Why Is My 11 Year Old Girl Withdrawn: What I’m Learning Worrying About My Cousin
Last weekend, I was bent over the backyard cooler grabbing ice for my lemonade when I spotted Lila, my 11-year-old cousin, huddled on the back step thumbing through her phone. A year ago, she’d have been herding all the younger cousins into a game of capture the flag, or dragging me into the woods behind my aunt’s house to hunt for tadpoles. That day, when my aunt called over to ask if she’d join cornhole, she just lifted one shoulder in a shrug and didn’t look up.
It’s been eight months since Lila’s parents finalized their divorce. She splits her time between two houses, switched to a new middle school this fall, and the shift in her has been so gradual it took me a while to name how worried I was. She used to stuff her backpack with a beat-up sketchbook and show me every new drawing of forest animals after dinner. Now, the sketchbook stays buried under her bed, her math grades dropped from A’s to low C’s, and she only speaks more than three words at family dinners if someone asks her about TikTok.
A month ago, I picked her up from school when my aunt got stuck late at work. We stopped at the drive-through for chocolate milkshakes, and I almost fell into the same trap everyone else does: asking her how she liked her new school, if she’d made any friends, if she was okay. Instead, I remembered what our school’s guidance counselor always tells parents at work (I’m a paraeducator at the local middle school, so I hear these conversations all the time) — asking point-blank for big feelings puts pre-teens on the spot. They’ll shut down before you finish the question. So I just said, “Any good viral videos this week I need to see?”
She perked up a little, showed me a 15-second clip of a golden retriever stealing a whole pizza off a counter, and that was that. I didn’t push for more. When we got back to my aunt’s, I remembered the extra sketchbook I had in my trunk, the same kind she used to use, and a pack of the colored pencils she used to rave about that are too expensive for my aunt to buy regularly right now. I didn’t wrap it, didn’t write a note. I just set it on the arm of the couch by her bag when she wasn’t looking.
I think a lot of adults get this wrong when an 11-year-old goes quiet. We think we have to fix it fast, get them to talk about the big change, get them back to the things they loved before everything shifted. I was there at first, texting my aunt every other week asking if she’d gotten Lila into counseling yet, saying we couldn’t just let her withdraw. But what I’ve seen over these past few months is that pre-teens this age don’t want to be a project. When everything in their life is shifting — their body, their friend groups, their whole home routine — the things they used to love can feel vulnerable. Drawing used to be Lila’s thing when her family was all in one house. If she draws a frog now and someone gushes over it and says “see, you still love this! Aren’t you happy you drew it?” that just reminds her how things used to be. It feels like pressure to go back to being the kid she was before the divorce, when she can’t be that kid anymore.
Her art teacher, when we mentioned it to her, made a small change that didn’t cost anything. She added 5 minutes of ungraded, unshared doodle time at the start of every art class. No one has to show their work, no one has to talk about it. Lila doesn’t have to participate if she doesn’t want to, but the teacher told my aunt she’s seen her drawing almost every day now. At home, we changed the questions we ask. No more “how are you feeling?” No more “why don’t you draw anymore?” We ask, “What’s the dumbest trend on TikTok right now?” We ask, “Do you want me to pick up extra fries when I get dinner?” Small, low-stakes questions that don’t require a big emotional answer. I started asking her to show me funny videos when we’re all sitting around after dinner, and sometimes she’ll stay on the couch with me for 15 minutes just scrolling, no talking required.
Last week, I stopped by my aunt’s to drop off some groceries, and I used the bathroom down the hall. Lila’s door was cracked open, and I caught a glimpse of that blank sketchbook I left her propped open on her desk. There was that frog, sitting on a rock, with all the little spots shaded in just how she used to do it. She saw me looking, and she slammed the cover shut, rolled her eyes, and said “It’s stupid.” I didn’t say “oh no it’s not, it’s amazing!” I didn’t give a big speech about how proud I was. I just said “That frog’s spots looked really good. I can never get mine that even.” Then I walked out to get the groceries from my car.
That’s the thing no one tells you when you’re worried about a pre-teen. You don’t get a big, happy ending right away. We still worry. Some weekends she stays in her room the whole time she’s at my aunt’s, doesn’t talk to anyone, doesn’t turn in homework. She still gets defensive if anyone brings up the divorce or her old school. But the frog drawing was there. She sat and watched cat videos with me for 20 minutes last Sunday. Small things, things that don’t fix everything, but things that mean she’s not shutting all of us out completely.
The work right now isn’t getting her back to normal. It’s just leaving the door open, leaving the sketchbook out, asking the low-stakes questions, and waiting. That’s enough, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Is My 11 Year Old Girl Withdrawn: What I’m Learning Worrying About My Cousin