Should My Teen Go to Boarding School? A Parent’s Guide to Making the Decision
Last month, I found my 14-year-old daughter Lila leaning over our kitchen table at 9:30 pm, a crumpled boarding school brochure spread across her half-finished math homework, a smudge of blue acrylic paint on the corner. She’d come home from her tutor’s that afternoon, where a classmate had been telling her about the art-focused boarding school an hour and a half north of our town. “They have a whole printmaking studio,” she said, pushing the brochure toward me. “And you can eat lunch anywhere you want, no one cares if you sit alone in the library.” I twisted the chipped handle of my coffee mug and didn’t say what I was thinking: I never imagined I’d be having this conversation.
Lila’s had a rough first year at our local public high school. After a group of girls she’d been friends with since middle school started leaving her out of plans, she began eating lunch in the bathroom stall. Her grades dropped from steady Bs to Ds in math, and she quit the art club she’d loved for three years because “all of them are in that group now.” We tried switching her to a different elective, we talked to the principal twice, we got her a weekly therapist in town. Nothing really stuck. So when she brought up boarding school, it wasn’t completely out of the blue. It just felt like a door I’d never considered opening.
Over the next three weeks, we toured three schools, and Lila did an overnight trial stay at the one she liked best. I spent the whole weekend she was gone rearranging the pantry and walking our golden retriever extra loops around the block, replaying my own mom’s comment from a week earlier: “She’s 14, you can’t send your baby away that young.” My sister texted me “Aren’t you worried you’ll miss everything?” And I was. I thought about how she still comes into our room when she has a nightmare, how she asks me to braid her hair before soccer games, how she’ll forget to pack a jacket if I don’t lay it out for her. Would an RA remember that? Would the school nurse call me if she had a fever, or just give her Tylenol and send her back to the dorm?
We didn’t try to decide based on gut feeling alone, because my gut was just swinging between “this will fix everything” and “this will ruin our relationship.” Instead, we sat down together at that same kitchen table and split all our pros and cons into two simple lists: things we can change here at home, and things we can’t. That’s the small trick that helped me stop spinning, honestly. It’s something any family can do in an evening, no fancy planning required.
For us, the things we can’t change at the local school are pretty fixed: the counselor for 9th grade has 320 kids on her caseload, so she can only check in with Lila once every three months. The art department can’t add a printmaking class because of district budget cuts. The girls who left her out are still in the same grade, and they’re not going anywhere for the next three years. That’s not going to shift just because we wish it would.
The things we could change at home are clear too: We could switch her to a local private day school, we could sign her up for weekly printmaking classes at the community arts center, we could move to a different town’s school district entirely. But switching to the local private would mean pulling her out of the soccer team she just started feeling comfortable on, and it’s almost as expensive as boarding school with financial aid, anyway. The community center printmaking classes are only once a week, after school, when she’s already too tired to focus.
Another concrete step that helped more than any long talk was the 3-day trial stay. Most boarding schools will let prospective students stay for a full weekend of classes and dorm life, not just a 1-hour tour. I made Lila write down three small good things and three small bad things every day, no big emotional declarations allowed, just facts. She wrote: “Good: no one bothered me when I worked on my linocut during study hall. Bad: the RA forgot to pass on my phone call from you. Good: the art teacher stays until 8pm every night if you want to work. Bad: the dorm bunk is squeakier than mine. Good: there’s an on-campus therapist I can see every week if I want.” After that, I stopped badgering her with “are you sure you want this?” because the plain facts told me more than any tearful or excited answer would.
I’ve talked to a lot of parents who act like sending your kid to boarding school is either a luxury for wealthy families or a last resort for “troubled” kids, but that’s not what I’ve seen. Most of the kids we met at the school were just kids who didn’t fit the mold of the local school, whether that’s because they need more academic support, or more time for their art, or just a fresh start when something’s gone wrong where they are.
We still don’t know for sure what we’ll do. We sent in our financial aid application last week, and we won’t hear back for another six weeks. Even if we get the aid package we need, Lila could change her mind between now and fall. I still have bad nights where I lie awake worrying that I’m making the wrong choice, either way. If I send her, I’ll miss all the small everyday things, the messy kitchen tables and the last-minute braids before games. If I make her stay, I’ll wonder what would have happened if I’d let her try.
Right now, we’re just taking it one step at a time. We’ve got our two lists, we know what’s fixed and what’s flexible, and we’re not rushing to pick an answer before we have all the information. There’s no perfect choice here, just the one that fits our kid, right now. We’ll see how it goes.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Should My Teen Go to Boarding School