When your kid can’t post online: Why groups require 10-day-old accounts and 100 positive karma
Last Tuesday, I was folding soccer cleat socks and sorting uniform laundry at the kitchen table when my 14-year-old Lila huffed so loud her bangs flew up off her forehead. She slammed her phone down hard enough to rattle the half-empty juice box next to my arm. “Stupid rule,” she said. “What stupid rule?” I asked, not looking up because I had three socks that didn’t have matches. “This fan group I want to post my art in won’t let me. It says in order to post your account must be older than 10 days and have 100 positive karma. I made the account yesterday! I’ve been working on this drawing for a week, what am I supposed to do now?”
Lila’s been obsessed with that high fantasy show none of her friends at school watch, so she’d been bugging me for a week to let her join the Reddit fan group to share her work. I’d said yes, as long as she didn’t share her full name or any photos of herself, so this was her first big online community letdown. I’d never heard of this specific rule before, so I pulled my chair over to look at her screen. Sure enough, that line was right there in plain grey text under the block on her post.
My first instinct was to offer a quick fix: just make a new account and backdate the birthday, right? But I stopped. Why would a group full of mostly teens put that rule in place if it was just to be annoying? I texted my cousin Mia, who mods three different fan groups for teen anime fans and has been doing it for five years. She wrote back right away, and what she said changed how I think about these random-seeming online rules.
First, it’s not gatekeeping, it’s basic safety and spam control. People who make fake accounts to drop malware links, harass other kids, or steal art don’t wait 10 days to build up karma. They just make a new account every time they get banned. This one rule weeds out 90% of that bad behavior before it ever hits the group feed. Second, it slows new people down enough that they learn how communities actually work. A lot of kids join, post their stuff right away, and then leave when they don’t get 100 likes in an hour. If you have to hang around for 10 days and build up karma, you figure out what the group cares about, you get to know people, and you’re more likely to stick around and contribute positively.
I went back to Lila and didn’t offer to hack the system for her. I just repeated what Mia had said, and asked, “What do you think we could do while we wait? She said most people get enough karma just from commenting on other people’s stuff.” Lila rolled her eyes and said that was dumb—she didn’t want to comment on other people’s art, she wanted people to comment on hers. I said, “Remember last month when you went to that first art club meeting at the library? You didn’t haul your whole portfolio out the first day and demand everyone look at it. You just sat and talked to the other girls about their sketchbooks, right? It’s kind of like that.”
She groaned, but that night after homework, she opened the group and started scrolling. I peeked over her shoulder a little later, and she was leaving comments like “I love how you drew her wings, the shading is so good” and “This take on the final battle is way better than what the show did.” By day seven, she already had 87 karma. She was also chatting with another girl her age who also draws fan art of the same main character, swapping tips for Procreate brushes and talking about which plot lines they hated. By the time the 10 days were up, she had 112 karma, enough to post. When she put her drawing up, that girl was the first one to comment and say she loved it, and within a couple of hours she had 40 upvotes. Lila was bouncing off the walls in a way she never is when she posts to her personal Instagram, which only has her school friends on it.
I’ve been thinking about this ever since. A lot of the time, as parents, we see any rule that blocks our kid from what they want as a problem to get around. We hear “you can’t post yet” and our first instinct is to help them bypass it, because we hate seeing them upset. But this simple rule is actually doing a lot of the work we should be doing, but rarely make time for.
It’s a low-effort safety filter that takes work off our plates. We spend so much time worrying about strangers online, and this rule keeps out the majority of people who don’t have good intentions, because they won’t put in the work of waiting and participating. It also teaches a lesson most kids don’t learn growing up with algorithm-driven social media: online communities aren’t there to give you attention for free. You have to participate first. You have to give something before you get something. That’s a lesson I’ve tried to teach Lila with offline groups too—you can’t just join the soccer team and expect to be starting striker without showing up to practice and passing to your teammates—but it never stuck as hard as it did when she experienced it herself online.
For other parents who run into this same rule with their kid, the steps are simple and low-friction. First, don’t help them bypass the rule. Don’t let them use your account, don’t help them lie about the account creation date. Let them wait. Second, walk them through specific small actions to build karma: leave one genuine comment on a post you like every day, ask one question in a discussion thread, share something small that doesn’t take much work before you post your big project. Third, ask them why they think the rule exists, instead of just explaining it to them. Most kids will figure out the troll and spam point pretty quickly on their own, which makes it easier for them to accept the wait.
Last week, Lila tried to join another fan group for the new Zelda game, and the same rule popped up. She didn’t huff and slam her phone this time. She just opened the feed, started scrolling, and left three comments before she even started her homework. She still complains that it’s annoying some days. I still worry about her online, there’s no rule that can stop every bad thing from happening. But it’s nice to see a community make a simple, low-stakes rule that actually works, both for keeping people safe and teaching a quiet lesson I’ve been fumbling to teach for years. It’s not a perfect system, but for right now, it’s working better than anything I’ve come up with on my own.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When your kid can’t post online: Why groups require 10-day-old accounts and 100 positive karma