Is a whiteboard unsuitable for high school? What parents should know
Last month, my 15-year-old son Jax hauled his beat-up 18×24 inch portable whiteboard into my mom’s kitchen, propping it against the breakfast nook table so he could cram for his algebra midterm while we went to an out-of-state wedding. The whiteboard has a faded sticker of his favorite soccer team stuck to the bottom corner, and it’s got faint old stains from half-erased chemistry equations along the edges. My mom leaned against the counter, sipping coffee from her chipped 1998 teacher appreciation mug, and shook her head. “That thing’s way too small for high school work,” she said. “You need a proper full-size whiteboard to get all those formulas and long steps down. This isn’t middle school anymore.”
Jax just blinked, twisted the cap off his dry erase marker, and said, “It works for me.” Then he leaned in and started scribbling. But the question stuck with me. My mom taught middle school math for 30 years, so she knows a thing or two about how kids work through problems. Was I wrong to let Jax stick with the tiny $12 whiteboard he got for his 8th grade birthday? Is it actually unsuitable for high school, like she said?
I started paying closer attention to how Jax uses that whiteboard over the next few weeks, to see what my mom was seeing. I’d always just assumed it was a good fit: before he got it, he wasted half a notebook a week working through practice problems, crumpling up entire pages when he messed up a negative sign or mixed up a chemistry bond. With the whiteboard, he can erase in two seconds and start over, no waste, no fuss. But I get why my mom thought it was too small. High school work is more complex, more steps, more material to juggle. It makes sense to assume you need more space to handle that.
What I found, though, was that Jax doesn’t use his whiteboard the way my mom used whiteboards in her classroom. She’s used to writing out full lessons for 30 kids to see from the back of the room, so big space is non-negotiable. Jax uses his for one thing at a time. He keeps his textbook open to the problem set, his lined notebook next to the whiteboard for writing down final correct answers to turn in, and the whiteboard just for working through the problem. He’ll scribble out one approach, erase it when it doesn’t work, try another, check his steps, then copy the finished solution into his notebook. By the time he’s done with that problem, he erases it to make room for the next. He never once runs out of space, because he only needs space for one problem at a time.
A couple weeks later, my mom came over to watch Jax do his homework after Sunday dinner, and she saw this for herself. She also heard us talking about Jax’s friend Lila, who has a 4×3 foot whiteboard nailed to her bedroom wall for high school. Lila swears by it: she maps out entire biology cell pathways on it, leaves her AP US History timelines up for a week to review before tests, and keeps multiple essay outlines visible at once when she’s working on college application drafts. Jax tried it when he studied at Lila’s house a few months back, and said all that empty space made him anxious. He kept wanting to fill it with random scribbles, and he couldn’t focus on the one problem he was working on.
That’s when it clicked: there’s no universal answer to whether a whiteboard is suitable for high school. It all depends on how the student uses it, not the size or the price tag. If you’re a parent wondering the same thing my mom was, there are a few quick, concrete things to check before you run out to buy an expensive new wall-sized whiteboard.
First, ask your teen how they use their current whiteboard. If they work through one problem or task at a time, and erase as they go, a small portable is almost always fine. If they need to keep multiple ideas or steps visible at the same time to connect them, then extra space will help. Second, check if the whiteboard you have actually works, regardless of size. If it’s so stained that marks don’t erase fully, that’s a problem. But most of the time, a $2 magic eraser will get rid of old stains, and a $5 easel stand will fix a wobbly whiteboard that slips around on the desk. You don’t need to replace it for those small issues. Third, if you’re still not sure, test before you upgrade. Borrow a larger whiteboard from a friend or family member for a week, instead of dropping $60 on a new one that ends up leaning against your closet door collecting dust.
My mom ended up agreeing with this, after watching Jax work. She still says that if he starts struggling with big multi-step problems that require more space, we should revisit it, which makes sense. It’s not a hard rule one way or the other.
Last week, Jax asked me to order him a second small whiteboard, just like his current one, to keep at my mom’s house for when he stays there overnight for long weekends. He says one’s enough for most days, but if he’s cramming for two midterms at once, it’s nice to have one for algebra and one for biology, so he doesn’t have to erase one to work on the other. We haven’t bought a big wall whiteboard yet, and I don’t think we will unless Jax asks for one. Right now, his tiny stained whiteboard works for him, and that’s all that matters.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is a whiteboard unsuitable for high school