My Teen Says “My Whole Econs Class Hates Me”: How To Help People-Pleasing Teens At School
Last Tuesday, I was folding fitted sheets at the kitchen table, leftover mac and cheese still congealing in the pot on the stove, when my 16-year-old daughter Mia dropped her backpack by the door—its side bulging with a dog-eared econs textbook and a crumpled pack of mint gum—and said, “I think my whole econs class hates me. I just don’t want anyone to be mad at me. I don’t know what to do.”
She’d had a group project for the class, worth 30% of their semester grade. Mia was in charge of compiling everyone’s work into the final slideshow, and she found a clear mistake in the unemployment data the two other girls in her group had pulled. Scared the whole team would get a C for the error, she mentioned it to their teacher after class, asked if they could fix it before the presentation. She thought everyone would thank her for catching it. Instead, the two girls didn’t sit with her at lunch the next day, and when they walked into class together they laughed right as Mia turned around. Now she’s convinced all 28 kids in the class think she’s a snitch, that everyone is mad at her.
Mia’s always been this way. When she was 10, she gave her front-row concert ticket to a girl who said she’d never seen her favorite band live, even though Mia had saved up allowance for six months to buy it. She’d rather re-do an entire lab report than tell a lazy lab partner they didn’t do their share. I used to think it was just her being kind, but this was the first time I saw it break her. She sat picking at her chipped mint-green nail polish for 10 minutes before she could even finish the story, her voice wobbly the whole time.
My first instinct was to jump in. I almost said, “They don’t hate you, you did nothing wrong,” or “Let me email the teacher right now to sort this out.” But I stopped myself. I’d seen enough of these moments to know that when a kid is carrying this much fear of other people being upset, telling them their feelings are overblown just makes them shut down. They stop telling you when things are bad, because they think you’ll just call them silly. So instead, I pushed the laundry basket off the empty chair and said, “Start from when you got to school this morning. Tell me every single thing that happened, even the parts that don’t matter.”
She talked for 22 minutes—I checked the clock because I was waiting for a laundry cycle to finish. She ranted about how the teacher always calls on her when she doesn’t raise her hand, how one of the girls chews gum so loud it makes it hard to focus, how she’d stayed up until 11 the night before re-checking all the numbers anyway. I just nodded, folded more socks, didn’t interrupt once. By the end, she’d cried a little, wiped her nose on a paper towel I handed her, and was still stuck on the same thought: everyone hates her.
I asked her one simple question, the one I’ve started asking any time this spiral starts now. “How many people in that class have actually said they’re mad at you out loud?” She counted on her fingers. Two. Just the two girls in her group. The other 26? She hadn’t heard a single word from any of them. She just assumed that because two people weren’t talking to her, everyone else knew, everyone else agreed, everyone else was mad. That’s the thing with people-pleasing kids, isn’t it? Their brains turn one small awkward conflict into a whole room full of people hating them, because they’re so used to carrying everyone else’s moods as their own responsibility.
I grabbed a scrap of wrapping paper from the junk drawer and a pen, and said let’s make two lists. One of all the things you can actually change or control here, and one of all the things you can’t. She wrote: Can control: Apologize for upsetting them, say why I did what I did, switch groups for the next project, sit by the door if that makes it less awkward. Can’t control: Whether they forgive me, whether other people talk about me, whether they like me after this. Looking at that list, she said, “I didn’t realize how much of this I can’t actually do anything about.” That’s the whole point, I told her. You don’t have to fix everyone’s bad mood.
We practiced what she wanted to say to the two girls, because she was too nervous to just walk up to them cold. She didn’t have to grovel. We landed on a short, simple line that felt true to her: “I didn’t mean to embarrass you guys by saying something to the teacher. I just didn’t want all of us to get a bad grade because of a mistake, that’s all.” She practiced it three times in front of the fridge before she went to bed.
Three days later, she pulled me aside after school and told me she talked to them. One of them said she was just embarrassed that she’d gotten the numbers wrong, that she wasn’t actually mad at Mia, and they sat together at lunch that day. The other one still hasn’t texted her back, and still doesn’t say hi in the hall. Mia says it’s still awkward some days. She still catches herself scanning the room to see if anyone is looking at her funny. She didn’t transfer out of the class, which she was dead set on doing that first night, and she got a B+ on the project—better than any of them expected.
I think a lot of us see people-pleasing as a good trait, right? We say “oh they’re just such a nice kid” and leave it at that. But it’s exhausting for them, carrying all that extra weight. The things that have worked for us aren’t big, fancy tricks. It’s the small, concrete stuff: don’t dismiss their feelings first, ask that simple question about how many people actually said they’re mad, write the control list down on paper to take the weight out of their head, let them practice what to say instead of pushing them to “just get over it.” You don’t have to fix the whole thing for them. You just have to help them untangle the part that’s their responsibility from the part that isn’t.
Last night, Mia ate two bowls of mac and cheese and rambled about how her econs teacher told her she’s doing really well on the unit quizzes. She didn’t mention the awkwardness, not once. I know it’ll come up again—probably next month, next semester, when she has another group project or another awkward interaction. She’s still learning that it’s okay if some people are mad at her sometimes, that she doesn’t have to fix every bad mood. It’s a slow process, and it’s not going to be fixed in one conversation. For now, though, that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My Teen Says “My Whole Econs Class Hates Me”: How To Help People-Pleasing Teens At School