Why Some Adults Wish They Were Held Back or Placed in Special Ed As Kids
Last month, I was grabbing a second cheeseburger at my 8-year-old’s end-of-school BBQ when my old friend Lila, who’s been a 3rd grade special education teacher for 18 years, leaned in against the picnic table and said something I haven’t stopped thinking about. “I ran into a guy from my graduating class at a reunion last month. He’s 42, runs his own landscaping business, seems totally happy. But he pulled me aside and said he still wishes someone had held him back in 2nd grade, or put him in special ed, instead of pushing him through every year.”
I didn’t say anything at the time, but I immediately thought of my cousin Jake, who’s 36 and lives two towns over. Jake was the youngest kid in his grade, born a week before the state cutoff for kindergarten, so my grandparents pushed to get him in early instead of waiting a year. He was always small, always quiet, and by 2nd grade, his teacher said he was half a grade behind in reading and writing, and suggested an evaluation for learning support. My aunt and uncle said no. They didn’t want Jake labeled, didn’t want him to feel stupid, didn’t want him to be the kid who got held back. They told the school he just needed to apply himself more, that he was lazy, not learning disabled.
I remember going to family holidays when we were kids, and Jake would hide his report card in the junk drawer by the fridge, and avoid talking about school at all. When he was 16, he dropped out halfway through 11th grade, got his GED a year later, and went into construction with his uncle. He’s great at what he does – he built the back deck on my house three years ago, and it’s still perfectly level, no squeaks anywhere. But last Christmas, we were sitting on that deck drinking beer after dinner, and he said the exact same thing that guy said to Lila. “I spent my whole childhood thinking I was dumb, because I could never keep up with the other kids. I wish someone had just held me back a year, or given me that extra help, instead of acting like I was just being bad. I still can’t write a full paragraph without second-guessing every word, because no one ever took the time to teach me properly when I was little.”
Lila told me that this isn’t a rare thing. She gets at least one email or comment a month from an adult reaching out, saying they wish their parents or school had done this for them. The biggest pushback she gets these days isn’t from school districts, it’s from parents. Parents hate the idea of holding a kid back or labeling them with a learning difference. They worry about self-esteem, they worry about bullying, they worry what other parents will say. But what no one talks about enough is that the damage from always being behind, always feeling like you’re not good enough, lasts way longer than any temporary awkwardness of being a year older than your classmates.
Last year, Lila had a 1st grade student who was borderline for retention. His mom fought it for three months, kept saying it would ruin his confidence. Finally, she agreed, and that year he went from reading at a mid-kindergarten level to the top of his new 1st grade class by spring. He started bringing his favorite comic books in to read to the class during free time. His mom told Lila later that she’d worried for nothing – the other kids never even mentioned him being older, and he hasn’t had a stomach ache from school anxiety since the first month of that year.
If you’re a parent sitting in a conference room right now, getting this suggestion from your kid’s teacher, here’s what I’ve learned from all this. First, don’t let your own fear of stigma drive your decision. It’s okay to ask the teacher to walk you through three specific, small things your kid is struggling with right now that they can’t keep up with. Not “they’re bad at math” – things like “they can’t sound out three-syllable words independently, which means they can’t keep up with the reading assignments for 3rd grade” or “they need one-on-one support to stay on task during group work, which we can’t provide in the general classroom right now.” That takes it from being a label to being a practical problem to solve.
Second, if you’re talking about holding your kid back, don’t frame it as a punishment to them. Instead of “you’re not ready, you have to do this over,” try saying “you’ll get an extra year to practice the things that feel hard right now, and you’ll be one of the oldest kids in your class next year. That means you can help the other kids when they need it, too.” Lila says framing it that way takes a lot of the shame out of it for kids, and most adjust in a couple of months.
Third, don’t assume that special ed is a dead end or a bad label. These days, it’s just extra support. It might mean your kid gets 20 minutes of one-on-one reading help every day, or extra time on tests, or a quieter space to take tests when they get overwhelmed. That’s not a label that will follow them forever – it’s help they need right now to keep from falling further behind.
Right now, I’m in this position with my own youngest. He’s also a December baby, right on the cutoff, and his kindergarten teacher mentioned last month that if he doesn’t pick up his reading fluency over the summer, holding him back might be the best option next year. I grew up hearing that holding kids back is bad for them, that labeling them is worse than letting them struggle. But after hearing Jake, after hearing what Lila sees every year, I’m not so sure. We’re going to get him evaluated over the summer, and we’re going to talk to him about what feels hard for him at school. There’s no perfect answer, and there’s still a chance we’ll decide to push him through and do extra tutoring at home. But I know for sure that I’d rather deal with a little short-term awkwardness than let him grow up wondering why no one gave him the help he needed when he was 6.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Some Adults Wish They Were Held Back or Placed in Special Ed As Kids