How To Help A Quiet Kid Who Won’t Participate In Class: Lessons From A Teacher In China
The crinkle of a crumpled worksheet stopped me halfway down the third-grade row. Xiao Ming had his head pressed to his desk, arms curled over his notebook like a shield, and when I held out my hand for the day’s homework, he didn’t move. The kid behind him snickered: “He didn’t do it again. He never does anything.”
I’ve been a homeroom teacher at this public suburban school in Chengdu for three years, and Xiao Ming transferred in right after Spring Festival. He lives with his grandma; his parents work 12-hour shifts at an electronics factory in Shenzhen, and come home once a year at most. For the first month, I logged all the usual red flags: he never joined recess games, just sat on the cement wall watching the other kids run around. He never raised his hand. If you called on him by accident, he turned bright red and stared at his shoes until you moved on. Most of his homework was half done, covered in so many eraser holes the paper was almost thin enough to see through.
I did what any teacher would do first: I called his grandma in for a meeting. She showed up 20 minutes early, carrying a crumpled plastic bag of dried bamboo shoots she’d grown herself, kept bowing and apologizing, and admitted she can’t read a single character of the textbook. She can’t even help him with his name in Mandarin, she said—they only speak Sichuan dialect at home. I texted his dad a week later, and he replied two days afterward: We can’t take time off work to come. Please just do your best with him, we can’t do much from here.
I felt stuck. Like a lot of teachers, I started to default to the easy labels: unmotivated, slow learner, let down by his family. That all changed one rainy afternoon in April. I stayed late to grade spelling quizzes, and glanced out the window to see Xiao Ming huddled under the school gate eave, waiting for grandma. She sells vegetables at the morning market, and sometimes runs late when a big order comes in. I waved him in to wait out the rain, gave him an orange lollipop I kept in my desk for upset kids, and went back to grading. He sat on the chair by the door, twisting the hem of his worn blue school uniform, and I noticed him scribbling on the back of an old math worksheet.
I leaned over to see what he was doing, and stopped. It was a whole page of dinosaurs, each labeled with their names in wobbly pencil. The T-Rex had tiny individual scales drawn on its belly, and the triceratops had little wrinkles around its horns. “That’s the most detailed T-Rex I’ve ever seen,” I said. “You got all the spikes on his tail right.” He looked up at me—that was the first time he’d made eye contact with me in two months—and nodded, just a little, but didn’t look away.
That’s when I stopped looking at what he wasn’t doing, and started looking at what he was. His old village school didn’t start teaching pinyin until second grade; our city school starts in kindergarten. He’s two years behind on basic reading, can’t even sound out most test questions, and he’s too embarrassed to ask for help after getting laughed at a few times for mixing up sounds. He’s not lazy or dumb. He’s just stuck, and he’s learned that shutting down is easier than being teased for getting it wrong.
I tried a few small changes that any teacher or parent can copy, none of which took extra time or money. First, I stopped calling on him in front of the whole class. Instead, when we go over reading questions, I write one easy, basic question on a sticky note and pass it to his desk. If he writes the answer back, I just give him a thumbs up and keep going—no big public praise that would just make him hide. If he doesn’t answer, I just take the sticky note and move on, no shame. Second, I bought him a 10-yuan sketchbook from the stationery shop down the street for his birthday. I told him: as long as you try to finish at least half of your daily work, you can draw the rest of the class time at your desk. Before, any drawing found in class got thrown away, so he just hid his sketching and didn’t do any work at all. Now he hurries through the half he can do to get to drawing, which is more work than he was doing before. Third, I talked to the after-school art club teacher and got him a spot, even though we usually only reserve spots for kids with passing test scores. He goes once a week, and the art teacher says he has a better eye for proportion than most fifth graders.
Even for parents who live far away, like Xiao Ming’s dad, there are small, low-effort changes that help. I told him to stop asking “Did you get good grades? Did you behave?” every weekend video call. Instead, just ask Xiao Ming to show you his latest drawing, and point out one specific thing you like, like “That blue race car has really cool wheels.” He started doing that, and last month Xiao Ming told me his dad is going to frame his latest full-page dinosaur drawing when he comes home for Spring Festival. That’s the first time I ever heard him volunteer a full sentence about his family.
It’s not a perfect story. He still doesn’t raise his hand, he still forgets to turn in homework sometimes, and his Chinese test scores are still well below the class average. Some days I wonder if I’m doing enough, if he’ll ever catch up on the reading he missed to get on grade level. But last week, he passed me a sticky note after class. It didn’t have an answer on it. It just had a drawing of a chubby orange cat, with a tiny heart next to it. I stuck it to the bezel of my work computer, and it’s still there. Helping a kid like this doesn’t mean fixing everything all at once. It just means meeting them where they are, one small sticky note at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How To Help A Quiet Kid Who Won’t Participate In Class: Lessons From A Teacher In China