Is My Kid’s Endless Doodling a Waste of Time? A Teacher and Parent’s Take
I was sorting leftover permission slips at my kitchen table last week, after a full day of third grade, when my 8-year-old son Jax dragged over the stack of old lesson plans I’d left out and started doodling on the back of every page. My sister, who’d stopped by for a quick coffee, leaned over his shoulder and raised an eyebrow. “Isn’t that just a waste of time?” she said, quiet enough that Jax didn’t hear. “He should be knocking out his reading log or practicing his multiplication facts instead of drawing the same space ships over and over.”
The question hit me because I get it, honestly. I’ve been a classroom teacher for 12 years, and for most of that time, I thought the same thing. If a kid’s pencil wasn’t moving on the assigned work, their brain wasn’t working. I’d walk by desks during quizzes and tap the margin where a kid had drawn a dragon or a basketball player, and raise my eyebrows until they erased it. If a parent asked me what to do about their kid doodling through homework, I’d say it’s probably a distraction, they should put the doodle paper away.
That changed two months ago, with a student of mine named Mia. We were taking a fractions quiz, and when I got to her desk, her answer sheet was almost blank. I was about to remind her to get to work, until I looked closer at the margin. The word problem on the quiz was about splitting a birthday cake between 8 people, three of whom ate their slice. What fraction was left? Mia had drawn the whole cake, cut into 8 neat slices, colored three of them pink, and written the fraction next to each uncolored slice. She just hadn’t copied the final answer onto the answer line yet.
“I can’t do the numbers until I see the cake,” she said, when I asked her about it. She got the problem right, and explained her reasoning more clearly than half the kids who’d only written the final answer on the line. I walked back to my desk that day and thought about Jax, and all the times I’d rushed him to stop drawing and get back to his homework. Two weeks before that, he’d spent 20 minutes throwing a fit over a decimal word problem about buying soda and chips at a gas station. He threw his pencil, stormed off, came back 10 minutes later and drew 3 soda bottles with $1.25 written on each, added them up one by one as he drew, and figured the answer out before I could even pull up the explanation video I’d saved. I’d just stood there and watched, because I didn’t have the heart to stop him.
What looks like wasted time to most adults is just how kids think. Their brains haven’t learned to separate fine motor movement from problem solving yet. When they’re doodling, their working memory is free to sort through the problem they’re actually stuck on, instead of forcing them to sit still and stare at a blank page. That doesn’t mean there’s never a time to rein it in, of course. I still have days where Jax is supposed to write three paragraphs for his book report, and he spends 45 minutes drawing an elaborate cover for the report instead of writing a single word of the actual text. I don’t ban doodling, I just say, “You can finish the cover once you write those three paragraphs. It’s your reward for getting the work done.” That works almost every time, and it doesn’t turn into a fight.
Over the past few months, I’ve made small changes both in my classroom and at home that work way better than banning doodling, and they take almost no extra effort. First, I tape a 2×3 inch sticky note to the corner of every kid’s desk at school, and we keep a stack of extra by Jax’s homework desk at home. That gives them a dedicated space to doodle while they listen or work through problems, so it doesn’t take over the actual assignment paper, and I don’t have to nag them to stop drawing on the worksheet. Second, if Jax or one of my students is stuck on a word problem, I don’t re-explain the steps again. I just say, “Why don’t you draw what the problem is talking about first?” Nine times out of ten, they get it in a minute, no extra help from me. Third, I started letting kids doodle during read aloud time, which used to be a big no-no for me. Instead of more kids zoning out, I have more kids paying attention, because their hands are busy and their brain can focus on the story.
I still get the question all the time, from other parents and even other teachers: Is this thing a waste of time? It’s not just doodling, either. It’s building Lego for three hours on a Saturday instead of doing the extra math workbook you bought. It’s collecting rocks in the backyard instead of practicing soccer drills. It’s making up silly stories with stuffed animals when they’re supposed to be reading a chapter book. What I’ve learned is that most of the time, the thing that looks like wasted time is just time your kid is spending learning how to think, in their own way. It doesn’t look like the learning we see on worksheets, but that doesn’t mean it’s not useful.
Last weekend I cleaned out Jax’s art bin, and I found that whole stack of lesson plans he doodled on, each page covered in space ships, each ship with a little name written under it, little backstory notes scribbled in the corner. I taped the best one to the fridge, the one with the giant battle cruiser named after our old cat. My sister still teases me about letting him “waste time” drawing instead of checking off more homework boxes. I still have days where I rush him to put the pencil down, where I worry we’re falling behind on the skills he’s supposed to have. Next year he’ll go into fourth grade, and homework will get heavier, and we might have to adjust our routine. But right now, that crumpled drawing on the fridge isn’t a waste of anything. It’s just Jax, learning how to make sense of the world, one space ship at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is My Kid’s Endless Doodling a Waste of Time