Why Your Kid Ignores All Those Expensive Learning Toys (And What To Try Instead)
I was on my knees sorting our overflowing play closet last Saturday, brushing cracker crumbs off the shelves when I hit a hard, unopened box behind the bin of stuffed animals. It was the STEM coding robot I’d ordered three months prior, advertised to teach preschoolers problem-solving. The security tag was still on it. I pulled it out, carried it over to where my 4-year-old sat cross-legged on the rug, busy gluing googly eyes to an empty Cheerios box. “You remember this, right?” I asked. “It’s supposed to be a robot you drive around. It’s really fun, and it helps you learn.” He glanced up long enough to point at his box. “Does this have a seat for my dinosaur?” I set the robot by the donation pile and went back to cleaning.
It’s not the first time this has happened. There’s the $40 wooden counting abacus with the colorful beads that’s been sitting on the shelf for six months. The phonics puzzle that lights up when you match the right letter to the picture, which he’s touched twice. The solar system memory game I bought after seeing a homeschool influencer rave about it, still in its shrink wrap. I used to look at all these unused toys and spiral a little: what am I doing wrong? Why isn’t he interested in learning? Did I waste all that money for nothing?
I vented about it to my friend Lisa, who’s been a preschool teacher for 18 years, when she came over for coffee last month. She leaned against the doorway of the playroom, took a bite of her cookie, and laughed. “Most of those learning toys aren’t made for kids. They’re made for parents. You know how many parents come in and tell me their kid has a whole closet of educational toys they never touch? It’s the number one complaint I hear.”
She pointed to my son, who was now turning his cereal box into a dinosaur garage, moving tiny plastic dinos in and out of the cut-out door. “That box has a hundred different ways to play. He can make it a car, a house, a drum, a garage, whatever he wants that day. Most of these store-bought learning toys only have one way to play. The puzzle only works if you match the right letter to the right spot. The robot only does what the instructions say it’s supposed to do. If his current obsession isn’t letter matching or robot driving that week, it’s useless. Kids don’t play to learn the thing the toy is trying to teach them. They play to follow whatever idea is in their head right now.”
That clicked. I’d spent so long buying toys based on what I wanted him to learn, I forgot that learning follows his interest, not the other way around. I started testing small changes after that, no big closet overhaul or expensive new purchases.
The first thing I did was box up half the unused learning toys and put them in the attic, instead of immediately donating them. Lisa said kids’ interests shift so fast that a toy he ignores at 4 might be his favorite thing at 4 and a half, when he suddenly cares about space or letters. I did that, and three weeks ago, my son pulled out the phonics puzzle himself when he was digging up there for a Halloween costume. He didn’t care about matching the sounds. He just wanted to line up all the pieces with farm animals on them. But he played with it for 20 minutes, which is more than it’s gotten all year. It’s still not his favorite, but it’s not just collecting dust anymore.
The second thing I started doing is hijacking his current obsessions for learning, instead of buying a new toy to teach a skill I picked. A month ago, he was obsessed with garbage trucks—we had to stop and watch the garbage truck pick up our bin every Tuesday, he drew garbage trucks for every art project. Instead of getting out the abacus to practice counting, I cut up 15 little scrap papers to be “trash bags,” wrote numbers 1 through 10 on them, and drew 10 little trash cans on a piece of paper with the matching numbers. I asked if he could help me put the right number of trash bags in each trash can. He did the whole thing, then spent another 15 minutes driving his toy garbage truck around the paper picking them all back up. I didn’t have to spend any money, and he practiced counting without even realizing it, because it was tied to something he already cared about.
The third little rule I made for myself is I don’t buy any toy labeled “educational” unless I can name at least three different ways my kid can play with it. If it only does one thing—only matches, only teaches one skill, only works one way—I put it back. If it’s a set of wooden blocks that can be castles, roads, counting towers, stand-in letters, I’ll grab it. That’s cut my impulse buys in half, and I haven’t added a new unused toy to the closet in two months.
I still slip up sometimes. Last week I bought a kid geology set, because my son has started picking up every rock he sees on walks, and the label said it teaches rock identification and mineral basics. It’s been sitting on the shelf for a week. He’s more interested in the plastic jar the set came in, which he’s using to store his rock collection. That’s fine, honestly. He’s learning that rocks can be collected and sorted, just like the set said, just not the way the manufacturer intended.
I don’t stress about the unused toys anymore. I leave a bin of cardboard boxes, empty jars, and scrap paper by the back door, and 9 times out of 10, that’s what he drags out to play. Some days I think about all the money I spent on those fancy learning toys, and I roll my eyes a little. But I think most of us go through that, right? Learning doesn’t come in a pretty box with an educational label. It comes from whatever holds your kid’s attention that day, even if it’s just an empty Cheerios box.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Your Kid Ignores All Those Expensive Learning Toys (And What To Try Instead)