What To Do When A Student Privately Asks For School Supplies: A Teacher’s Experience
Last Friday of the first week of 7th grade, I was erasing the welcome sign off my whiteboard and shoving leftover copier paper into my desk when I noticed Mia still lingering by my desk. She’d been quiet all week, wore a faded US Women’s Soccer hoodie every day, never brought a snack from home, always took the free apple at lunch. She kicked a loose floor tile back and forth for a full minute before sliding a crumpled, half-torn sheet of notebook paper onto my desk and ducked her head. I unfolded it, and that’s the line I still remember: I feel embarrassed to ask this but I need school supplies for this year, I have 5 siblings and money is tight. Anything would help, all I need is the necessities.
I didn’t know what to say for a split second. Early in my career, I would’ve panicked, maybe said something loud and sympathetic that would’ve made every kid still waiting for pickup turn and look, which is the last thing a 12-year-old wants. Instead I just folded the note back up, slipped it into the side drawer of my desk, and said “Thanks for telling me. I’ll have everything ready for you before homeroom tomorrow. Your ride’s out front, right? Want a granola bar while you wait?” She nodded so fast her hair fell in her face, took the bar and left.
Later that afternoon, I checked in with our school counselor, who confirmed what I’d guessed. Mia’s mom works two shifts at the diners on the main highway, her dad moved out last year and doesn’t send child support, there are six kids total ranging from 4 to 16, they live in a three-bedroom apartment that eats up most of her mom’s paycheck. School supplies were just something that didn’t fit in the budget that month. She’d tried to reuse old notebooks with the first pages torn out, but three of her core classes required new composition notebooks for graded assignments, and she didn’t have any.
A lot of new teachers and parents ask me how to handle these moments, because it feels awkward, right? You don’t want to embarrass the kid, but you also don’t want to ignore their need. I’ve learned over 12 years in the classroom that the biggest mistake people make is turning a private request into a public event. Early on, I participated in a district-wide school supply drive that put every kid receiving supplies on a list posted by the front office. One 8th grader I had stopped coming to school for three days because his name was on that list, and he never asked me for anything again after that. Shame sticks with kids a lot longer than a free notebook does.
What I do now is small, low-effort, and doesn’t require a big social media post or a school assembly. I keep a locked drawer at the back of my closet full of extra supplies: unopened notebooks left over from bulk orders, half-packs of pencils that kids leave in the classroom at the end of the year, extra glue sticks and rulers that parents donate at back-to-school night. I put together a plain canvas bag for Mia that night: three composition notebooks, a pack of 12 pencils, a small eraser, a ruler, and a blue pen she’d mentioned liking when we did the first day get-to-know-you activity. The next morning, I caught her between first and second period, when the hallway was almost empty, and handed her the bag. I just said “These were all extra from last year, no one’s using them. If you run out of anything, just let me know, I’ve got more.” That’s it. No big speech, no photo, no asking her to thank me in front of anyone.
For other teachers, there are three concrete things you can do that take almost no extra work. First, always respond casually to a request like this. If you gasp or say “oh you poor thing” that just makes the kid feel more ashamed. Treat it like they asked you for a tissue, no big deal. Second, always deliver supplies one on one, when no other kids are around. If you can’t do it in person, leave it in their locker or homeroom cubby with no note that calls out why it’s there. Third, if you don’t have extra supplies, most schools have a small private fund from the PTA or counselor that you can access without sharing the kid’s name broadly. You don’t have to post their request on your local parent Facebook group to get help.
For parents, if your kid comes home and says a classmate mentioned needing supplies, don’t make your kid hand it over in front of the whole class. Just send it in to the teacher, and ask the teacher to pass it along privately. If you want to help generally, buy an extra pack of pencils or a couple of notebooks when you’re buying supplies for your own kid, and drop them off at the school office. They’ll almost always get used by someone who needs them, no public recognition required.
It’s been three months since Mia handed me that note. She still doesn’t talk a lot in class, but she raises her hand sometimes now, and she turned in a full 3-page writing assignment last month instead of a half sheet of torn paper like she did the first week. A month ago, she left a stick of mint gum with a tiny drawing of a cat taped to my desk after class, that’s all it said. There are three other kids who’ve quietly asked me for supplies this semester, all with different stories, none of them wanted anyone else to know. I just keep adding to that locked drawer, and hand off the bags when no one’s looking.
I know this doesn’t fix the bigger problem of families choosing between rent and school supplies, or paying for groceries and notebooks. But it keeps a kid from being embarrassed to ask for what they need, and that’s the first small thing that matters right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What To Do When A Student Privately Asks For School Supplies: A Teacher’s Experience