Weird Things That Calm My Kid Down (And Why They Actually Work)
Last October, on a rainy Saturday, I stood in the cereal aisle of our local grocery store watching my four-year-old son Leo have a full-blown meltdown. He’d spotted the box of Lego cereal with the tiny promotional toy inside, I’d said no (we already had three unopened cereal boxes at home), and he’d dropped straight to the linoleum, screaming so hard his face turned purple and he snort-sobbed between yells. I ran through my entire go-to list of calm-down tricks first: I knelt down to his level and validated his feelings (“I know that toy is so cool, it’s really disappointing we can’t get it today”), I offered a trade of a banana and a cookie at the checkout, I promised we’d get the cereal on our next grocery run, I even tried picking him up to hold him, which only made him arch his back and scream louder. A few other shoppers slowed down to glance over, and I could feel that familiar hot flush of embarrassment creep up my neck. I was fumbling in my purse for a tissue, and my hand hit the stack of 3×5 index cards I’d stuffed in there for the PTA meeting I had right after shopping. Some were blank, some had random scribbles from when Leo had played with them a few days earlier. On a total whim, I sat down on the floor next to him (I stopped caring about judgment at that point) and started sorting them into three piles: all blank, all with one scribble, all with more than one scribble. I didn’t even prompt him to join. Mid-sob, he stopped, blinked at me, crawled over, and shoved a scribbled card into the correct pile. Five minutes later, he was totally calm, we agreed we’d come back for the Lego cereal next week, and we finished our shopping like nothing had happened. I couldn’t believe it. Sorting index cards isn’t a trick I’d ever read about in a parenting blog. It was just the first thing I had on hand.
This isn’t the only weird thing that’s worked for us. A couple of months after that grocery run, Leo had a huge meltdown before bed after his cousin accidentally broke the tail off his favorite plastic T-Rex. We tried everything: we hugged him, we gave him extra ice cream, we glued the tail back on right there in the kitchen, nothing worked. He just kept sobbing, running circles around the living room, refusing to sit still or talk about it. Then he spotted the full basket of clean folded laundry I’d left on the coffee table to put away later, specifically the pile of socks. He demanded to line every single sock up along the living room baseboard, sorted by the width of the stripe on the cuff. I was exhausted, I had a load of dishes in the sink, I just let him do it. Eighteen socks later, he yawned, dropped the last one into place, and asked me to tuck him into bed. Again, totally weird, not in any parenting manual I’ve ever owned.
I’ve seen the same pattern play out at the preschool where I sub part-time, too. Last semester, there was a five-year-old named Mia who struggled with transitions after recess. Every single day, coming inside from playing to sit down for art would set off a screaming meltdown, and she’d hide in the supply closet for 20 minutes. We tried everything the behavior guide suggested: visual transition warnings, visual schedules, letting her pick her art supplies first before anyone else, nothing stuck. One day I was getting set up for class, and she crept out of the closet, grabbed the big heavy metal stapler off my desk, and just started opening and closing it, click click click, over and over. Two minutes later, she put it down, walked straight to the art table, and started coloring. Now that’s just our routine: she gets two minutes of stapler clicking before art starts, and we haven’t had a transition meltdown since.
I used to feel guilty that none of the popular calm-down tricks worked for Leo. I’d read all the posts about deep breathing, calm down jars, and sensory bins, and I’d wonder what I was doing wrong that my kid wouldn’t use any of it. Then I talked to the school occupational therapist about it a while back, and she put it simply: when a kid is in full meltdown mode, the part of their brain that handles breathing, counting, and intentional regulation is already offline. They can’t access those skills, no matter how many times you’ve practiced them. What they need is something small, repetitive, and tactile that lets their nervous system reset on its own, without forcing them to “be good” or “calm down” right now.
That’s the secret to all these weird tricks, right? None of them demand anything from the kid. They don’t require them to pull themselves together before they’re ready. They just give their hands something to do, and give them a tiny bit of control when everything around them feels out of whack, which is 9 times out of 10 what caused the meltdown in the first place.
I started keeping a tiny low-mess calm down bag in my purse and my car now, based on this. It has a roll of quarters to sort, a pack of post-its to stack, a few plastic straws to cut into small pieces with kid safety scissors, and that’s it. It cost me less than four dollars to put together, and it’s gotten me through three more grocery store meltdowns since that first one.
It’s not perfect. Last week, Leo had a meltdown at the park when it was time to leave, and even sorting all the different sized rocks by the playground didn’t work. I ended up carrying him screaming to the car, and he cried all the way home. Some days nothing works, and that’s just how it goes. I still get the occasional side-eye from other parents when I let Leo fold receipt tape at a restaurant while he works through a tantrum. But I don’t care anymore. There’s no “right” way to calm a kid down. If the weird thing works, it’s not a mistake. It’s just what your kid needs. So far, the weirdest things have worked the best for us.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Weird Things That Calm My Kid Down (And Why They Actually Work)