Why most teen financial literacy doesn’t stick (I built a new course and need honest testers)
Last month, my 16-year-old nephew slid his first summer job pay stub across my kitchen table, half a peanut butter cookie sticking to the corner. “I worked 80 hours at $15 an hour,” he said. “Where did $182 of it go?” I pointed to the lines marked FICA and state income tax, and he blinked. He’d just finished the mandatory personal finance unit at his high school, and no one had mentioned either of those. That checks out, I thought. I’ve taught 10th grade for eight years, and I’ve watched the same play out hundreds of times.
Last semester, I did an informal poll on a slow Monday. How many of you can explain what a credit score is? Three hands out of 27 went up. How many of you think you’ll get a credit card within a year of graduating high school? Fourteen hands. A few weeks later, I talked to a mom whose 19-year-old had fallen for one of those “get rich quick” Instagram side hustles, lost $300 she’d saved for textbooks. No one had ever taught him how to spot a fake employment scam. That’s when I decided I’d had enough. I started pulling together my own course on weekends, between grading papers and driving my own kid to soccer practice.
Most of the financial literacy material I’ve seen for teens falls into two unhelpful buckets. The first is outdated: it spends three days teaching how to balance a checkbook, which almost no one under 30 does, and skips over everything teens actually need to know right now. The second is preachy: it’s all about “cut out your daily latte” to save for retirement, which is ridiculous when most teens are working irregular part-time hours just to save for a car or a senior trip. They don’t have daily lattes to cut.
I built this course to be 10-minute modules, because teens don’t have an hour a day to sit through a lecture. Each one covers something they’ll actually deal with in the next five years: how to read a pay stub, how a 401k match works and why you should always take the full match even if you’re only making minimum wage, how to spot a fake side hustle, how to split bills with roommates without ruining a friendship, how a late credit card payment can mess with your first apartment application, how to budget when your work hours change every week. I even added one on how to negotiate your first salary after college, something most courses never touch.
I tested the first three modules with three local teens a few weeks back. One of them, a 17-year-old who works at a downtown coffee shop, told me the pay stub module finally made taxes make sense, but I’d missed something important: what happens when you’re an authorized user on your parents’ credit card, and how that can help or hurt your own score. That’s exactly the kind of gap I couldn’t see on my own, because I built it from my perspective as a teacher and parent. I need people who actually use it to tell me what’s wrong, what’s missing, what’s boring enough to skip halfway through.
This whole project got me thinking about what small things parents can do right now, even before this course is finalized, to help their kids. You don’t need a finance degree to do this. Next time your teen brings home their first paycheck, don’t just say “that’s just taxes” and move on. Spend five minutes going through each line: explain what FICA covers, what state income tax pays for, why the numbers add up the way they do. Next time you’re paying your monthly bills, invite your teen to sit with you for 10 minutes. Show them how much your rent or mortgage is, how much electricity and internet cost. Most teens have no idea how much regular life costs, because we never talk about money in front of them. I’ve had students tell me they thought a $60k starting salary after college would mean they could buy a new car and rent a nice apartment in a major city, because they’d never seen a real household budget. Those 10-minute conversations stick way more than any worksheet a teacher hands out in class.
That’s why I’m looking for honest testers right now. The course is free, and it’s all online, so you can go through it at your own pace. I’m looking for parents of teens 13 to 18, high school teachers who want to use it as a supplement in their classroom, even teens themselves who want to work through it and tell me what they think. I don’t need glowing reviews. I need you to tell me if a module is too confusing, if a critical topic is missing, if an activity is a waste of time. The only thing I ask in return is that you fill out a 10-question feedback form when you’re done, that’s it.
I know this isn’t going to fix the whole problem. Most schools don’t have the time or budget to teach good financial literacy, and most parents don’t feel confident talking about money with their kids anyway. I don’t have all the answers, and I know this course will have holes. That’s the point of testing it. If you’re interested, or you know someone who might be, just leave a comment below. We’ll tweak it as we go, and see what works.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why most teen financial literacy doesn’t stick (I built a new course and need honest testers)