My 5-Year-Old Nervous Flower Girl: What I Learned About Helping Shy Kids Handle Big Moments
The vestibule of the old downtown church smelled like melted candle wax and lemon Pledge on Saturday of my best friend Mia’s wedding, and my 5-year-old daughter Lila was glued to my calf, her flower girl dress tulle scratchy against my bare ankle. Half the glitter I’d dusted on her cheeks was rubbed off on my jeans, and she was breathing so hard I could feel the puffs through the fabric. The bridesmaids adjusted their bouquets down the hall, the organ started the first processional chord, and Mia poked her head out of the bride’s room, smiling soft. “It’s okay if she sits this out,” she mouthed. I nodded, then knelt down to Lila’s level.
I knew this wasn’t out of the blue. Lila’s been the kid who hides behind my leg at preschool drop-off for three years, who turns her face into my shoulder when the cashier says hello, who once left a birthday party crying because everyone sang happy birthday to her. When Mia asked her to be flower girl three months earlier, Lila had nodded so hard her pigtails flew, chattering about pink petals and a sparkly dress. I’d warned Mia she might change her mind, but I’d still prepped for weeks, showing her photos of the church, walking her through what the walk would look like, practicing throwing petals in our backyard. I still got it wrong on the day. “My tummy hurts,” Lila mumbled into my shoulder. “Everyone is gonna look at me.”
I used to do the thing most of us do: I’d say “there’s nothing to be scared of” or “come on, you promised” or “everyone is going to think you’re so cute.” That never worked. It just made her squeeze tighter. This time, I didn’t do that. I said, “You’re right, a whole room full of people looking at you sounds really scary. What part is the scariest?” She pulled back a little, eyes shiny, and said “standing up at the front by the altar where everyone can see me. And walking all by myself.”
I didn’t tell her she had to do it either way. I just offered a new plan. “What if I hold your hand for the first half of the walk? You can throw petals the whole time, just like we practiced. When we get to the middle, you can go the rest by yourself if you want, and when you get to the front, you don’t have to stand at the altar. You can go sit with Grandma in the front row, and eat the mint she has in her purse. Does that sound better?” She thought for 10 whole seconds, then nodded.
We slipped into line after the bridesmaids, and when the ushers held the big doors open, I laced my fingers through hers. The first five steps, she was squeezing my hand so hard my knuckles went white. Then she remembered the petals, and she reached in her little basket and tossed a handful. Someone in the audience aww-ed, and she threw another. By the time we got to the middle of the aisle, she let go of my hand. She walked the rest of the way by herself, throwing petals the whole time, grinning so wide her dimples showed. When she got to the front, she veered straight to Grandma’s row, climbed into her lap, and didn’t stand at the altar once. No one minded. When Mia walked down the aisle a minute later, she winked at Lila, and Lila waved back.
Afterward, when everyone was telling me how cute she was, I started thinking about how much unhelpful guidance I’ve absorbed about shy kids. I’ve heard so many times that if you let them avoid things, they’ll never get over being shy. That you have to push them out of their comfort zone to help them grow. But what I’ve found over the last few years is that pushing just makes them stop trying new things altogether. When I force Lila to say hello to a stranger, she just learns that being with me means she’ll be forced into things she hates, instead of trusting that I’ll keep her safe.
What works, that I’ve started doing consistently, is small, adjustable plans. It doesn’t take any extra time, just a little conversation before we go somewhere new. Before any big event – a birthday party, a school performance, a family dinner with people she doesn’t see often – I talk through three possible plans with her, not just the one everyone expects. For the wedding, the original full plan was plan A, the adjusted one we used was plan B, and plan C was we leave and wait in the car together if it was still too much. That’s it. No big deal, no pressure. If she knows she has an out that doesn’t involve letting anyone down, she’s way more likely to try something that scares her.
Another small shift I made is I don’t prioritize other people’s comfort over hers anymore. I used to apologize for her hiding, or force her to hug a relative to be polite, because I didn’t want other people to think I’m a bad parent or she’s rude. Now I just say “she’s a little shy right now, she’ll say hello later” and that’s that. For the wedding, I didn’t care that the photographer didn’t get that perfect shot of her standing alone at the front of the church. I cared that she tried something that scared her, on her own terms.
That night, she fell asleep in the car on the way home, her flower basket still full of leftover petals in her lap, glitter tangled in her hair. She told everyone at preschool on Monday that she was a flower girl, and she threw leftover petals for all her friends at show and tell. She still won’t order her own chicken nuggets at McDonald’s. She still hid in the wings during her preschool fall show last month instead of sitting on stage with the other kids, and that’s okay – we watched from the side together, and she clapped for all her friends. I’m proud of her, not because she did what was expected of a flower girl, but because she figured out what she could handle, and went for it. We’re still figuring it out, one adjusted plan at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My 5-Year-Old Nervous Flower Girl: What I Learned About Helping Shy Kids Handle Big Moments