called our boarding group, warm sweet goo seeping through the front of my hoodie and into my carry-on, while my 2-year-old Leo tugged his hand free and made a break for the moving walkway. My partner grabbed him by the hood of his dinosaur jacket and nodded at the short business class line, 10 feet away from the snaking economy line that wrapped around the terminal. “Told you splurging wasn’t crazy,” he said. I wiped applesauce off my wrist and still wasn’t convinced. Six months earlier, we’d flown the same route in economy, and I’d left the plane with a cricked back, a public meltdown of my own, and a firm belief that any extra money for a seat was just a scam for anxious parents.
That trip, Leo was 18 months, just learning to walk steadily, and the man in front of us reclined his seat all the way back two minutes into takeoff, so Leo couldn’t even spread his board books on the tray table. He tried to stand between my legs and the seat in front, and his head bumped the plastic every time he moved. The woman next to me pulled her blanket a little tighter every time he fussed, and I spent an hour and a half holding him in the narrow aisle, my shoulder pressed against the beverage cart, while he chewed on my lanyard. We landed at 10 p.m., Leo screamed through baggage claim, and I didn’t sleep more than two hours that night even after we got to my parents’ house.
This time, we were going out for my grandma’s funeral, so we all needed to be functional enough to hug people and sit through a service. That’s why we’d bitten the bullet and paid the $800 upgrade for two seats, a cost that still makes my stomach twitch a little — that’s our entire summer camping grocery budget, for context.
The first thing that hit me once we boarded was the space. Leo didn’t have to contort himself to stand up and turn around. He could drop his stacking cups on the empty floor between our seats and crawl after them without kicking the back of the seat in front of me. When he got wiggly 20 minutes in, he walked up and down the business class aisle by himself, holding the seat backs, and only one person even looked up from their laptop. In economy, that same walk would have meant bumping every elbow and knee in a three-row stretch, and half the plane would have been watching us.
I got to drink a full cup of coffee before it got cold. That’s not nothing, when you travel with a toddler. He still had a meltdown when the flight attendant asked him to give up the extra cookie he’d stuffed in his pocket for takeoff, and he still spilled a full sippy cup of apple juice on the leather seat, and I still felt that familiar hot flush of embarrassment when it happened. Business class doesn’t fix toddler behavior, it just gives them enough room to be a toddler without disrupting everyone else within a 5-foot radius.
Here’s the thing I’ve realized, after these two trips, that a lot of parenting content doesn’t talk about: Toddlers can’t sit still for hours because that’s how their developing bodies and brains work. It’s not misbehavior. They need to move, to touch new things, to change position every 15 or 20 minutes, because their little muscles and sensory systems are still growing. Confining them to an 18-inch space between two seats for half a day is like asking an adult to do a 4-hour plank. It’s not that you’re bad at parenting if they melt down, it’s that you’re asking them to do something that’s developmentally really hard.
When it comes to business class, that extra space directly solves that problem, but it’s not the only way to solve it. It is worth it if you’re traveling alone with a toddler, if your flight is longer than 4 hours, or if you need to be rested when you land (for a work thing, a family event, whatever). If you’re flying an hour to see grandparents, it’s almost never worth it. If you can’t swing business class, the next best thing is paying $30 to $50 extra for a bulkhead or extra legroom economy seat. That gives you enough floor space for them to play with toys or crawl around, which cuts meltdowns way more than bringing 10 new screen time devices does. Another trick: keep your stroller until you gate check it, so you can walk them around the terminal for an extra 20 minutes before you board, to burn off that extra energy before you sit down. I’ve done that on short economy trips, and it works almost as well as extra seat space.
Last month, we flew a 2-hour trip to visit my sister, and we just got extra legroom economy for $50 total. Leo got wiggly halfway through, walked up and down the aisle a few times, and we landed fine. No major meltdowns, no sore backs, and we didn’t blow our vacation budget on seats. That worked for us.
Next year, we’re planning a trip to visit my partner’s family in Portugal, that’s an 8-hour flight over the ocean. We’re already setting aside a little money each month to upgrade to business, if we can. If we can’t, we’ll book two bulkhead seats, pack extra sticker books and snacks, and plan for a cranky day after we land. No matter what you book, every flight with a toddler is still a little bit of a gamble. Some days they sleep the whole way, some days they scream for 2 hours no matter how much space you have. Business class just tilts the odds a little in your favor, for a price. That’s all it is.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Traveling With a Toddler: Is Business Class Actually Worth the Extra Cost